NFL Awards by Charean Williams

Messages
27,093
Reaction score
0
NFL INSIDER

There's plenty of credit for New England's perfect year

By CHAREAN WILLIAMS
Star-Telegram Staff Writer


Now that the have finished off the greatest regular season in history, it's time to figure out where the credit goes.
The Patriots scored the most points (589) and the most touchdowns (75) in a season. They also had the largest point differential (315).
Tom Brady set the record for touchdown passes in a season (50), and Randy Moss set the NFL record for receiving touchdowns in a season (23).
Brady, who plays the most important position on a team, is the league MVP. But Brady had never been an All-Pro and had never been a league MVP until this year, when Moss arrived from Oakland. It was not coincidence.
Moss deserves credit, too.
Moss is the league's offensive player of the year. It's similar to the St. Louis Rams in 1999 and '01. In those two seasons, Kurt Warner was MVP and Marshall Faulk was offensive player of the year. (Faulk won both awards in 2000.)
But what about Mike Vrabel for defensive player of the year? Or Bill Belichick for coach of the year? Both are deserving, but I didn't vote for either.
My reasoning on Belichick was this: The Patriots were picked to win the Super Bowl before the season started. Their undefeated season was talked about as a possibility after a 38-14 victory over the Chargers in Week 2.
The Patriots did do something that had never been done before in a 16-game season, but I don't think anyone is surprised. In fact, after their 24-20 victory over the Colts in Week 9, I think it would have been a surprise if the Patriots hadn't gone undefeated.
The Awards
MVP -- , QB, Patriots: He had the best season a quarterback ever has had, with a 68.9 completion percentage, 4,806 yards, 50 touchdowns, eight interceptions and a 117.2 passer rating.
Runner-up: , QB, Packers
Comeback Player -- Greg Ellis, OLB, Cowboys: Before he played in Week 4, it appeared he might never make it back on the field from the Achilles' heel he tore last season. But despite not starting his first game until Week 7, Ellis finished tied for sixth in the NFL with 12.5 sacks.
Runner-up: Albert Haynesworth, DT, Titans
Defensive Rookie -- Patrick Willis, ILB, 49ers: Chad Johnson said he still doesn't know Willis' name, but he knows his number after watching game film of Willis making every tackle. Willis led the league with 174 tackles. He is the real deal.
Runner-up: Jon Beason, ILB, Panthers
Offensive Rookie -- Adrian Peterson, RB, Vikings: Peterson set the NFL record for rushing yards in a game with 296 against the Chargers. He had a 224-yard game against the Bears.
Runner-up: Joe Thomas, OT, Browns
Defensive Player -- Bob Sanders, SS, Colts: How valuable is Sanders to the Colts? They played 12 games without him last year and had one of the worst rushing defenses in NFL history. Sanders came back for the postseason, and the Colts won the Super Bowl. This season, with Sanders playing 15 games, the Colts ranked third in total defense. It's why the Colts rewarded him with a five-year, $37.5 million contract last week.
Runner-up: DeMarcus Ware, OLB, Cowboys
Offensive Player -- , WR, Patriots: He had one of the best seasons ever for a receiver with 98 catches, 1,493 yards and a record 23 touchdowns.
Runner-up: Brett Favre, QB, Packers
Coach -- Jack Del Rio, Jaguars: Jacksonville had no Pro Bowlers voted to Hawaii. It likely will have no All-Pro selections. (The Patriots likely will have the MVP and the offensive player of the year.) If the Jaguars have no all-star talent, then there has to be some reason why they won 11 games. The only explanation is coaching.
Runner-up: Bill Belichick, Patriots
ALL-PRO TEAM
Fifty writers do the voting for the NFL All-Pro team. Results will be released Jan. 10. Here is how Star-Telegram NFL writer Charean Williams voted:
OFFENSE
QBTom Brady, Patriots: Threw a record 50 touchdown passes during a perfect 16-0 season.
RBLaDainian Tomlinson, Chargers: Had 602 yards in the final five games to win another rushing title. His 1,474 rushing yards were 133 more than -up Adrian Peterson, who missed two games and had eight other games with fewer than 80 rushing yards. Peterson totaled 144 rushing yards in his final four games.
RBBrian Westbrook, Eagles: Had 2,104 yards from scrimmage (1,333 rushing, 771 receiving).
FB Tony Richardson, Vikings: Minnesota led the league in rushing with 164.6 yards per game.
WRRandy Moss, Patriots: He broke Jerry Rice's NFL record with 23 receiving touchdowns.
WRReggie Wayne, Colts: It was a tossup between Wayne and Terrell Owens, but Wayne led the league with 1,510 receiving yards.
TEJason Witten, Cowboys: Antonio Gates is the best tight end in the NFL, but Witten had the best year: 96 catches, 1,145 yards, 7 touchdowns.
LTWalter Jones, Seattle: Browns rookie Joe Thomas was considered, but Jones is the best.
LGSteve Hutchinson, Vikings: He was the biggest reason Adrian Peterson rushed for 1,341 yards and Chester Taylor for 844.
CJeff Saturday, Colts: Was a big part of Colts' high-powered offense.
RGLeonard Davis, Cowboys: One of the best free-agent signings of the off-season.
RTJordan Gross, Panthers: In a weak year of right tackles, Gross was the best of the bunch, having given up only one sack.
KR/PRDevin Hester, Bears: The toughest pick of the whole All-Pro team. Cleveland's Josh Cribbs is equally deserving. Hester returned four punts and two kickoffs for touchdowns.
DEFENSE
DEMario Williams, Texans: No defensive end had a bigger portion of his team's sacks.
DTKevin Williams, Vikings: He and teammate Pat Williams are the best pair of interior players in the league.
DTAlbert Haynesworth, Titans: Would have been strong Defensive Player of the Year candidate if he hadn't injured his hamstring.
DEPatrick Kerney, Seahawks: Jared Allen, Aaron Kampman, Osi Umenyiora and Kyle Vanden Bosch deserve All-Pro, too.
OLB DeMarcus Ware, Cowboys: He was one of the league's most dominant players with 84 tackles and 14 sacks.
ILBLofa Tatupu, Seahawks: Single-handedly beat the Eagles with three interceptions and 11 tackles.
ILBPatrick Willis, 49ers: He was the best rookie this year with a league-leading 174 tackles. Opponents raved about him.
OLBJames Harrison, Steelers: Mike Vrabel deserved to be here, too, but Harrison was the team MVP of the league's best defense.
CBCharles Woodson, Packers: Teammate Al Harris is going to the Pro Bowl, but Woodson had a better season.
CBAsante Samuel, Patriots: Had six interceptions and is in line to become a very rich man this off-season as a free agent.
SS Bob Sanders, Colts: He had 96 tackles, 3.5 sacks and two interceptions.
FS Ed Reed, Ravens: Was tied for third in the NFL with seven interceptions.
PAndy Lee, 49ers: He and Oakland's Shane Lechler became the fifth and sixth punters ever to finish with a 40-yard net or better; Lee won the spot with 42 punts inside the 20.
Charean Williams, 817-390-7760

