NFL.com: NFC East Draft Grades

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,563
NFL.com analyst Bucky Brooks is handing out grades for each team following the 2010 NFL Draft. Check back daily as he breaks down each team, division by division.


Cowboys' draft picks

Rd Sel. # Player Pos. School
1 24 Dez Bryant WR Oklahoma State​
2 55 Sean Lee LB Penn State​
4 126 Akwasi Owusu-Ansah CB Indiana (Pa.)​
6 179 Sam Young OT Notre Dame​
6 196 Jamar Wall CB Texas Tech​
7 234 Sean Lissemore DT William & Mary

» Cowboys' pick-by-pick analysis


Dallas Cowboys: B+

Jerry Jones is a noted wheeler and dealer, and his aggressive ways resulted in the Cowboys landing a terrific draft class. The team traded up a handful of spots to land one of the most talented players in the draft in Dez Bryant, and used a similar ploy to get Sean Lee in the second round. Both players have the potential to be all-stars at their respective positions and will make contributions very early in their careers. Throw in the addition of draft sleeper Akwasi Owusu-Ansah, and the Cowboys' draft class will play a major role in their Super Bowl run in 2010.

Key picks:

Round 1 (24th overall): Dez Bryant, WR, Oklahoma State
Though Bryant has been roundly labeled as a potential character risk, his exceptional talent is undeniable and he gives the Cowboys an all-star caliber pass catcher. With Roy Williams under performing, Bryant could become a key contributor early in his rookie season.
» Video: Cowboys select Bryant
Round 2 (55th overall): Sean Lee, LB, Penn State
The Penn State star quickly diagnoses plays and has a knack for slipping blocks on the way to the ball. In addition, Lee gives the team a versatile linebacker with the athleticism to man multiple roles in their defense.
» Video: Lee's combine workout
Round 4 (126th overall): Akwasi Owusu-Ansah, CB, Indiana (Pa.)
The athletic playmaker from Indiana (Pa.) has outstanding ball skills, and is a dynamic returner in the kicking game. With the Cowboys looking to add quality depth in the secondary, the pick of Owusu-Ansah is a solid addition.
» Video: Owusu-Ansah's combine workout


Eagles' draft picks

Rd
Sel. # Player Pos. School
1 13 Brandon Graham DE Michigan​
2 37 Nate Allen FS South Florida​
3 86 Daniel Te'o-Nesheim DE Washington​
4 105 Trevard Lindley CB Kentucky​
4 121 Keenan Clayton LB Oklahoma​
4 122 Mike Kafka QB Northwestern​
4 125 Clay Harbor TE Missouri State​
5 134 Ricky Sapp DE Clemson​
5 159 Riley Cooper WR Florida​
6 200 Charles Scott RB LSU​
7 220 Jamar Chaney LB Mississippi State​
7 243 Jeff Owens DT Georgia​
7 244 Kurt Coleman SS Ohio State

» Eagles' pick-by-pick analysis


Philadelphia Eagles: B

The Eagles continued to infuse the locker room with young talent by taking 13 players in the draft. Andy Reid cleverly moved up and down the board to pick up targeted players, while also adding a bevy of picks. Brandon Graham was nabbed after making an aggressive jump into the top half of the first round, and he gives the team a high-motor rusher to pair with Trent Cole. In Nate Allen, the Eagles address their pressing need at free safety by bringing in a natural ball hawk in the back end. Mike Kafka becomes the Eagles' latest quarterback project to develop into a future contributor.

Key picks:

Round 1 (13th overall): Brandon Graham, DE, Michigan
Graham possesses exceptional first-step quickness, and his relentless motor often leads to negative plays for the defense. With the Eagles seeking to bring pressure from all angles, Graham gives Sean McDermott another weapon in his arsenal.
» Video: Eagles select Graham | Graham's combine workout | Meet Graham
Round 2 (37th overall): Nate Allen, FS, South Florida
The former South Florida star is a rangy defender with outstanding instincts and awareness. Though he isn't regarded as a headhunter in the back end, Allen's ball skills and playmaking ability are so superior that the Eagles were comfortable adding him despite his finesse style. He should start immediately at free safety.
» Video: Meet Allen
Round 4 (122nd overall): Mike Kafka, QB, Northwestern
As an athletic thrower with good overall skills, Kafka is a solid fit in the Eagles' West Coast offense. Though he is a few years away from being a legitimate candidate to play as a starter, he is a developmental passer that should flourish in the team's scheme.
» Video: Kafka's combine workout


