Love Emmitt Smith as an all time great player, teammate and person. But if he was a great coach, wanted to coach, or even had great coaching potential, he would have already been a coach at some level the last 15 years. Considering a guy like ES as an NFL HC at this point is just crazy.
What amazes me over the years is how often people do not understand that former great players rarely make great coaches. There are exceptions of course. But the list of all-time greats who were terrible HCs is long over multiple sports.
Quick examples off top of my head of all time greats who were terrible coaches: Michael Jordan, Magic Johnson, Wayne Gretsky, Ted Williams…in football Art Shell, Mike Singletary, Norm Van Brocklin we’re all NFL HOFers and just terrible HCs.
Why are great players usually bad coaches? Because their greatness cannot be taught. Great players have a hard time relating to players who don’t have great ability. On the other hand, most great coaches were average athletes in the sports they played.
Look at some of the great college and NFL HCs who were NOT great players as pros (if they even made it to the pros):
- Nick Saban - the greatest college HC was an average college football player at Kent State in the early 70s. Never played in the pros.
- Bill Parcells - played OL at Colgate University and was in the lions training camp in 1964. He never played a down of NFL football.
- Tom Landry - played at UT in college. A good not great college player. Played for the ny giants for less than decade and was a decent DB and a good punter. But he was identified early as a great coach.
- Bill Walsh - the HOF HC at SF played college fb at “powerhouse” College of San Mateo in California. Never played a down of NFL football.
- Jimmy Johnson - the second greatest Cowboys HC, HOFer Jimmy J played college fb at Arkansas where he was a good DL, making the “All SWC“ first team as a senior. Too small for the NFL, he never even made a training camp.
This list could go on and on. The greatest coaches are almost always not the greatest athletes.