*Official :Eli suks Thread***

juck · Dec 17, 2005

He will never carry this team very far.He is horrible.And Tiki cant do everything.

lcharles · Dec 17, 2005

He's still young. He will get better. Wish we had him.

The30YardSlant · Dec 17, 2005

He doesnt "suck". He is a second year player with all the talent in the world who makes mistakes. Will he be as good as his brother? Probably not, but he will be a good QB in this league.

Cbz40 · Dec 17, 2005

juckie said:
He will never carry this team very far.He is horrible.And Tiki cant do everything.

and I say you will be eating those words in the very near future.

Gordon · Dec 17, 2005

Don't be ridiculous, it's his 2nd season, he's allowed to struggle.

The same way people said Eli wouldn't have been the 1st pick if his last name wasn't Manning, I say that he wouldn't get near the criticism he gets if his last name wasn't Manning as well.

Hoov · Dec 17, 2005

juckie said:
He will never carry this team very far.He is horrible.And Tiki cant do everything.

but what sthe point of this threasd, just caus ewe're so PO'd right now, lol. the giants just ruined my good buzz. Excuse the typos, moretti is a good itiallian beer, more kick than our dometsics.

TheHustler · Dec 17, 2005

Can official thread titles at least be free of spelling errors?

juck · Dec 17, 2005

I hope he continues to struggle,i dont like the way he dictated where he wanted to go out of the draft beacaue of his daddy and brother.

DragonCowboy · Dec 17, 2005

It's his second year. What if the Cowboys wrote off Aikman after that 1-15 year?

Cbz40 · Dec 17, 2005

Manning has 22 starts in the NFL.....I would say he is ahead of schedule as far as the norm for young QBS

Juke99 · Dec 17, 2005

I understand that a young QB will have problems...as cited, Aikman certainly did.

BUT the thing that would concern me if I was a Giant fan

is that his accuracy is AWFUL...usually a young guy will have problems with the mental part of the game...and their poise...those are not issues with Eli.

His throws are scattershot...ducks...etc..

juck · Dec 17, 2005

i dont care what year it is for him,right now he sucks.and his team around him is good,like big ben last year.

Cbz40 · Dec 17, 2005

Juke99 said:
I understand that a young QB will have problems...as cited, Aikman certainly did.

BUT the thing that would concern me if I was a Giant fan is that his accuracy is AWFUL...usually a young guy will have problems with the mental part of the game...and their poise...those are not issues with Eli.

His throws are scattershot...ducks...etc..

I will have to somewhat disagree......his inaccuracy occurs when he is being pressured, hurried, or when he is forced out of the pocket. As he matures and learns to read D's quicker I think his accuracy improves.

One thing for sure he is learning the NFL game ...playing...and not trying to improve by throwing footballs through a tire somewhere.

The30YardSlant · Dec 17, 2005

I'd trade Bledsoe for Manning in a heartbeat. I'd even drive Drew to the airport, load his luggage, stand on the runway and wish him a fond farewell.

juck · Dec 17, 2005

Y,so we could watch them and wish that the manning on the field was his big brotha?huh,hitta?

Juke99 · Dec 17, 2005

Cbz40 said:
I will have to somewhat disagree......his inaccuracy occurs when he is being pressured, hurried, or when he is forced out of the pocket. As he matures and learns to read D's quicker I think his accuracy improves.

One thing for sure he is learning the NFL game ...playing...and not trying to improve by throwing footballs through a tire somewhere.

Welllllll, I'll have to disagree with you disagreeing with me

....there were more than a few times when he wasn't pressured and he simply missed the open guy...in fact, if you think back to the Denver game, he was under tremendous pressure when he threw the winning TD pass. He seems to do pretty well in pressure situations..

I'm far from a believer at this stage.

Cbz40 · Dec 17, 2005

Juke99 said:
Welllllll, I'll have to disagree with you disagreeing with me ....there were more than a few times when he wasn't pressured and he simply missed the open guy...in fact, if you think back to the Denver game, he was under tremendous pressure when he threw the winning TD pass. He seems to do pretty well in pressure situations..

I'm far from a believer at this stage.

We all get lucky now & then.

I am a believer in his future in this league.....but.....I hope he falls on his face.....otherwise he will be a big pain in our arse for years to come.

Juke99 · Dec 17, 2005

Cbz40 said:
We all get lucky now & then.

I am a believer in his future in this league.....but.....I hope he falls on his face.....otherwise he will be a big pain in our arse for years to come.

Well...let's mark this spot and we can come back and discuss it in 10 years....

Cbz40 · Dec 17, 2005

Juke99 said:
Well...let's mark this spot and we can come back and discuss it in 10 years....

Spot marked!!!!

I predict the Giants and Cowboys will be fighting for the top spot in the division for years to come. Philly will be in the running as well.

Da Hammer · Dec 17, 2005

Right now he does suck, in the future i don't know how good he'll be. Still one big thing going against him is he is playing in NY and everytime he has a bad game (even now) he'll get flamed by the media and fans. Thats not an easy place to play for a young player. Thats why i do think there is a better chance that he'll be a bust rather than a star.

***Official :Eli suks Thread*****

Well-Known Member

Negativity King

Benched

The Grand Poobah

New Member

Senior Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

The Grand Poobah

...Abbey someone

Well-Known Member

The Grand Poobah

Benched

Well-Known Member

...Abbey someone

The Grand Poobah

...Abbey someone

The Grand Poobah

The Natural

*Official :Eli suks Thread***