http://www.star-telegram.com/329/story/384981.html
 

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
ThreeSportStar80;1874838 said:
The Awards
MVP -- , QB, Patriots:
Brady
He had the best season a quarterback ever has had, with a
68.9 completion percentage,
4,806 yards,
50 touchdowns,
8 interceptions and a
117.2 passer rating.




I am not a big Marino fan... definitely not a Brady homer.

Marino
64.2 completion percentage,
5,084 yards,
48 touchdowns,
17 interceptions and a
108.9 passer rating.



I would like to know what some think about the game THEN and the game NOW... how much of/and what are... the differences that allowed Brady to edge out those Marino stats.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,114
Reaction score
11,463
Well, you may know what my opinion is... :)

It's much easier for offenses now than when Marino played. They let offensive players, from the O-line to WRs, get away with virtual murder now compared to what they did then. And defenses are barely allowed to hit or cover anymore.

Brady is great, but there's a reason passing records stood so long until 2004 when they began to fall.
 

Future

Intramural Legend
Messages
27,566
Reaction score
14,714
Good to see Bigg getting some love.

But why the love for Bob Sanders? His numbers aren't really any better than Roy's...
 

Bizwah

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,158
Reaction score
3,877
YoMick;1874860 said:
I am not a big Marino fan... definitely not a Brady homer.

Marino
64.2 completion percentage,
5,084 yards,
48 touchdowns,
17 interceptions and a
108.9 passer rating.



I would like to know what some think about the game THEN and the game NOW... how much of/and what are... the differences that allowed Brady to edge out those Marino stats.

Mark Clayton, Mark Duper, and Nat Moore were all good WRs. But none could match Randy Moss. How many games have we seen Brady just throw one up carelessly just because he knew Moss could come down with it?

Neither Marino nor Brady have a guy like Emmitt Smith at RB.....but the Pats running game is a lot better than anything Marino had.

Plus, the NFL is simply not what it was. The addition of four teams since Marino set all those records have watered down the NFL. Think about it...there are over 200 more players in the NFL now than there were when Marino played.
 

Bluefin

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,209
Reaction score
9,677
Future;1874965 said:
But why the love for Bob Sanders? His numbers aren't really any better than Roy's...
Bob Sanders is a total game changer for the Colts defense.

They flat sucked on defense when Sandy didn't play most of last season and caught fire when he returned right before the playoffs.

If you think what Terrell Owens means to our offense, Sanders has the same impact on the Colts D.

That's the kind of impact Roy Williams is supposed to make on our defense.
 

