nfldraftcountdown cowboys draft review

Bigdog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,858
Reaction score
11,511
Scott Wright of nfldraftcountdown.com just did the Cowbys review of their selections. It was a pretty good review and he graded the draft as a B+. I am sorry I can not paste it here. My work computer has been acting up. It has been a very frustrating morning with it:bang2: I just thought some of your guys would like to know.
 

Vintage

The Cult of Jib
Messages
16,714
Reaction score
4,888
Thanks to a Draft Day trade a year ago the Cowboys had two first round picks and as a result they were the focus of much speculation in the months leading up to the draft. In the end Jerry Jones resisted the temptation to make a flashy move and instead chose to fortify an already impressive roster. This class may not feature an immediate starter but it could be just what the doctor ordered to put Dallas over the top as they make their Super Bowl run.

Going all the way back to the start of the college season there was speculation about Dallas using their two #1 picks as bait to trade up for Darren McFadden. Jerry Jones certainly coveted McFadden and would have loved to bring him into the fold but at the end of the day that was all a lot more smoke than fire. The cost was simply too prohibitive. The Cowboys still needed to replace Julius Jones though and to no one's surprise they did wind up selecting an Arkansas running back with their top pick. Felix Jones to Dallas was a pick that everyone and their grandmother had pegged in their mocks since the day the draft order was finalized and there was a reason for that: It just made too much sense not to happen! Jones played Robin to McFadden's Batman in college but don't think for a second that he isn't a fantastic talent and top pro prospect in his own right. Jones may not have been a starter in college but he always found a way to contribute and that was actually excellent training for the role he will play in Dallas as a rookie. A big play threat who can impact a game as a runner, receiver and return man, Jones will be a perfect compliment to Pro Bowler Marion Barber, providing the lightning to his thunder. Many Dallas fans were clamoring for Rashard Mendenhall when he fell further than expected but while Mendenhall may be a better player Jones was a better fit for Dallas and they chose the right guy. The Cowboys running game was formidable last year with the duo of Barber / Jones but it should be even better in 2008, which is a scary proposition for opponents that have to stop them.

With their other first round pick the Cowboys actually traded up a couple of spots to nab South Florida's Mike Jenkins, who they reportedly had rated as the #2 cornerback in the draft. In fact, Jenkins could have very easily gone 10-15 picks higher and nobody would have batted an eye. A great athlete who has everything you look for physically in a top pro corner, Jenkins was overshadowed throughout the draft process by guys like Leodis McKelvin, Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie and Aqib Talib to a certain degree and may have actually been a little underrated. Cornerback was arguably the Cowboys #1 need going into the draft with Anthony Henry getting up there in years and even though they did trade for Pacman Jones he hasn't even been reinstated yet and certainly can't be counted on once he is. If he is reinstated that is... Look for Jenkins to start out as the nickel guy, which is essentially a starter in today's NFL, and don't be surprised if he is ultimately starting opposite Terence Newman, if not in 2008 then in 2009. Jenkins was a potential steal as #25.

In round two the Cowboys replaced backup tight end Anthony Fasano, who they traded to Miami in a pre-draft deal, with Martellus Bennett of Texas A&M. Just to give you an idea of what kind of pure athlete Bennett is, he actually entered the NBA Draft out of high school! A great physical specimen, Bennett was never really able to fulfill his potential in the Aggies run-orientated offense and had he played at Miami (FL) he might have been a first round pick. On the plus side Bennett was able to develop as a blocker which will serve him well with Dallas because that will likely be his top priority. Bennett still has a lot of upside and probably could have made a bigger impact had he landed with another team but in Dallas he will be stuck behind Pro Bowler Jason Witten for the foreseeable future. In round four Dallas added yet another running back when they chose Georgia Tech's Tashard Choice. Even though he may not have elite size or speed Choice is a natural runner who was very productive and actually a bit similar to Marion Barber. Ironically Choice was probably selected as insurance for Barber, who at the time of the draft was set to become an unrestricted free agent next offseason and was asking more than Dallas was willing to pay. Since Barber has now been re-signed Choice will be buried on the depth chart and will have to settle in as the #3 guy and only an injury will net him serious playing time in '08. Round four was a bit early for a third-string running back.

