On a 2nd glance, some observations...

InmanRoshi

Zone Scribe
Messages
18,334
Reaction score
90
Just some things I noticed rewatching game on All-22

This was a good tackling football team on Wednesday Night, and perhaps the reports of Garrett's more physical approach to training camp this year paid off. Giants wide receivers and backs got very, very little yards after contact, and Nicks and Cruz are great YAC guys ... Cruz maybe the best YAC in the league last year. Bradshaw is a very good open field runner too, although NY media speculates that he's lost something from his foot injuries. Maybe an unsung, non-memorable play that exemplifies the tackling came when Eli hit Hynoski on a quick out and Spencer immediately brought him down for a small gain. Hynoski isn't going to remind anyone of Marshall Faulk, so on first glance you really don't appreciate Spencer's tackle. But on All 22, you see that Spencer had nothing but green field behind him, and even Hynoski could have moonwalked 60 yards into the endzone if Spencer doesn't get him on the ground.

In the first quarter a Giants defender ran free off the edge untouched, and Romo used his spin move to leave the guy standing by himself in the pocket. On first glance one might think that the OL allowed a jail break. That defender running into the backfield was actually the outside linebacker who blitzed off of JPP's backpocket off the outside edge . The Cowboys employe an empty backfield, so there was no RB to pick up the blitz. I'm guessing a WR missed his hot read assignment and was supposed to run a hot route to that linebackers vacated area. Romo bailed out someone's mental error.

Our OLBs can get a lot of credit for the goalline stand after Romo's INT. On 1st down the Giants tried to run a strong side stretch run and Spencer just masterfully stacked and shed his guy at the LOS and spilled out the RB to the sideline. The all 22 might give me a better appreciation for Spencer than I previously had. On 2nd down they tried another outside run to Ware's side, and Ware just stood Marty B up to set the edge and forced Bradshaw to cut back insidde into the teeth of the Cowboys pursuit.

Something that doesn't get mentioned enough, IMHO, is how much the injuries on the OL during training camp hurt the rhythm of the running game. It's not only that the OL unit needs some collective cohesion, it's also getting DeMarco getting some feel and timing down with them. The first half the running game and Murray just seemed discombobulated, despite the OL getting some push in their individual assignments. Murray was just half a step slow or half a step fast hitting the hole. As the game wore on they just seemed to get on the same page with their timing better. I also think Murray might have had some early jitters in the game too, and started displaying more of his patience and his vision as the game went along and he relaxed a little bit.

Nate Livings may never have the athletic ability to be a great guard, but he has the raw strength and mentality to be a good guard ... and maybe even a very good guard. A lot of people may remember the play where JPP basically swatted away Tyron Smith like Reggie White 1996 using the hump move to tackle D. Murray in the backfield, but what got overshadowed on that play is a 322 lbs. Linvell Joseph flying sideways after Livings catches him telegraphing a hard inside move and pushes him. On the 13 play drive in the 4th Livings makes two critical combo blocks on a 9 yard and 15 yard Murray runs. He also anchors really well in pass protection and does not get pushed back no matter how big the guy pushing on him. He plays with a little nasty streak too. I imagine he makes a lot of guys wake up sore the next morning. One of those offensive linemen who has that one last shove/punch to throw on his guy right before the whistle blows.

2 plays really showed off how much Dez has progressed as a WR in the offseason. On that square in where he tried to run it in 60 yards after the whistle is blown, he makes a great adjustment. He saw the deep safety shift down into the box during pre-snap, and he runs that square in slips right behind that safety. Romo fires the ball before Dez is out of his break into that area, showing trust Dez is going to be where he's supposed to. His route running is also much cleaner and more crisp. That 9 yard out route he he tapped the two 2 feet in during the 3rd quarter, he buckled Corey Webster's legs planting that foot and making that out cut. Really clean route.


Brandon Carr was left isolated one on one almost all night with zero coverage behind him as the over the top safety shaded to Claiborne's side on most plays.

Romo was a thing of beauty on that 38 yard sideline pass to Dez over the sidelines right before half. Kenny Phillips was actually the only deep safety shading over Dez when the ball was snapped to take away that play. Romo used Jedi Mind Powers to lead Phillips back into the middle of the field with his eyes and away from Dez. By the time Phillips realized he was being manipulated the ball was aleady in the air, Dez was breaking free down the sidelines and it was too late.
 