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
Thanks for that guys.... sort of along the lines of what I thought.... BUT MORE DETAIL... good stuff
 

DallasInDC

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,136
Reaction score
5,019
Defensive Player -- Bob Sanders, SS, Colts: How valuable is Sanders to the Colts? They played 12 games without him last year and had one of the worst rushing defenses in NFL history. Sanders came back for the postseason, and the Colts won the Super Bowl.


Bluefin;1874995 said:
Bob Sanders is a total game changer for the Colts defense.

They flat sucked on defense when Sandy didn't play most of last season and caught fire when he returned right before the playoffs.
If you think what Terrell Owens means to our offense, Sanders has the same impact on the Colts D.

That's the kind of impact Roy Williams is supposed to make on our defense.

I don't disagree with that statement, but what does his impact last year have to do with this years DPOY?
 

wrnboysfan

New Member
Messages
54
Reaction score
0
well now he is the biggest reason that the colts have one of the top defenses in the league. he is a game changer in both the run game and coverage and is the only player in my mind that deserves DPOY more then ware.

if ware doesn't win DPOY, i'd only be ok with sanders winning. that's how good a season and how much he means to his team.
 

jackrussell

Last of the Duke Street Kings
Messages
4,165
Reaction score
1
Bizwah;1874983 said:
Plus, the NFL is simply not what it was. The addition of four teams since Marino set all those records have watered down the NFL. Think about it...there are over 200 more players in the NFL now than there were when Marino played.

And about 30 million more Americans to draw those 200 from. Chances are you could draw up another 200 NFL caliber players out of there.
 

THUMPER

Papa
Messages
9,522
Reaction score
61
YoMick;1874860 said:
I am not a big Marino fan... definitely not a Brady homer.

Marino
64.2 completion percentage,
5,084 yards,
48 touchdowns,
17 interceptions and a
108.9 passer rating.



I would like to know what some think about the game THEN and the game NOW... how much of/and what are... the differences that allowed Brady to edge out those Marino stats.

Here are some comparisons from the top-3 seasons by a QB (TDs & Yards mostly):

Brady 07
578 Att, 398 Comp, 68.9%, 4806 yards, 8.3 avg, 50 TDs, 8.65%, 8 INTs, 1.38%, 117.2 QB Rating

Manning 04
497 Att, 336 Comp, 67.6%, 4557 yards, 9.2 avg, 49 TDs, 9.86%, 10 INTs, 2.01%, 121.1 QB Rating

Marino 84
564 Att, 362 Comp, 64.2%, 5084 yards, 9.0 avg, 48 TDs, 8.51%, 17 INTs, 3.01%, 108.9 QB Rating

As great as Tom Brady has been this season, he still doesn't beat out Peyton Manning's 2004 season. Manning averaged a full yard per attempt and more than a full percentage point in TDs per attempt. He also has the highest single season QB Rating of all time.
 

wrnboysfan

New Member
Messages
54
Reaction score
0
THUMPER;1875256 said:
Here are some comparisons from the top-3 seasons by a QB (TDs & Yards mostly):

Brady 07
578 Att, 398 Comp, 68.9%, 4806 yards, 8.3 avg, 50 TDs, 8.65%, 8 INTs, 1.38%, 117.2 QB Rating

Manning 04
497 Att, 336 Comp, 67.6%, 4557 yards, 9.2 avg, 49 TDs, 9.86%, 10 INTs, 2.01%, 121.1 QB Rating

Marino 84
564 Att, 362 Comp, 64.2%, 5084 yards, 9.0 avg, 48 TDs, 8.51%, 17 INTs, 3.01%, 108.9 QB Rating

As great as Tom Brady has been this season, he still doesn't beat out Peyton Manning's 2004 season. Manning averaged a full yard per attempt and more than a full percentage point in TDs per attempt. He also has the highest single season QB Rating of all time.

yeah and a lot of people forget that manning only played two series in the last game, unlike Brady who played every game.
 

Bluefin

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,209
Reaction score
9,677
DallasInDC;1875197 said:
I don't disagree with that statement, but what does his impact last year have to do with this years DPOY?
The Colts were something like 20th in total defense without Bob Sanders on the field last year, with him this season they've risen to 3rd, I believe.

Sanders is the key to that unit, that makes him a DPOY candidate in my book, his impact is much bigger than personal stats.
 

AdamJT13

Salary Cap Analyst
Messages
16,583
Reaction score
4,529
Bluefin;1875293 said:
The Colts were something like 20th in total defense without Bob Sanders on the field last year, with him this season they've risen to 3rd, I believe.

They were just as bad with him during the regular season as they were without him. And they were just as good without him THIS year (or better) than they were with him. He doesn't make a lot of big plays, and his entire DPOY candidacy is built around his mere presence. Sorry, but I'm not buying it.
 
Top