Dallas may have gotten themselves a steal in round five when they chose Boise St. cornerback Orlando Scandrick, who many felt would be a 2nd or 3rd rounder. A "Workout Warrior" who had his coming out party at the Scouting Combine when he ran a 4.32 forty at 5-10 and 192 lbs., Scandrick excels in man coverage and had he gone back for his senior year he probably would've gone much earlier. As it stands Scandrick will battle for the dime job as a rookie but how big of a role he actually plays in 2008 will likely depend on what happens with Pacman Jones. Either way Scandrick further bolsters the Cowboys depth at cornerback and was a tremendous value pick. With their final choice in the 2008 NFL Draft the Cowboys chose Middle Tennessee St. defensive end Erik Walden in round six. A classic DE / OLB 'tweener, Walden has some experience lining up as a rush linebacker and that is the role he will be asked to play in Dallas. However, the Cowboys have a lot of depth at outside linebacker and unless he really impresses the best Walden can probably hope for is a third-string spot on the depth chart and he could even be a candidate for the practice squad as a developmental guy. Also, it's hard to label someone who was a 6th round pick as "a reach" but it doesn't sound like many teams had Walden graded as a draftable prospect.

Entering the draft the Cowboys didn't have many glaring holes they needed to address but the few they did have were taken care of with their first three selections. Unless there is an injury neither Felix Jones or Mike Jenkins will be starters in 2008 yet you could make the case that they will still play integral roles for Dallas. Sure they could have packaged some picks in an effort to make a big splash but the Cowboys didn't need to do that. Instead they added some much-needed depth at key positions and supplemented an already talented roster with players who were, for the most part, very good values. You can always nitpick one or two selections but the bottom line is Dallas used this draft to shore up their roster for 2008 and this class helps get them one step closer to their ultimate goal: The Super Bowl.

GRADE: B+
 

Vintage

The Cult of Jib
Messages
16,714
Reaction score
4,888
Skins

For years the Commanders were always one of the flashiest and most unpredictable teams in the league, especially when it came to their offseason moves, but the second Joe Gibbs era brought a return to normalcy. However, with their Hall of Fame coach once again out of the picture nobody really knew what direction Washington would go with this draft. Would they continue on their current path of restraint or would Dan Snyder once again take the reigns and shake things up? After not making much noise in the free agency period the draft was basically Washington's last chance to make a bold move and while they didn't necessarily shock the world they did make a few picks that caught everyone's attention and created some excitement. Will this class help them take that next big step in the playoffs though?

washington.jpg
Even though they traded out of round one many feel the Commanders still landed a first round talent with their top pick. As late as the morning of the draft Michigan St. wide receiver Devin Thomas had a legitimate shot at going in the Top 15-20 overall picks but he slid all the way to round two, where Washington was only too happy to finally take him off the board. A big play threat who excels at running after the catch, physically Thomas really has everything you look for in a stud NFL wideout including great size (6-2, 216), speed (4.40) and natural athleticism. However, Thomas was just a one-year wonder for the Spartans which is why he fell as far as he did. He isn't a finished product and it may take a few years for him to reach his full potential but Thomas is a great player with the talent to outperform his draft slot. Later in round two the Commanders added yet another big wide receiver when they chose Oklahoma's Malcolm Kelly, who at one time they were actually targeting in the first round. At one point in the draft process there was talk of Kelly going as high as #11 overall to Buffalo but by and large that was a product of internet and media hype. Poor workouts (4.68 forty), health concerns (both knees) and maturity questions ultimately killed any chance Kelly had of being a first round pick. Some still cling to the notion that Kelly was an unbelievable steal at #51 overall but in reality he went right about where he should have and in my mind he is a poor-man's Dwayne Jarrett, who went 45th overall a year ago. Kelly has some question marks, there is no doubt about that, but he also has great size, outstanding hands and good ball skills. Look for Thomas and Kelly to battle it out for the #3 and #4 jobs behind Santana Moss and Antwaan Randle El as rookies and even though Thomas should be a better player in the long run don't be surprised if Kelly is able to make more of an impact in 2008, especially in the redzone.

In an interesting move with their other second round pick, sandwiched between Thomas and Kelly, the Commanders chose USC tight end Fred Davis. Washington certainly needed some depth at tight end but with a Pro Bowl-caliber player in Chris Cooley firmly entrenched as the starter you can't help but wonder if Davis was a bit of a luxury pick. With that said Davis is a good fit for the Washington offense and while he leaves much to be desired as a blocker he's a terrific pass catching threat so they now have some insurance if something were to happen to Cooley. After looking like a potential first round pick at one point most felt that character concerns and poor workouts had pushed Davis into the third round range so he may have been a bit of a reach in mid-round two. Davis is a solid player but at the end of the day he was a questionable pick when it comes to both value and need so I can't really endorse the selection. Injuries along the offensive line killed Washington last year so in Round 3 they took a step toward rectifying that problem when they chose Chad Rinehart of Northern Iowa. A big, physical blocker with above average athleticism and a mean streak, Rinehart was a left tackle in college but he will likely be a guard at the pro level although he could also play right tackle if needed. As a rookie look for Rinehart to provide valuable depth but he will likely be groomed to replace either Pete Kendall or Randy Thomas down the line.

