NFC East top 10 again

[gazmc_06]

Do you watch him all the time? He is the best player in the division. If we take off our homer glasses (TOP 4 AS COWBOYS?! Please.) we can see it. Westbrook is the most dangerous player in the east.

And if you take off your Westbrook glasses you will see it....he's good, but not the best.

 

[dstew60105]

I agree. I watch Westbrook week in and week out, and I'm telling you, he is the BEST.

He never has a bad game. He is such a smart player who does every little thing right. I never see him lose yards. He always seems to bullet forward for a gain of two if it looks like he's going to lose two. He's an amazing receiver as well. He is the best RB in the league and I would say best player in the division.

Having Landry above T-New though is ridiculous. Landry isn't top 10.

1.Westbrook
2.Ware
3.TO
4.Cole
5.Witten
6.Romo
7.Andrews
8.Newman
9.Samuel
10.Umenyiora

He's not the best. LT or AP hands down. Not even close.

 

[Big Country]

ok flame away, but how is Barber better then Portis? Portis has proven he can start, but you are correct in stating Romo is better then Eli

mmmmm. What was Barber's rushing stats in his first start?

I don't think I would say one is better than the other. One is more experienced than the other, but the comparison should end there IMO

Portis was/is super super effective in the zone blocking then cutback and haul *** to daylight style

Barber is as effective as a 16 lb sledgehammer, but effective nonetheless, with a sidekick like Felix Jones, defenses hopefully will get plum worn out this coming season.

 

[Clarkson]

And if you take off your Westbrook glasses you will see it....he's good, but not the best.

Why would I have Westbrook glasses? That doesn't even make sense. Good one.

What makes Ware better than Westbrook?

 

[gazmc_06]

Why would I have Westbrook glasses? That doesn't even make sense. Good one.

What makes Ware better than Westbrook?

People have favorite players outside of Dallas...thinka about it, makes plenty sense.

What makes Ware better is being consistently great in all aspects of the game and being close to DPOY, where was Westbrook in the offensive players of the year award race? behind Brady, Moss, Owens and a few others.

 

[DallasDomination]

Do you watch him all the time? He is the best player in the division. If we take off our homer glasses (TOP 4 AS COWBOYS?! Please.) we can see it. Westbrook is the most dangerous player in the east.

You're the one saying that Westbrook is the best Rb in the NFL. Adrian peterson is the best right now and it's not clos. I like westbrook but there are player like Ware or Terrell Owens that IMO rank higher then Him.

 

[gazmc_06]

You're the one saying that Westbrook is the best Rb in the NFL. Adrian peterson is the best right now and it's not clos. I like westbrook but there are player like Ware or Terrell Owens that IMO rank higher then Him.

Couldn't agree more to be honest, as of RIGHT NOW AP is the best running back and Ware and Owens are better players.

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

I actually like Trent Cole, he was on my most underrated list a few years back, but some og you are way overrating him.

 

[NextGenBoys]

I'd have Owens, Witten, Ware and Romo above Westbrook honestly. Gonna sound like a homer but I'm being honest. T.O.'s impact on Philly and here has put both teams to another level.

We havent won a playoff game in the 2 years he's been here, and havent won since 96.

We're far from "another level"

 

[jobberone]

I love Barber but he's not earned a spot near Portis whom I don't like much less love. Give credit where it is due. If Barber does what he did for the next few years then I'd say he is better than Portis. He may prove to be better but he has to do it.

Ware has done it long enough to be considered perhaps the best defensive player in the league. Arguably.

Romo has proven he can do it. But until he does it in the playoffs he will not be considered that good my most. So far he's been superb at times and good with problems at others. He has to do it in Dec and Jan/Feb.

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

I actually like Trent Cole, he was on my most underrated list a few years back, but some og you are way overrating him.

He shines on a defense thats just past its prime last year and the year before that. You also have to consider the garbage they put on the other side of him, Howard and Kearse didnt do diddly.

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

And if you take off your Westbrook glasses you will see it....he's good, but not the best.

he creates so many matchups int he Eagles favor, I dont see how you dont see that.

Look at what he did to Dallas in our last game. How clutch that run he made where he could have easily walked into the endzone, but purposely stopped short to let the clock out.

The fact that he had the most yards from scrimmage than any other player in the league speaks something.

More than LT.

The problem with AP is that we havent actually seen the guy play the entire season, he probably will show us how good he can be next season for sure. Its not like AP was untouchable, he played great, but he was stopped towards the end of the season (injury or not). San Francisco anyone?

Dont get me wrong, I love AP, I just dont think he is the best right now. Right now I take Westbrook, if we were looking five years down the road, I take AP.

 

[gazmc_06]

We havent won a playoff game in the 2 years he's been here, and havent won since 96.

We're far from "another level"

We were having a hard time just making the playoff's, we are now on another level to what we were.

 

[gazmc_06]

he creates so many matchups int he Eagles favor, I dont see how you dont see that.

Look at what he did to Dallas in our last game. How clutch that run he made where he could have easily walked into the endzone, but purposely stopped short to let the clock out.

The fact that he had the most yards from scrimmage than any other player in the league speaks something.

More than LT.

The problem with AP is that we havent actually seen the guy play the entire season, he probably will show us how good he can be next season for sure. Its not like AP was untouchable, he played great, but he was stopped towards the end of the season (injury or not). San Francisco anyone?

Dont get me wrong, I love AP, I just dont think he is the best right now. Right now I take Westbrook, if we were looking five years down the road, I take AP.

I can see what he does, it's very easy to see his talnet, but he is not better than LT. LT had more yards and more than double the TD's of Westbrook.

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

I can see what he does, it's very easy to see his talnet, but he is not better than LT. LT had more yards and more than double the TD's of Westbrook.

he had more rushing but not total. Westy does it all, even returns punts well.

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

San Diego had no passing game either....I'd have LT or AP first.

atleast SD has Gates, Rivers, and Chambers.

 

[gazmc_06]

atleast SD has Gates, Rivers, and Chambers.

I was talking about over the years, not just last year...Chambers just got there. LT set the record with virtually no passing game, all eye's were on him and he still ran through everyone.

Westbrook is very good, but he had 7 TD's compared to LT's 15.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

1. Sean Taylor
2. Adam Archuleta

best safety duo, ever...

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

I was talking about over the years, not just last year...Chambers just got there. LT set the record with virtually no passing game, all eye's were on him and he still ran through everyone.

Westbrook is very good, but he had 7 TD's compared to LT's 15.

true, and a valid point.

 

[Teague31]

well then I will just copy mine from the other thread:

1. Ware
2. Westbrook
3. T. Cole
4. T.O.
5. Romo/Eli (Ill probably get flammed for that, but Eli did win it all)
6. Portis (anyone else feel like Portis has been a little off his game recently?)
7. Burress
8. Samuel
9. Landry
10. T. New

I think osi is a little bit overrated, theres no doubt his sacks were padded by the eagles game; bc winston justice is the biggest slob of all OLmen in the league. I just think were gonna see it this year without Strahan that Osi slips up a bit.

And Mcflab is a joke now. They dont even talk about him, all you hear Eagles fans talking about is Kolb.
__________________

cole? did you see what flo did to him last year.. he is a one dimensional player who can't hang with the big boys. landry? overrated. no way he is a better player than witten (or cooley for that matter).