Peyton vs McCarthy for HC

[john van brocklin]

I would say that Peyton would be my first choice in a vacuum.

But he would cost multiple draft picks in compensation.

McCarthy would cost salary only.

They have very similar coaching records and both have won Super bowls.

I would take McCarthy and keep the draft picks, thank you!

Hope we hire a proven NFL coach and don't go the College route.

Your thoughts ?

 

[ultron]

Sean Payton just signed a contract extension and the saints aren't going to let him go.

 

[foofighters]

Sean Payton just signed a contract extension and the saints aren't going to let him go.

This x 1,000,000 and people just need to let it go.

 

[basilhayden]

I have seen people in the past couple of days worried that McCarthy will not be an upgrade.
Based on what?

 

[john van brocklin]

Sean Payton just signed a contract extension and the saints aren't going to let him go.

Prolly would for multiple picks , like when Oakland traded Gruden to Tampa Bay.

 

[Stash]

I would say that Peyton would be my first choice in a vacuum.

But he would cost multiple draft picks in compensation.

McCarthy would cost salary only.

They have very similar coaching records and both have won Super bowls.

I would take McCarthy and keep the draft picks, thank you!

Hope we hire a proven NFL coach and don't go the College route.

Your thoughts ?

My thought is this. McCarthy was fired and his team immediately went 13-3 and are the #2 seed.


Mic drop.

 

[john van brocklin]

I have seen people in the past couple of days worried that McCarthy will not be an upgrade.
Based on what?

Seriously?
Be a major upgrade!

 

[Stash]

Prolly would for multiple picks , like when Oakland traded Gruden to Tampa Bay.

No.

 

[big dog cowboy]

I would say that Peyton would be my first choice in a vacuum.

But he would cost multiple draft picks in compensation.

Not interested in trading for a HC. The Cowboys need the draft capital.

 

[Stash]

I have seen people in the past couple of days worried that McCarthy will not be an upgrade.
Based on what?

The fact that his team went 13-3 the year after firing him.

 

[john van brocklin]

My thought is this. McCarthy was fired and his team immediately went 13-3 and are the #2 seed.


Mic drop.

Not saying he is wart free, but who else available is better ?

 

[Stash]

Not saying he is wart free, but who else available is better ?

Urban Meyer off the top of my head.

Read the ‘For those who want McCarthy’ thread and the accompanying article. Then never mention his name again.

 

[john van brocklin]

Not interested in trading for a HC. The Cowboys need the draft capital.

Agreed !

 

[john van brocklin]

Urban Meyer off the top of my head.

Read the ‘For those who want McCarthy’ thread and the accompanying article. Then never mention his name again.

NFL Experience

 

[CF74]

Is this even a real issue???

 

[Whyjerry]

Didn’t Meyer say he wanted the job? When a coach of that caliber lobbies for a job he gets hired immediately correct???

Except in Dallas...

 

[cowboy_ron]

Hey Sean, the good news........we've traded for you to be the new Dallas Cowboys head coach

The bad news...... you'll have no draft picks till 2023

 

[john van brocklin]

Hey Sean, the good news........we've traded for you to be the new Dallas Cowboys head coach

The bad news...... you'll have no draft picks till 2023

LOL. good news/bad news

 

[Stash]

NFL Experience

Overrated in my opinion.
Jimmy didn’t have it and win it all.
Same for Switzer.

If a guy can innovate, inspire, and hold players accountable, he can win. At any level. That’s my opinion.

 

[nalam]

Mccarthy is a intriguing prospect , he got a good record in GB , The offense was always good , had decent defense most years , but one problem is he had Aaron rodgers , how much minus with a QB like Dak or a new pick ?