devinthomas.jpg
In round four the Commanders reached a bit for Arizona St. cornerback Justin Tryon in an effort to bolster their secondary. Tryon isn't the biggest guy around but he is a great athlete who can handle himself in man coverage and isn't afraid to play physical. Assuming Carlos Rogers comes back healthy Tryon will likely be slated for dime duty as a rookie and while he may never be more than a backup in the NFL he could excel in that role. With the first of three sixth round picks the Commanders chose Georgia Tech punter Durant Brooks, who may be the only immediate starter they get out of this draft. The Ray Guy award winner as the nation's top punter, Guy is actually a family friend and Brooks' mentor so you have to like that connection. Brooks will battle Derrick Frost for the punting job but word is the organization really likes the young guy so unless he looks terrible in training camp and the preseason the job is probably his to lose. With their next choice Washington continued to fortify the secondary by selecting Nicholls St. safety Kareem Moore. Despite his small school roots Moore actually began his college career at Ole Miss and while he lacks top speed he makes up for it by being extremely tough and physical. The Commanders needed some reinforcements at safety due to the untimely passing of Sean Taylor and while Moore isn't starting material he can be a nice backup/special teamer.

With their next pick Washington chose one of the most intriguing players in the '08 Draft, Hawaii quarterback Colt Brennan. Detractors will label Brennan a product of Hawaii's Run & Shoot system and point to his unconventional delivery as reasons why he won't cut it at the pro level. Those are certainly valid points but count me among the minority who still feels Brennan can make it in the NFL. Will he ever be a starter? Probably not. However, Brennan's intangibles are off the charts and in the right situation I think he can be a solid backup. New head coach Jim Zorn has taken a liking to Brennan and while he will begin his career as the #3 signal caller the Commanders could groom him to be Jason Campbell's long-term backup since Todd Collins is about to turn 37-years-old. With the first of two seventh round picks Washington finally brought in some help at defensive end when they chose Rob Jackson of Kansas St. An undersized JUCO transfer with just average speed, Jackson is a solid all-around player but doesn't stand out in any one area and probably doesn't profile as anything more than a backup at the next level. Many felt the Commanders would take a pass rusher very early on since Phillip Daniels is nearing the end of his career and there is little or no depth to speak of so if there is one big criticism of Washington's effort it may be their failure to land a top defensive end. With their final pick of the 2008 NFL Draft the Commanders added one more defensive back when they chose UCLA safety Chris Horton. Another physical, aggressive, in-the-box type, Horton isn't a great athlete and lacks elite timed speed but his intangibles and special teams potential could earn him a roster spot.

All in all Washington did a good job in this draft, not only addressing most of their glaring needs but also getting good value with the majority of their picks. One way or another the Commanders got the big wide receiver they were looking for, whether it be Thomas or Kelly, they bolstered their depth along the offensive line and in the secondary, and for good measure they may have even gotten a starting punter. This class certainly doesn't feature a lot of immediate impact guys and, realistically, there may only be 2-3 starters to come out of this group long-term. That's okay though because Washington was already a playoff team to begin with and they didn't necessarily have ten glaring holes to fill like an Atlanta or a Kansas City. What the Commanders did was use this draft to bring a bunch of complimentary guys who will supplement their roster and provide some much-needed depth. For an already solid team trying to take the next step that was probably the appropriate course of action.

GRADE: B-
 

Vintage

The Cult of Jib
Messages
16,714
Reaction score
4,888
Giants

The Giants shocked the world by winning the Super Bowl but even though they are the champs the reason it was such a surprise is because most just didn't consider them to be that kind of elite team. In other words they still had holes to fill coming into the 2008 NFL Draft. The Giants didn't necessarily need to hit a grand slam on Draft Day '08 but coming through with a strong effort would be imperative if they hope to return to the big game next year. The G-Men had one of the best drafts in the league last year, could they do it again?

newyorkg.jpg
By the time Draft Day rolled around just about everyone had the Giants taking a safety in their mock draft, the only question was which one would it be. Kenny Phillips of Miami (FL) was the obvious choice but there was a chance he could be gone and Tyrell Johnson had made a late push up draft boards but they ultimately had their pick between the two and went with Phillips. At one point it looked like Phillips was destined to be a Top 10 overall pick but a sub par junior season and average workouts pushed him down draft boards. It's hard to go wrong with the program pedigree though and when it comes to safeties nobody does a better job of producing NFL safeties than the Hurricanes. From Bennie Blades to Ed Reed to Sean Taylor, the list just goes on and on. Where exactly Phillips will ultimately rank in that group remains to be seen but there is no question he has the talent to be one of the best. At this point Phillips is probably best in the box but he has enough speed and range to be a ballhawk in coverage as well so the potential is there for him to be a great all-around performer. With Gibril Wilson signing a big free agent deal with the Raiders the Giants had a gaping hole in their secondary so it would be a surprise if Phillips didn't claim a starting job very early on, perhaps even by Week One.

Even though they took a defensive back in round one the Giants still had issues in the secondary and they took another step to address them by selecting USC cornerback Terrell Thomas with their second round pick. Last year's #1 pick Aaron Ross looks like a keeper but Corey Webster still has bouts of inconsistency and both Sam Madison and R.W. McQuarters are getting up their in years so some reinforcements were definitely needed. Thomas is a battle-tested cover guy with very good measurables (6-0, 202 / 4.49) and was a solid late second or early third rounder so for the most part it looks like a pretty good pick on all three fronts, which are talent, value and need. However, my only reservation with the choice is how Thomas will fit in with the Giants defensive scheme. Throughout most of the draft process Thomas was viewed as more of a zone guy whose best fit would be with a team like Tampa, Indy, etc. Will he be able to handle matching up in man-to-man coverage at the pro level? I guess we will see. With their next selection in round three the Giants took a flyer on Michigan wide receiver Mario Manningham, who may be the ultimate "Boom or Bust" pick. Based on talent and production Manningham was probably a first round pick but questions about his character pushed him down draft boards and some took him off completely. What are those issues? Well, he failed drug tests in college, lied about it to NFL decision makers in pre-draft meetings, had a terrible workout at the Scouting Combine and scored a six on the Wonderlic. At first glance it may not appear as though the Giants need help at wideout but staying healthy is a constant battle for Plaxico Burress and Amani Toomer is nearing the end of his career so other than last year's second round pick Steve Smith they really didn't have many long-term options at the position. Manningham could become a star or be out of the league in a few years but the potential rewards far outweighed the risks late in round three and if he can just somehow manage to keep his head on straight he could be a major steal.

kennyphillips.jpg
In the months leading up to the 2008 NFL Draft many mock drafts had the Giants selecting a linebacker in round one and while that didn't come to fruition they did use their fourth and fifth round picks on the position. First up was Bryan Kehl of B.Y.U., who really saw his stock rise on the heels of a great senior year and some excellent workouts. Not only is Kehl a talented player but he also has top-notch intangibles and at the very least he should be a solid backup and that is where he will begin his pro career. However, if / when Michael Strahan retires Mathias Kiwanuka will likely move back to defensive end and when that happens Kehl could battle for a starting job on the strongside. After landing an outside 'backer the Giants shifted their attention inside and selected Jonathan Goff of Vanderbilt. A smart, productive college linebacker with good size who worked out better than anticipated, Goff may only be a two-down run thumper but he should battle for the backup job in the middle behind Antonio Pierce. Keep an eye on Goff though because he's the type of guy who might be hard to get him out of the lineup once he gets an opportunity. If nothing else the G-Men have now significantly bolstered their depth at linebacker by landing two solid, high-character prospects in Kehl and Goff.

In round six the Giants plucked a big name off the draft board when they chose Kentucky quarterback André Woodson. At one point in the process Woodson looked like a sure-fire first round pick but late in his senior season questions began to emerge about his delivery and the system he played in. Those issues were just magnified at the Senior Bowl and Woodson's stock really began to take a tumble. This may be a blessing in disguise for Woodson though because with Eli Manning firmly entrenched as the starter there won't be any pressure on him to play early, which will give him plenty of time to work out his mechanical flaws. Woodson is a developmental signal caller at this point who will battle Jared Lorenzen for the #3 job as a rookie and if all goes well maybe he can assume the backup job 2-3 years down the road. With their final selection the Giants opted for Southern Miss defensive end Robert Henderson, who was a bit of a surprise pick that many teams didn't have rated as a draftable prospect. Who are we to judge the Giants when it comes to evaluating defensive ends though! Henderson will certainly battle for a roster spot and with his ability to play either outside or inside they could utilize him like they do Justin Tuck.

At this point it looks like Kenny Phillips will be the only immediate starter to come out of this class but that's all right because it's not like the Giants had a half dozen holes in their starting lineup that needed to be filled. However, in addition to Phillips there are 3-4 other guys who could assume starting positions in the next few years and anytime you can get both instant impact and long-term upside out of a draft class it was a good day at the office. Will these seven picks help get New York back to the Super Bowl next year? Maybe and maybe not, but if this group can have even half the impact that last year's rookies had for the G-Men the team would be absolutely elated. It will obviously be a few year's before we know exactly how good this class is and what kind of impact they will have but at least on the face it has the potential to be yet another bumper crop of youngster for the Giants.

GRADE: B
 
Top