Needell: At the trade deadline, it's Buyer Beware for teams acquiring players

Gryphon

Merge Ahead
Messages
3,407
Reaction score
31
By Paul Needell/The Star-Ledger
October 18, 2009, 6:30AM

Wide receiver Roy Williams has not provided the impact the Cowboys would have hoped for since they traded for him at the deadline last year.
http://www.nj.com/sports/ledger/needell/index.ssf/2009/10/needell_at_the_trade_deadline.html

The NFL trade deadline is 4 p.m. Tuesday. It’s always a “buyer beware” market for anyone hoping to strike it rich. See: Walker, Herschel.

You would think that the man who feasted on the riches the Dallas Cowboys collected from the Minnesota Vikings by shipping them Walker for a myriad of draft choices — which would become a large part of three Super Bowl titles in four seasons (1992-95) — would know better about how such tomfoolery works out for the buyer.

But Cowboys owner Jerry Jones is no ordinary man. Just ask him.

So there he was a year ago, believing that Detroit Lions wide receiver Roy Williams was the answer to his latest string of unanswered Super Bowl prayers. Off to Dallas went Williams, along with a seventh-round draft pick in 2009, in exchange for a first (TE Brandon Pettigrew), a third (WR Derrick Williams) and a sixth-rounder (RB Aaron Brown).

It's too soon to say how the picks are working out, but Roy Williams has been a huge disappointment, by any measure. In 14 games with the Cowboys, Williams has caught only 30 passes, three for TDs, and has yet to have 100 yards receiving in a game.

The Jets, of course, have every reason to hope their recent acquisition of former Cleveland Browns wide receiver Braylon Edwards pays more immediate dividends for them. All indications are he will.

Williams was added to the Cowboys last season to complement established diva wideout Terrell Owens. He wasn’t asked to be the man until this season, but thus far, former Monmouth University star Miles Austin has done more to seize the day than Williams has.

The coast is all clear for Edwards to become that rare in-season trade acquisition that reaps huge rewards. His partner in pass-catching crime will eventually be Jerricho Cotchery, an excellent Robin who needs a Batman.

Edwards can be that Batman.

As a member of the Buffalo Bills this afternoon at Giants Stadium, perhaps Owens will look longingly over at the Jets and think, “Maybe they can get it right.”

Playing fantasy football did not work out well this time around for Jones. Not with T.O. in the mix. He is poison for quarterbacks, as Tony Romo learned the hard way.

Edwards does not have to become another T.O. It’s not too late for him to change his stripes.

Maybe Jets GM Mike Tannenbaum has better luck playing the rotisserie game, putting Edwards and Cotchery together with rookie quarterback Mark Sanchez and second-year tight end Dustin Keller. These chemistry experiments are always fun to watch.

Volatile, too. Buyer beware, indeed.

NOTES ETC.

What did Saints coach Sean Payton do with ex-Giants TE Jeremy Shockey all week? How did he ever get the Shockster to take such a milquetoast stance before Sunday’s battle of undefeateds at the Superdome? Rest assured, the real Shockey moments will come in the locker room after the game — if we’re not treated to a few during it. ... As predicted, Cowboys owner Jerry Jones gave Wade Phillips another vote of confidence on his radio show the other day, this time committing to his head coach for the rest of the season. “Two years ago the Giants were seemingly not in disarray, but they were in trouble,” Jones said. “It was also absolutely expected that something was going to happen with the coach, [Tom] Coughlin. ... Well, that same year they won the Super Bowl. You’ve got to be mindful that this is a long, long journey. ... A lot can happen from the beginning to the end.”

No such endorsement for Commanders coach Jim Zorn from Danny Boy Snyder. Zorn’s almost certainly a goner if Washington loses Sunday to the winless Chiefs after already giving the Giants, Lions and Panthers their first Ws. ... More evidence of parity gone by: For the first time in NFL history, four teams are 5-0. And for the first time in more than 20 years, four teams are 0-5. ... Chiefs coach Todd Haley recently demoted former Jets WR Dedric Ward from WR coach and replaced him with ex-Jets RB Richie Anderson. ... The three teams that fired their offensive coordinators before the end of training camp — the Bills, Chiefs and Buccaneers — are 1-14. Just sayin’. Oh, and Buffalo’s win was over Tampa Bay. Should that even count?

Of the 27 players traded at the deadline in the previous 20 years, seven were WRs. Wideouts are among the players most easily acclimated into a team’s system. ... Remember when passing for 300 yards was once the kiss of death for teams? Not anymore: Clubs which passed for 300 yards or more are 23-8 thus far in those games, the most wins in history for the first five weeks of the season. ... The league’s leading rusher is Bengals RB Cedric Benson (487 yards). This bears repeating: The league’s leading rusher is Bengals RB Cedric Benson (487 yards). That has to pain fans of Da Bears, who picked him fourth overall in ’05. ... The Josh Johnson Era in Tampa Bay is two games old but already on borrowed time. Bucs coach Raheem Morris is inching closer to handing over the reins to No. 1 pick Josh Freeman after the team’s Week 8 bye, unless something unforeseen occurs — like the Bucs beating the Patriots in London Oct. 28. Yeah, right. Pencil in Freeman for Nov. 8 at home vs. the Packers. ... If Saints FS Darren Sharper picks off Eli Manning a time or three Sunday, per usual, isn’t it time for Giants GM Jerry Reese to get him over to the QB’s side?
 

theebs

Believe!!!!
Messages
27,462
Reaction score
9,207
How long before Haley hires Randall williams to replace richie anderson?
 

burmafrd

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,820
Reaction score
3,379
Roy Williams has been a huge disappointment, by any measure

Typical hack reporting. And he says later on how much TO messed things up last season but blames Roy. MORON.

Last season should be tossed. NOW if Roy has not shown more by the end of this season then he is a huge disapointment. But otherwise except for idiots like this worthless hack its too soon to make any kind of an INTELLIGENT judgement.
 

NeonDeion21

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,500
Reaction score
1,065
Exactly whats has been the disappointment? He has helped us become the top offense in the NFL. He played some tough football aganist Denver even after the hit he took. I would hardly call him a disappointment through 5 games.
 

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
21,555
Reaction score
22,657
I'm not disappointed in RW but I would have thought he would have produced more. Whether the lack of production is due to injury, JG not calling his number, poor routes or whatever else may be the case, I'm disappointed in the lack of production. Having said that I think he can get it done.

There was a lot of talk about Romo and RW getting on the same page. While I believe some of that was true in the beginning, there should not be any reason for them not to be now. IMO Romo quickly gets a feel for his receivers so there is something going on. I wonder if he (Romo) feels the whole thing is being forced so the lack of feel is not there.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
theebs;3021001 said:
How long before Haley hires Randall williams to replace richie anderson?

Todd Haley looks like he is in over his head. No wonder his team is so ineffectual, his coaching staff is equally disorganized and bewildered.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
84,018
Reaction score
76,724
A bit premature isn't it? And I mean that on both fronts. To say Braylan and Sanchez will be money and to say that Roy hasn't worked out?
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
81,310
Reaction score
102,239
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
NeonDeion21;3021133 said:
Exactly whats has been the disappointment? He has helped us become the top offense in the NFL. He played some tough football aganist Denver even after the hit he took. I would hardly call him a disappointment through 5 games.

Because the complainer fans and media, hasn't seen 12 catches and 200 yards and 4 TD's per game like they expected. Anything less is a dissappointment.
 
Top