Giants' draft picks

Rd
Sel. # Player Pos. School
1 15 Jason Pierre-Paul DE South Florida​
2 46 Linval Joseph DT East Carolina​
3 76 Chad Jones FS LSU​
4 115 Phillip Dillard LB Nebraska​
5 147 Mitch Petrus G Arkansas​
6 184 Adrian Tracy DE William & Mary​
7 221 Matt Dodge P East Carolina

» Giants' pick-by-pick analysis


New York Giants: B-

The Giants do an excellent job of stockpiling talent at critical positions, and that philosophy was reflected in their approach this year. The team added two young defensive linemen (Jason Pierre-Paul and Linval Joseph) to an already deep rotation, and third-round pick Chad Jones becomes the team's third safety. While they were unable to get a middle linebacker in the early portion of the draft to fill their obvious hole at that spot, the addition of Phillip Dillard gives them a highly productive player to compete for time at the position. The Giants' draft is short on pizzazz but provides the team the necessary depth to make a strong push for the NFC East title.

Key picks:

Round 1 (15th overall): Jason Pierre-Paul, DE, South Florida
Although the South Florida standout is a little raw in some aspects of his game, he possesses outstanding first-step quickness and has an exceptional burst off the edge. Given the Giants' ability to develop young pass rushers, the addition of Pierre-Paul ensures that their stable will remain full for a long time to come.
» Video: Giants select Pierre-Paul | Meet Pierre-Paul
Round 2 (46th overall): Linval Joseph, DT, East Carolina
The former East Carolina standout is a classic nose tackle with the strength and power to hold the point against single or double teams. Given the Giants' defensive woes last season, Joseph's presence in the middle should stop some of the leakage that plagued the unit.
» Video: Joseph's combine workout
Round 4 (115th overall): Phillip Dillard, LB, Nebraska
Dillard, the highly productive linebacker from Nebraska, has good instincts and is a tough, downhill player in the middle. He should compete for the starting job as a rookie.
» Video: Dillard's combine workout | Meet Dillard


Commanders' draft picks

Rd
Sel. # Player Pos. School
1 4 Trent Williams OT Oklahoma​
4 103 Perry Riley LB LSU​
6 174 Dennis Morris TE Louisiana Tech​
7 219 Terrence Austin WR UCLA​
7 229 Erik Cook C New Mexico​
7 231 Selvish Capers OT West Virginia​

» Commanders' pick-by-pick analysis


Washington Commanders: C+

The Commanders must be graded on a curve due to the addition of Donovan McNabb. The acquisition of the six-time Pro Bowler cost the team their second-round pick, but stabilized a quarterback situation that had been in flux for more than a decade. Additionally, the team solidified the left side of the line with the selection of Trent Williams. Although most teams had Russell Okung rated higher, the Commanders believe that Williams' athleticism makes him a better fit for their scheme. With only mid- to late-round picks at their disposal, the Commanders are hoping to uncover a gem in Perry Riley and Terrence Austin.

Key picks:

Round 1 (4th overall): Trent Williams, OT, Oklahoma
Williams, who logged starts at both tackle spots and center during his collegiate career, gives the team a nimble athlete to play left tackle in their zone-based blocking scheme. Although there were some concerns about his work ethic, his ability to cut off blockers on the backside on running plays made him a better fit for Washington.
» Video: Commanders select Williams | Meet Williams
Round 4 (103rd overall): Perry Riley, LB, LSU
As an instinctive player with good awareness, Riley gives Jim Haslett a versatile player to line at one of the inside linebacker spots in their new 3-4.
» Video: Riley's combine workout
Round 7 (219th overall): Terrence Austin, WR, UCLA
The Commanders made clear before the draft they were interested in acquiring some more depth at the receiver position, and Austin helped himself during the pre-draft process with an impressive pro day. Austin does not have the size typically preferred by Mike Shanahan and is extremely thin, but he can potentially earn a roster spot if he shines as a slot receiver or returner in training camp.
 
