Cowboy Brian
@BrianLINY
- Messages
- 15,864
- Reaction score
- 5,053
Hey all - wow it's been a while. Hope everyone and their families are safe and healthy.
Andy Dalton –
The team he wants to play for (as a starter, no doubt) has a QB that is currently holding out (yes voluntarily, but you’ve been QB1 for 3 years. Not appropriate) – with the chance that maybe you somehow get on the field that way (his contract indicates he is banking on some playing time) and perhaps you run with it and never look back
Next years FA QB market looks like a joke – literally it goes Dak Prescott, Phillip Rivers, Jacoby Brissett, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Tyrod Taylor. (plus Cam Newton but will Cam so eagerly take a back-up role - show his commitment to the game and maturity) Philip Rivers could possibly retire, he’d be going on 40.
Andy proved to any team looking at him next year under any circumstances that he is mature type of individual you want as the face of your brand, under what must be some insanely hard emotions as he lost a job he held for a decade without any fuss and nothing but class. Then he took a high-incentive (impossible if Dak is our starter and healthy) deal, albeit in what is the absolute best situation for him - signing with Dallas. Why?
Under situation 1)
Dak re-signs, everyone is happy, healthy – us doing well – Andy Dalton walks out as quite possibly the best QB free agent asset next year by holding a clipboard.
Under situation 2)
Dak re-signs, gets injured – Dalton is not terrible, he’s an average QB, however long-term he's been very stable and consistent, spending 9 years with a terrible brand in terms of his image in the Bengals. In typical circumstances would be one of the biggest names in free agency.
A) He does well. Result: 9 figure contract
B) HE does “better than expected”: Close to 9-figure contract
C) He performs at the level he did in Cinncy which is “well” and looks solid doing it. He’ll get a much bigger deal next year
Under situations ranging from Dak re-signing to Dalton magically stealing the job of QB1)
A) Benefits in every single way possible image and brand wise
B) Gets a chance to play for QB of the team he grew up dreaming being QB of
C) The moment Dalton has a good game on the field, Dak loses all leverage in negotiations
D) Could create such a QB on-team contract pressure that it is whoever signs first gets the job, Jerry holding all the cards
E) But most of all, in any situation, Dalton is Cowboys QB#1 or the biggest name and the top, or near the top, of the QB free agents next year (since the formula will now go either Dak or Dalton enter free agency as they are teammates)
Yet throughout this as a huge fan who has been consumed with work (I can’t believe I joined the board when I was 14). My biggest takeaway is Dak is not behaving like who you want as QB1 of your franchise. Dalton is behaving like who you want as QB1 of your franchise.
All around great singing for the Cowboys and Dalton. Dak may find he overplayed his hand.
(ps - yes it's different eras, but check out this comparison of Romo & Dalton's career stats. Romo from 06 until retirement. Dalton's career so far. I like Dalton. I hope this works out for him, with us, or elsewhere)
Andy Dalton –
- Grew up in Katy, Texas and wants to play in Dallas, Texas (shout out Drake)
- Went to TCU
- Cowboys fan
- Only 32 years old
- Wants to start. This year isn’t the market for him. He is truly better off sitting as a back-up for a year… or playing his cards so well he has guaranteed he will be an absolute winner as elaborated on below….
- Also didn't we want to take him in the draft??
The team he wants to play for (as a starter, no doubt) has a QB that is currently holding out (yes voluntarily, but you’ve been QB1 for 3 years. Not appropriate) – with the chance that maybe you somehow get on the field that way (his contract indicates he is banking on some playing time) and perhaps you run with it and never look back
Next years FA QB market looks like a joke – literally it goes Dak Prescott, Phillip Rivers, Jacoby Brissett, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Tyrod Taylor. (plus Cam Newton but will Cam so eagerly take a back-up role - show his commitment to the game and maturity) Philip Rivers could possibly retire, he’d be going on 40.
Andy proved to any team looking at him next year under any circumstances that he is mature type of individual you want as the face of your brand, under what must be some insanely hard emotions as he lost a job he held for a decade without any fuss and nothing but class. Then he took a high-incentive (impossible if Dak is our starter and healthy) deal, albeit in what is the absolute best situation for him - signing with Dallas. Why?
Under situation 1)
Dak re-signs, everyone is happy, healthy – us doing well – Andy Dalton walks out as quite possibly the best QB free agent asset next year by holding a clipboard.
Under situation 2)
Dak re-signs, gets injured – Dalton is not terrible, he’s an average QB, however long-term he's been very stable and consistent, spending 9 years with a terrible brand in terms of his image in the Bengals. In typical circumstances would be one of the biggest names in free agency.
A) He does well. Result: 9 figure contract
B) HE does “better than expected”: Close to 9-figure contract
C) He performs at the level he did in Cinncy which is “well” and looks solid doing it. He’ll get a much bigger deal next year
Under situations ranging from Dak re-signing to Dalton magically stealing the job of QB1)
A) Benefits in every single way possible image and brand wise
B) Gets a chance to play for QB of the team he grew up dreaming being QB of
C) The moment Dalton has a good game on the field, Dak loses all leverage in negotiations
D) Could create such a QB on-team contract pressure that it is whoever signs first gets the job, Jerry holding all the cards
E) But most of all, in any situation, Dalton is Cowboys QB#1 or the biggest name and the top, or near the top, of the QB free agents next year (since the formula will now go either Dak or Dalton enter free agency as they are teammates)
Yet throughout this as a huge fan who has been consumed with work (I can’t believe I joined the board when I was 14). My biggest takeaway is Dak is not behaving like who you want as QB1 of your franchise. Dalton is behaving like who you want as QB1 of your franchise.
All around great singing for the Cowboys and Dalton. Dak may find he overplayed his hand.
(ps - yes it's different eras, but check out this comparison of Romo & Dalton's career stats. Romo from 06 until retirement. Dalton's career so far. I like Dalton. I hope this works out for him, with us, or elsewhere)
Last edited: