Biggems;2125150 said:I was able to catch the list up to Jackie Smith.........who did they list in the 2nd half of the show?
I am sure Ditka and Winslow.....possibly even Clark......did Novacek make the list at all?
playmakers;2125232 said:How Tony G. is not in the top 3 of all time is beyond me., I didnt see the show but imo the top three of all time are (in no paticular order) Winslow, Sharpe and Gonzo. I think a guy like Ben Coates should make the latter half of the top 10.
jobberone;2125244 said:Gates hasn't played long enough. And these guys must not be old enough to have seen some of the better TE's from the 60s and 70s. Witten hasn't done it long enough. If he had to hang it up today would you put him in a top ten list? Not if you're honest IMO.
Mackey was the best TE I've ever seen but TE's weren't prominent targets in those days. They did get Ozzie and Ditka in there. Ditka couldn't hold a candle to Mackey although he was a very good TE. Ozzie wouldn't block anyone which I still hold against him. Winslow at least tried to block and did an ok job at it.
DaBoys4Life;2125204 said:10 was antonio gates
9 was some dude from the giants
8 was Tony Gonzalez I think
i don't remember the rest and i turned after a while.
DaBoys4Life;2125204 said:10 was antonio gates
9 was some dude from the giants
8 was Tony Gonzalez I think
i don't remember the rest and i turned after a while.
jterrell;2125331 said:Gates deserves it.
He is that offensive team's best receiving weapon which makes him a throwback to the Winslows of the world. He has 43 receiving TDs(which is amazing playing with TD-hog LT) and over 4300 yards receiving.
Kellen has only 2 more career Receiving Tds.
Jackie Smith had only 40 receiving TDs and was never All Pro, not even once.
Jason Witten has 4 Pro Bowls and 1 All-Pro to his credit already with 21 receiving TDs.
These new TEs are better and only good old days syndrome prevents noting that.
Witten is 25-30 pounds heavier than Jackie Smith and can flat out de-cleat people with his blocking.
Tony Gonzales has 66 receiving TDs and almost 10K yards receiving. He revolutionized the position. He is the best TE of all time. How do I know? Because every GM wants to find a Tony Gonzales to play for them right now.
Mackey was a monster but when his career was over he had 1 more Pro Bowl than Witten does now at 25 years old. Witten may very well pass him in receiving yards this year.
jterrell;2125331 said:Gates deserves it.
He is that offensive team's best receiving weapon which makes him a throwback to the Winslows of the world. He has 43 receiving TDs(which is amazing playing with TD-hog LT) and over 4300 yards receiving.
Kellen has only 2 more career Receiving Tds.
Jackie Smith had only 40 receiving TDs and was never All Pro, not even once.
Jason Witten has 4 Pro Bowls and 1 All-Pro to his credit already with 21 receiving TDs.
These new TEs are better and only good old days syndrome prevents noting that.
Witten is 25-30 pounds heavier than Jackie Smith and can flat out de-cleat people with his blocking.
Tony Gonzales has 66 receiving TDs and almost 10K yards receiving. He revolutionized the position. He is the best TE of all time. How do I know? Because every GM wants to find a Tony Gonzales to play for them right now.
Mackey was a monster but when his career was over he had 1 more Pro Bowl than Witten does now at 25 years old. Witten may very well pass him in receiving yards this year.