Make it the Pro Bowl Recognition event….25 players per conference. Not All Pro, but All Conference. Keep it a secret until the event. Then introduce each team, 1x1, with season highlights of the player at his position, along with some comments from a few opponents or opposing coaches.
We all enjoy highlights, and we would actually watch for the highlights, to hear what opposing players say about them, and to see how many of our players make it…..at least I would. I haven’t watched the Pro Bowl for more than 5 minutes in years! A show like this could be very entertaining. Besides opponents, you could even get some comments from former players and colorful coaches.
Forget the game of the early years and make it an entertainment thing for football fans while recognizing deserving players. This would also keep the lousy alternates out of it. Injured? Playing in the SB? No problem, we will watch the greatest runs, blocks, passes, catches, sacks, bone crunching tackles, etc from the best players each season.