On a scale of one to ten, who are the most crucial or important players?

CowboyMcCoy

Business is a Boomin
Messages
12,749
Reaction score
235
Let's play a game. Let's have some off season fun by giving points to the most important players on a scale of 1-10. Or rather let's play where the most important or crucial players this team has, from 1-10. It should look something like, but not exactly as follows. Using my demonstration, you should get the idea.

10 Points -- Romo - Captain of the team, leader of the ship. Without the shifty, savvy and accurate Romo, the Cowboys are still a marginal team. He puts them over the team and is the catalyst of the Dallas Cowboys

9 Points -- I can see where someone may choose Demarcus Ware. However, without Witten I don't think this team has much spunk.

8 Points -- Demarcus Ware has the goods here. He provides exactly what every team wants: a quick, speedy, consistent pass rush. Nobody in the league brings it like Demarcus Ware. Teams have to account for that every time they play us--or risk losing.

7 Points -- Miles Austin makes big plays. He's been the go to guy in the passing game. A team with such emphasis on passing, in a league full of passing teams, needs a big-play threat like the one provided by Miles Austin. One of the leagues top-performers has caught up to the top-five pack of receivers in the game of football, and can be mentioned amongst the best in the league.

6 Points -- Mike Jenkins. Jenkins has been all that we hoped for--and then some.

5 Points - Terrence Newman. Newman hasn't been perfect. But he doesn't need to be. He just needs to be in position to make plays on the ball and give up as few yards as possible. Solidifies the defense. Easily a top 10 corner in the league.

4 Points - Anthony Spencer. Spencer has really beefed up the defensive line. It's not easy for teams to run to one side of the field against the Cowboys. When avoiding Ware, teams also have to account for Specner, who really turned it on as a play maker for the Cowboys.

3 Points -- Jay Ratliff. Boy, was this a diamond in the ruff. The seventh-round pick put Dallas in position to really dominate using the 3-4 defense. If this guy stays healthy, as does the rest of the d-line, this defense is going places in '10.

2 Points -- Brady James. Brady a silent but important contributor to this defense. Not only is he consistent; he's also persistent. Which is part of his act that makes him a good player. That, and he's a tough competitor who adds spark to the Cowboy's defense.

1 Gerald Senabaugh. People rag on his defensive abilities, but there is nothing to rag on as to why we DOMINATED the Eagles offense, 3 games in a row. This was no coincidence. The reason is Gerald Sensabaugh is not only an exciting player for the Cowboy, but from my recollection (and my recollection seems to be fit) is that he whooped up on the Eagles. And he matches up against our division rivals really well.

I've ran out of points, as I had a hard time ordering players with only the given number of points. But it was fun to see how the team broke down when I started using a point system for the most crucial player.

I know it's the off season, but I had fun with it and would look forward to arguments and analysis'. Go Cowboys!
 

artofvela

New Member
Messages
16
Reaction score
0
Jay Ratliff is huge for this defense. Miles Austin is arguably the savior of last season, but I can't see Mike, Newman, or Spence being ahead of him.
 

CowboyMcCoy

Business is a Boomin
Messages
12,749
Reaction score
235
artofvela;3296034 said:
Jay Ratliff is huge for this defense. Miles Austin is arguably the savior of last season, but I can't see Mike, Newman, or Spence being ahead of him.

Your top 10?
 

ThrowuptheXDez88

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,447
Reaction score
454
10. Romo -
9. Ware
8. Ratliff
7. Witten
6. Flozell
5. Felix
4. Jenkins
3. Spencer
2. Miles
1. Brooking
 

CowboyMcCoy

Business is a Boomin
Messages
12,749
Reaction score
235
royw11utdc;3296038 said:
10. Romo -
9. Ware
8. Ratliff
7. Witten
6. Flozell
5. Felix
4. Jenkins
3. Spencer
2. Miles
1. Brooking

I'll take your Brooking at 2 and leave Sensy at 1. Good point.
 

tomson75

Brain Dead Shill
Messages
16,720
Reaction score
1
10. Romo
9. Ware
8. Witten (stock V)
7. Ratliff
6. Austin (stock ^)
5. Adams (Stock V)
4. Jenkins (stock ^)
3. Newman (stock V)
2. Gurode
1. Brooking (stock ^)

Honorable mention: James, Choice, F. Jones, Colombo, Spencer

Quick list before my fiance gets pissed at me...I reserve the right to change later. :D
 

CowboyMcCoy

Business is a Boomin
Messages
12,749
Reaction score
235
tomson75;3296054 said:
10. Romo
9. Ware
8. Witten (stock ^)
7. Ratliff
6. Austin (stock ^)
5. Adams (Stock V)
4. Jenkins (stock ^)
3. Newman (stock --)
2. Gurode (V)
1. Brooking (stock --)

Honorable mention: James, Choice, F. Jones, Colombo, Spencer

Quick list before my fiance gets pissed at me...I reserve the right to change later. :D

FIFY.
 

Rynie

Benched
Messages
4,609
Reaction score
3
10 Points: Nick Folk: Wish we could bring him back. Dude's a beast
and NEVER misses a field goal.

9: Roy Williams: So good. Never misses a catch or runs the wrong route.
EVER!

8. Flozell Adams: He never gets penalties. We NEED this guy!

7. Suisham: Why did we ever let him go? Like folk, he NEVER misses field-
goals. I wish we could have both. We wouldn't even need to
score touchdowns.

8. Philips: He's a tight-end right? We we need him!

7. The water boy: My guys need to stay hydrated! I would put him at
number 1, but Nick Folk is my IDOL!

6. McQuistan: I'm not going to lie. I have no idea what he does.

5. Duke Preston: I just like his name. He sounds noble.

4. The kids that catch the balls the punter is punting when practicing:
Those little guys are go-getters!

3-1. Terrel Owens. He still plays for us right? He's awesome and such a
team-player.
 
Top