My Top 10 Dallas Cowboy Qb's Of All Time

[Vinnie2u]

10. Beurlein
9. Garrett
8. Dak
7. Lebaron
6. Morton
5. Meredith
4. Romo
3. Danny White
2. Aikman
1. Staubach

 

[unionjack8]

no way for me is Garrett above Steve beuerlein.

I put kosar above him too cos of his role in the playoffs when troy was out.

other than that can't find fault , other than no Kevin Sweeney...........

 

[Alexander]

This was quick.

It is usually February proper when this kind of thread is the rage.

 

[ShiningStar]

back up Garrett over Testeverde? Id put Dak higher than a few others because he had such a stellar rookie season, sure we can factor in eras and stuff. LeBaron was a good qb, dont get me wrong. I can see White over Romo if anyone really wants to. I think Romo brought more, but the turn overs will always hurt him.

Good list, at least you shared and did it. Kudos.

 

[DandyDon1722]

Where's Bernie Kosar?

 

[joseephuss]

Beurlein has a playoff win, so that should get him ranked higher.

Quincy Carter started more games than Garrett and made the playoffs.

 

[joseephuss]

back up Garrett over Testeverde? Id put Dak higher than a few others because he had such a stellar rookie season, sure we can factor in eras and stuff. LeBaron was a good qb, dont get me wrong. I can see White over Romo if anyone really wants to. I think Romo brought more, but the turn overs will always hurt him.

Good list, at least you shared and did it. Kudos.

Danny White had his share of turnovers.

 

[irishline]

I can see White over Romo if anyone really wants to. I think Romo brought more, but the turn overs will always hurt him.

Danny White had 132 interceptions in 95 games as QB with a 4.5% career interception percentage.

Tony Romo had 117 interceptions in 127 games as QB with a 2.7% career interception percentage.

I can see White ahead of him for a couple reasons if someone wanted to (playoff wins being one possibility), but turnovers would not be on that list.

Tony gets a bad rap for his interceptions, and while I agree many were untimely, there weren't as many as people want to blame him for. (FYI Troy aikman and Roger Staubach had 3.0 and 3.7 career interception percentages respectively - and no I am not insinuating Room is better than either of them (he's not IMO), just pointing that fact out.)

 

[Seven]

10. Beurlein
9. Garrett
8. Dak
7. Lebaron
6. Morton
5. Meredith
4. Romo
3. Danny White
2. Aikman
1. Staubach

Yay.....You remember.

 

[JackOfNoTrades]

Any Dallas Cowboys great QB list w/o Steve Pelluer is wack!



Seriously though, I loved the guy back then even if it was for only a fleeting second!

 

[muck4doo]

Drew Bledsoe dissed again

 

[percyhoward]

4. Romo
3. Danny White
2. Aikman
1. Staubach

You've got White ranked too high. He was a very good player who was fortunate enough to have the best supporting cast in the NFL over the three seasons that he "led" the Cowboys to the conference championship game. Of the teams with the most wins from 1980-82, those Dallas teams had the league's best defense and best running game. In any one particular year, there was always a team that was better than the Cowboys, but no team was consistently better over that 3-year period.

1980-82
Dallas Cowboys
Defense
pts allowed 8th
DPR 5th
Running game
yards 4th
TD 8th
team avg rank 6th

1980-82
Philadelphia Eagles
Defense
pts allowed 7th
DPR 7th
Running game
yards 14th
TD 8th
team avg rank 9th

1980-82
Washington Commanders
Defense
pts allowed 8th
DPR 7th
Running game
yards 12th
TD 13th
team avg rank 10th

1980-82
Miami Dolphins
Defense
pts allowed 10th
DPR 12th
Running game
yards 10th
TD 14th
team avg rank 12th

1980-82
Oakland Raiders
Defense
pts allowed 16th
DPR 14th
Running game
yards 12th
TD 13th
team avg rank 14th

1980-82
San Diego Chargers
Defense
pts allowed 23rd
DPR 19th
Running game
yards 14th
TD 3rd
team avg rank 15th

 

[BotchedLobotomy]

10. Beurlein
9. Garrett
8. Dak
7. Lebaron
6. Morton
5. Meredith
4. Romo
3. Danny White
2. Aikman
1. Staubach

You lost all credibility when your list did not include Quincy Carter.