Must Win is all about perception

CouchCoach

Staff member
Messages
41,122
Reaction score
74,970
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Technically, it is only must win if the loss ends any hopes of extending the season into the playoffs and I will not argue that with those riled up by the use of the term because, technically, they are right and I am wrong. However, perceptively, I believe I am right in this case and this is most certainly a must win game for this team for this season.

Consider the fact that while the WFT is 2 games back with 5 to play, they still control their own destiny because it is unusual to have all of these division games, specifically 2 games with the division leader, all packed into the end of the season and the East is the only division with this schedule.

Consider McCarthy has guaranteed a win in the eyes of the media and those of the WFT because Rivera is trying to use that as motivation that McCarthy is insulting his team thinking he can get into their heads. But he goes one step further and stated that McCarthy's message was not for the WFT or the media.

Consider why McCarthy said what he did. Did that seem a little out of character for a blue collar coach not known for flashy making a headline grabbing statement like that? Why do you think he did that? And btw, I agree with Rivera, that wasn't for the media or WFT, it was for his own team because he realizes the importance on this game, it is a must win game to him or why say that? And he sees something that troubles him and needed to take a drastic step to get their attention.

Remember what several of the team leaders said after the DEN game about how practices were that week? Did he get that feeling again with how they responded to the additional time off and prep time for this game. Because he saw this team do the same thing against the Raiders.

You may not feel this is a must win game and they can fix everything by beating the NYG and the WFT at home in the next 2 games but I do not feel that at all and I think there is at least one other person that feels the same as I do, Mike McCarthy. He felt it so strongly he stepped out of character and took the chance of being ridiculed in the media, particularly that local media. The one his owner loves so much.

Ya see, Mike and I agree. This is the most important game in his Cowboys stewardship because it will be a playoff type atmosphere and game and he added to that earlier in the week. It's a road game and they will have to win more games against better opponents if they are to make any noise and there are at least 5 NFC teams better than the WFT. And that includes the Dallas Cowboys.

Mike and I know he has the better team, the better talent, but they haven't always played like that. The better team doesn't always win, the team that plays the best does and if they cannot do that in D.C., what makes you or I or Mike think they can do that in January?

It is simple to me and fits my criteria for must win. Win and they are a contender; lose and they were just a pretender. I believe the season hangs in the balance with this game and that makes it a must win game for both teams.
 
As they say

“there is perception and then there is reality”

The reality is that this is most certainly not a “must win”

But Dallas will win anyway!:flagwave:


Btw, I don't see how beating a below average WFT would say “we are a contender”
 
Last edited:
while i like your write-up, your first line and last are contradictory.

to you its a must win, in reality its not..
a loss isn't a big setback, fans will lose it , sky will be falling, posts will be all negative an depressing, but you are correct a win is more then just a win it nearly locks up the division and shuts down any hope by the rest of the east to catch us with 3 game lead with 4 to go and many H2H games coming..

so while win would be HUGE for many factors, a loss isn't the end of our season by any means.,. it simply makes it tougher..
 
As they say

“there is perception and then there is reality”

The reality is that this is most certainly not a “must win”

But Dallas will win anyway!:flagwave:
I don't think I like the way you put those " around my must win.

"They" also say "perception is the reality of the perceiver" and this is my thread and my perception so it is most certainly a must win and no ".

Seriously, if they cannot win this game, and I do agree with you that they will win, what makes you think they can win the reality "must win" game? With a loss, they will be 2-4 in the last 6 while the WFT will be 5-1 and only 1 game out of 1st.
 
This became a "must win" the second McCarthy guaranteed a win.

If we lose now, not only do we have very little margin for error moving forward, but now the organization must deal with the embarrassment of failure after their doofus coached guaranteed a win.
 
As they say

“there is perception and then there is reality”

The reality is that this is most certainly not a “must win”

But Dallas will win anyway!:flagwave:


Btw, I don't see how beating a below average WFT would say “we are a contender”
This game has been elevated to another level with the comments of the HC's and now Dallas Cowboys benches showing up on their field? Tell Booger and McCarthy this isn't a must win game.

The implications of this game on the season for both teams is most unusual and that below average WFT is on a 4-0 roll.

If winning doesn't make the Cowboys a contender then losing certainly makes them a pretender. And I didn't say true contender as I do not believe they are that right now. I think they would be underdogs to any of the 4 NFC teams I have above them, GB, AZ, TB and LAR. Lose and the WFT goes above them as well.
 
It all depends on your definition of must win. I just know that I don't want our 'Boys only 1 game ahead of a red hot WFT. If WFT were to win this game they would have all the momentum and our 'Boys would likely be questioning there own worth.
So to me it IS a must-win.
 
This game has been elevated to another level with the comments of the HC's and now Dallas Cowboys benches showing up on their field? Tell Booger and McCarthy this isn't a must win game.

The implications of this game on the season for both teams is most unusual and that below average WFT is on a 4-0 roll.

If winning doesn't make the Cowboys a contender then losing certainly makes them a pretender. And I didn't say true contender as I do not believe they are that right now. I think they would be underdogs to any of the 4 NFC teams I have above them, GB, AZ, TB and LAR. Lose and the WFT goes above them as well.
So if they lose and then win the next 4?
The point is, this game tells us how both teams played today, not how good or bad they will play the rest of the way.

You are talking theoretical and hypothetical.

A loss simply makes WFT 1 game behind vs 2 games behind.
All the rest is theoretical mind games
 
EVERY. GAME.IS. MUST. WIN. BABY

So glad I got that out of my system. I blame my grumpiness on the fact it hasn't been above freezing for several days and we're under another winter storm warning.
 
Once again, this thread has proven to me the existence of a special "Must Win "alarm, silent to the rest of us but blaring to the others, and it exists across all Cowboys sites. Wanna start a ruckus on the old DC.com, use the two words that must never be spoken.
 
It is an important game no doubt. But it is not a must win, math or otherwise.

I get it, They are as healthy today as they have been all season, with the exception of Pollard and Zeke. But they are healthy on the offensive and defensive lines, they have all their WRs. They have Dak and the entire secondary basically. There is no excuse to lose this game.

However, a loss is not a problem. How they respond to a loss could be - or it could be what gets them back on track again. If they lose and hang their heads, panic, or give up then a loss means the end of the season for them in all likelihood. But what if a loss is a shock to their system? What if they are embarrassed by a loss and they get as fired up as they did against Atlanta after the Denver game? Then they go out the following week and hammer the Giants. Then win the rematch with Washington in Dallas. Two wins including a win against Washington, in either of their games, means Washington has to win out to win the division. I do not think they can sweep the Eagles. The next 3 weeks are going to tell us a lot about this Cowboys team, starting with the game today.

On paper, Dallas should win this game and it should not be close. But it is also a test of character. We'll see if Dallas is ready to go for a Super Bowl.
 
As they say

“there is perception and then there is reality”

The reality is that this is most certainly not a “must win”

But Dallas will win anyway!:flagwave:


Btw, I don't see how beating a below average WFT would say “we are a contender”


Right, we should win this game going away, then the same ones worried will say "Well that doesnt mean anything WFT sucks". The only thing I'm looking for is to see if the 10 days with more bodies back in practice can get the offense back in rhythm and the Dline pieces that were out for extended period back to 70-80% snaps...we should roll this team, just means we are getting back on track...another 5-6 game streak heading in would tell me we are ready to go after it.
 
So if they lose and then win the next 4?
The point is, this game tells us how both teams played today, not how good or bad they will play the rest of the way.

You are talking theoretical and hypothetical.

A loss simply makes WFT 1 game behind vs 2 games behind.
All the rest is theoretical mind games
Do you really think they will rattle off 4 in a row if they lose this game today? They would be 2-4 over the last 6 and you would expect a 4-0 run? That is exactly why I perceive this game to be must win. I not only do not see a 4-0 run with a loss today but more losses to follow

Also, add the HC's comments, from both sides, and now the Cowboys benches showing up in their stadium? There are people on that team that most assuredly see this as a must win game.

I believe the season is not won in D.C. today but it most certainly will be lost with a loss. None of this has to do with math.
 
Thats why I live in Texas. Sure, we have the occasional moody Texas weather (80 degrees 2 days ago, 30 something today) but it beats the hell out of 4 months of snow and ice.
Actually, I love our winter weather... had to blame my grumpy start to the day on something and I knew better than to blame my wife.

I grew up in Texas and couldn't escape the heat and humidity fast enough.
 
Do you really think they will rattle off 4 in a row if they lose this game today? They would be 2-4 over the last 6 and you would expect a 4-0 run? That is exactly why I perceive this game to be must win. I not only do not see a 4-0 run with a loss today but more losses to follow

Also, add the HC's comments, from both sides, and now the Cowboys benches showing up in their stadium? There are people on that team that most assuredly see this as a must win game.

I believe the season is not won in D.C. today but it most certainly will be lost with a loss. None of this has to do with math.
They did in 2014....almost the same scenario, but worse.

  • 5 games to go, Dallas stumbling, Philly with all the momentum. Dallas "had" to win.
  • But Philly killed us to take the division lead
  • Then Dallas rolled the rest of the way...winning 4 straight in record-setting fashion (including a win over Philly 2 weeks later)
SO similar to this week.

No big deal. We can agree to disagree on this one.
I think we both lie Dallas' chances today anyway
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,011
Messages
14,506,480
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top