Pennington and Romo?

GLIDINGJJ

New Member
Messages
58
Reaction score
0
Ok, I admit I'm a Romo fan. Have been since I went to training camp in San Antonio when he was a Rookie. Myself and my son spent four days watching camp and I formed my own opinions of the QB's in camp that year.

As I recall (and I'm old so forgive me if I missed some camp fodder) the QBs in camp that year were Quincy, Hutchinson, Stoener and Romo. Quincy and Hutch were the chosen ones. Hutch had that California thing going. Blond, big sucker with a big arm, but couldn't hit a bull in the a## with a base fiddle (I mean he missed receivers by yards not feet). Plus he had the Ryan Leaf thing of thinking he was really hot stuff. Sort of arrogant in a non TO way (arrogance is fine if your really that good :). Quincy had the mobility and a decent enough arm, but no touch and threw a really flat, ugly and often erratic ball. Stoener I liked, but the arm strength just wasn't enough, although he had moxie and was quite accurate.

Anyway, Romo seemed to be able to do just about anything he wanted to. He certainly seemed to have enough juice in his arm to make all the throws. He had very good mobility and could actually throw on the run accurately (I'm talking on his back foot, side foot, falling backwards, you name it. He could just throw the ball). He was also a very hard worker and stayed after practice to throw to other rookies trying to make the team. The other thing that I noticed is he threw a perfect spiral and the ball just seemed very easy to catch. Both my son and myself thought there was something special about him and we weren't alone.

Flashing forward three years, and I was setting there thinking about this the other day and suddenly came to the revelation that the closest quarterback out there similar to Romo may be Pennington. They seem similar in their abilities in lots of ways. I think Pennington reads defenses better at this stage (more experience of course), but both are supremely confident in their respective abilities. I think arms are similar (Romo's a bit stronger), but both throw a ball with touch which is easy to catch. Both seem to have the inate ability to hit a receiver in stride (a biggie for sure). I think Romo may be a tad stronger and a lot more mobile.

Ok. Someone throw some rocks at this and tell me what I'm missing. Figure smarter folks then me will have their own opinions on this. :starspin
 

speedkilz88

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,950
Reaction score
23,098
You say Romo has the arm to make all the throws then say its just a tad stronger than Pennington. From everything I have seen Pennington has a noodle arm and I've never been impressed with Romo's just watching preseason games,(but coaches do claim he can make all the throws-according to Babe the worst Cowboys qb of all time)
 

DragonCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,498
Reaction score
250
Why would I throw rocks at this?

I like your thoughts about Romo. Hopefully he'll have a better outcome than Pennington.
 

Yeagermeister

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,629
Reaction score
117
speedkilz88 said:
You say Romo has the arm to make all the throws then say its just a tad stronger than Pennington. From everything I have seen Pennington has a noodle arm and I've never been impressed with Romo's just watching preseason games,(but coaches do claim he can make all the throws-according to Babe the worst Cowboys qb of all time)
Yeah having your arm strength compared to Pennington is not a compliment.
 

GLIDINGJJ

New Member
Messages
58
Reaction score
0
speedkilz88 said:
You say Romo has the arm to make all the throws then say its just a tad stronger than Pennington. From everything I have seen Pennington has a noodle arm and I've never been impressed with Romo's just watching preseason games,(but coaches do claim he can make all the throws-according to Babe the worst Cowboys qb of all time)
I mean Pennington's arm before he ripped his shoulder up. I agree, it is indeed a "noodle" arm now.
 

Cajuncowboy

Preacher From The Black Lagoon
Messages
27,499
Reaction score
81
DragonCowboy said:
Why would I throw rocks at this?

I like your thoughts about Romo. Hopefully he'll have a better outcome than Pennington.

If he just stays healthy he will have a better outcome than Pennington.
 

Yeagermeister

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,629
Reaction score
117
GLIDINGJJ said:
I mean Pennington's arm before he ripped his shoulder up. I agree, it is indeed a "noodle" arm now.
He never had a strong arm before the injury. He had a good arm but not great.
 
Messages
51
Reaction score
0
Only a moron would think Romo has a noodle arm. Heck out of combine he tested very high on speed velocity. Romo has a knack for accurately hitting receivers in stride with the football. Thats more important than having a strong armed loose cannon.
 

JBond

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,028
Reaction score
3,491
Drew Brees may be closer in style and strength than Pennington.
 

LD Fan

New Member
Messages
611
Reaction score
0
Yeagermeister said:
He never had a strong arm before the injury. He had a good arm but not great.

And the original poster said he had a better arm than Pennington, which you just said was strong.......sounds "strong enough" if all the other tools are there to me. You want a cannon, go get one of the guys with cannons who are carrying clip boards on Sunday. I'll take a guy who has touch, can move, read defenses and all the other stuff.
 

wileedog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,356
Reaction score
2,393
Yeagermeister said:
Yeah having your arm strength compared to Pennington is not a compliment.

I would compare Pennington's arm strength to Joe Montana's.

Brady doesn't remind anyone of Aikman either when considering velocity and accuracy.

There is more to QB than arm strength. A lot of guys have been very succssful without having a cannon. Conversely, a lot of guys with big time arms have failed miserably.

QB is first and foremost a mental position. If you have the mental part, you can in large part compensate for not having the best arm. The reverse is rarely true.
 

Vertigo_17

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,278
Reaction score
56
Romo's arm is nothing to get excited about IMO. For whatever reason (gulp)...he reminds me of Jeff Garcia minus the lifestyle.
 
Top