This draft, Dallas didn't churn the bottom of it's roster as it did the previous year and Philadelphia did this season. The team had a solid draft, and the quality was added at three positions up to the start of Day Three. Three strong projections is about par for a draft that doesn't possess a large number of additional picks.

Philadelphia did a huge amount of work and looks to have laid a very strong foundation on it's defensive side of ball. This Eagles team looks to be another group of 'Banjies' coming into this season.

I'm interested in how the Washington defense adjusts to becoming a 3-4 defense now. Remember the growing pains of the Dallas change? Wade is just now getting the adjustments in types of personnel coming in to raise elements to attack with.

The Giants should be pretty solid this season. When a team has 3 deep strength developing in their defensive line and safeties now, they should be tough up front and behind.

Thanks for a realistic evaluation posting that isn't 'skewed' to create turmoil and fan unrest....
 
CCBoy;3381380 said:
Philadelphia did a huge amount of work and looks to have laid a very strong foundation on it's defensive side of ball. This Eagles team looks to be another group of 'Banjies' coming into this season.

If you take away the questionable fourth round, the Eagles have a scary good group on paper. Sapp, Chaney and Cooper were unbelieveable bargains.
 
Alexander;3381394 said:
If you take away the questionable fourth round, the Eagles have a scary good group on paper. Sapp, Chaney and Cooper were unbelieveable bargains.


Unfortunately I agree.
 
Philadelphia did a huge amount of work and looks to have laid a very strong foundation on it's defensive side of ball. This Eagles team looks to be another group of 'Banjies' coming into this season.

Not sure about that. I saw the Iggles picking defense left and right in this year's draft. I think they were swinging for the fences in hopes of hitting a homerun with one of their picks considering the multiple haymakers Dallas landed on them last season.

Desperation comes to mind when looking at the Iggle's draft this year.
 
Fletch;3381399 said:
Desperation comes to mind when looking at the Iggle's draft this year.
Making a strong effort to improving areas you were exposed in the playoffs is desperation?

Linebacker and safety were the two problem areas for that team last year, no question about it. They went out and tried to do something about it.
 
Hostile;3381212 said:

Dallas Cowboys: B+

Jerry Jones is a noted wheeler and dealer, and his aggressive ways resulted in the Cowboys landing a terrific draft class.
So terrific = B+?
 
big dog cowboy;3381405 said:
So terrific = B+?
It is an A if they got the values of Bryant and Lee without giving up the draft choices.
 
Top incoming talent has a high price, either the previous year as to record or the current season with pick slots.

A third round and extra fourth round pick might have added some strength of projection at the bottom tiers of roster considerations as well. That was the cost to expand what is in place. Yea, just like the cost of a Galloway or Roy Williams. Even Roy will eventually start to produce at a higher clip. That falls back to talent level being paid for...
 
big dog cowboy;3381405 said:
So terrific = B+?

I gave them a B+ too. I graded 4 of their choices As, 1 B (Wall) and 1 C (Young). To me that was a B+. Which is a good grade IMO.
 
Fletch;3381399 said:
Desperation comes to mind when looking at the Iggle's draft this year.

Same here. The Eagles always stock pile the number of picks.
 
hipfake08;3381902 said:
Same here. The Eagles always stock pile the number of picks.
So were we desperate last year when we stockpiled 12 choices after the Eagles embarassed us?

Accumulating picks is not desperate. The Eagles are not the only team that did it and has done it. It is just a smart way to even the odds and give yourself a better chance of fielding a better team if you execute it properly.
 
The Giants going D-Line with there first 2 picks makes me think they don't think much of Canty...
 
These grades seem about right to me. The Giants I think might be graded slightly high as I don't think they did enough for their biggest need, the LBer spot, especially in the middle, but other than that I pretty much feel like he got it right on the rest.
 
BraveHeartFan;3381976 said:
The Giants I think might be graded slightly high as I don't think they did enough for their biggest need, the LBer spot, especially in the middle, but other than that I pretty much feel like he got it right on the rest.
Perhaps they have faith in their young ILBs like we do with the OL and S.
 
God the Commanders had a crappy draft. When you are picking so high in a year with so many quality prospects you would actually have to try to have a draft as crappy as the Commanders.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,011
Messages
14,506,482
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top