Great stuff man. Loved the part about Livings. Any insight on Bernadeau? If him and Livings play well, it helps Cook ease into that starting center job. This could also help lead to a big year for D29 and take a ton of pressure off Romo.
 
Glad to see that the film is showing the positives that Spencer provides to this team. I tried to make my points in the offseason about the guy but it's hard to put it in words the impact he makes in the game.

I suspect that there will be a few more players that will turn some heads and cause a change of opinion because of the All-22.
 
Texas_Pete;4716965 said:
Great stuff man. Loved the part about Livings. Any insight on Bernadeau? If him and Livings play well, it helps Cook ease into that starting center job. This could also help lead to a big year for D29 and take a ton of pressure off Romo.

Just from watching the game live it looked like Livings had a very good game while Bernadeau struggled at times but that was just an initial impression. I would love to hear from someone who has seen the all 22 and focused on him.
 
THUMPER;4717021 said:
Just from watching the game live it looked like Livings had a very good game while Bernadeau struggled at times but that was just an initial impression. I would love to hear from someone who has seen the all 22 and focused on him.
Yeah, I remember one play very early in the game where Bernadeau just got creamed. But I wasn't focusing on him and he may have done much better the rest of the game.
 
This is really good stuff. I wonder if this type of access is going to further make mediots irrelevant. But I would not feel sorry for them....they have access to the team....front seat for the game...and all they have done in the last 10 years is print nonsensical garbage that has very little to do with football....and show how low their football IQ is.

Two thumbs up too fans in search of the truth on their own!
 
one needs to tap the brakes a little on the 22 stuff

One problem is that you have to KNOW what the exact assignment is for every player on a particular play to really know how well he did.

Sometimes it is self evident- when the player either is owned or owns

But there are times that you really cannot tell what he was SUPPOSED to be doing
 
happy to read your comments IR

i had commented about the tackling in the preseason games that it looked a lot better and that was my impression in watching the game. i do think it goes back to garrett and it is often a very very important and often underappreciated part of the game

glad to hear about livings and Dez

what Dez was doing was more obvious than what livings was doing, but good to hear
 
my biggest takeaway from the game was HTH did that team just win the SB last year?!!?
I know they lost Jacobs, a TE, and Manningham, all of who they will miss more than they thought...but wow they are and were not an "elite" team.
There really aren't hardly any "elite" teams anymore. NE is the closest thing to "elite" simply because they are always there at the end of the season and have the top QB in the league but they also haven't won a SB in almost a decade. We are significantly better than the NYG this year and I expect to beat them much worse next time.
 
ghst187;4717117 said:
my biggest takeaway from the game was HTH did that team just win the SB last year?!!?
I know they lost Jacobs, a TE, and Manningham, all of who they will miss more than they thought...but wow they are and were not an "elite" team.
There really aren't hardly any "elite" teams anymore. NE is the closest thing to "elite" simply because they are always there at the end of the season and have the top QB in the league but they also haven't won a SB in almost a decade. We are significantly better than the NYG this year and I expect to beat them much worse next time.

The NYG are very streaky. Remember last season they had just lost to the Commanders before beating us and going on their SB run.

You also have to give us credit for going into their house and making a good team look ordinary for the most part. The NYG beat 80% of the NFL teams easily Wednesday night under the circumstances.
 
JohnsKey19;4717134 said:
The NYG are very streaky. Remember last season they had just lost to the Commanders before beating us and going on their SB run.

You also have to give us credit for going into their house and making a good team look ordinary for the most part. The NYG beat 80% of the NFL teams easily Wednesday night under the circumstances.

Def agree on the first part, I'm not so sure on that last part. They have no running game, they lost their power running game as well as one of their top WRs and their only TE. Their secondary is atrocious and injured, they look like a middle pack team this year, of course we all would've said that last year when they had a better roster...:banghead:
 
Pretty much agreed on all points, IR. The All 22 tape has made available conversations that we could never have before. Such a huge addition for the avid football fan.
 
theogt;4717995 said:
Pretty much agreed on all points, IR. The All 22 tape has made available conversations that we could never have before. Such a huge addition for the avid football fan.

Absolutely it can turn an average die-hard fan with limited resources into an 'expert' simply by having access to such a scouts eye perspective.

I expect a major boom in 'pseudo-scouts' with blog history that now have the means to develop educated opinions and really support their positions with actual evidence as opposed to seeing just what the average Fox broadcast shows and making assumptions from there.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,678
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top