I think he went a little high with the Commanders grade.
They got their first three guys in Goose's Top 100, all were taken about where Goose had them rated. Solid picks. Helu didn't make the Top 100, but he certainly could have been in the next 32 spots. Kiper had him as a 4th round pick. There were higher rated rbs available and I don't really see any "special" qualities though he is a one cut back (with straight line speed) and that fits Shanny's system. The rest of their picks are mostly blah imo with Niles Paul, Aldrick Robinson and Chris Neild the standouts. I would give them a C.
Giants and Cowboys both got their 4 top picks out of Goose's Top 100. The value's are fairly similar also with the biggest difference in the second round where the Giants took Marvin Austin at 52 when Goose had him projected in the first round 26 while the Cowboys took Bruce Carter at 40 when Goose had him at 65.(25 picks early) So Giants have better value there according to Goose, but Carter is a guy that would have been higher if not for the knee.(which has good reports) I also think Austin is just as much a gamble after not playing last season and might have been over valued by Goose which is why he ended up at 52. Cowboys tended to get better value with the late picks imo with Thomas, Harris, and Chapas as standouts and an interesting guy in Nagy who lost his chance at a starting spot on the best OL in the country because of a moped accident. Goose has even reported that the Cowboys had one of the best 3rd day of the draft. Giants standouts being Jones and Sash. So I would give them both a B but could understand the Giants getting the better grade because of the 2nd round.
Cowboys B
Giants B
Eagles only got their first two picks out of Goose's Top 100. Watkins was taken slightly higher than he ranked on Goose's list (5 spots)But they got the best G in the draft with the pick.(over aged player being his biggest knock) Jaiquan Jarrett was their 2nd round pick and he was taken a round earlier than he was rated in Goose's Top 100.(54/92) Curtis Marsh didn't make Goose's Top 100, but was considered a 3rd round prospect by Kiper. Casey Matthews seem to be taken a round too high. Alex Henery was the best K in the draft looks to be an automatic 3 kind of guy. The rest is kind of mixed with Lewis, Kelce and Havili the standouts. C-
