PFT: Dak; QBs are judged by winning that last game

[Relayer]

according to fish they are planning on giving dak another extension.
It depends on what happens this year and maybe in 27. How dak does. lol

I mean for me if he isnt real good you gotta get a cheaper one. but only if they are going to spend that extra $ on some other good players they need.

Maybe they are and maybe they aren't. Fish doesn't know. I doubt Jerry does.

 

[Relayer]

Dak is capable of making those same throws, but not nearly as consistently. Remember Stafford’s first year with the lambs? I think he threw like 25 interceptions. He’s better than Dak but not as great as some of you want to make him out to be. And don’t get me wrong, I like Matt and he is great.

I stick by my assessment. And no, Dak has never played with that kind of control and accuracy. NEVER.

 

[Relayer]

I don’t think so. They all have different skill sets for sure but I honestly don’t think there’s a difference in Lamar and Dak. I don’t think Herbert is inferior to Stafford. Goff and Dak are the same caliber. Josh Allen I can hear the argument but to me he’s closer to Lamar than he is Mahomes. Might be a hot take. I feel it’s Mahomes and then about 8 other guys.

Jackson is in the middle of the top 10 somewhere. Dak, not even sure he makes it regularly.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Put their lives on the line? A bit dramatic.

You think so? We aren’t that far removed from the Bills safety actually dying on the field and being brought back to life. I’m not equating them to our military and servicemen but these guys for sure out their lives out there.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Jackson is in the middle of the top 10 somewhere. Dak, not even sure he makes it regularly.

Which is why I said 2-10 is interchangeable. Lamar is a 2 time MVP and Josh is widely regarded as the second best QB. M it’s just a silly discussion to me. Stafford was rarely mentioned in the top 5 until he got with McVay. Darnold
Never mentioned at all. Hurts is rarely mentioned. Meanwhile he’s played in two SBs and outplayed Mahomes in both but nobody would ever say he’s better than Mahomes or even top 5. They will say he’s “carried”. It’s just what it is.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

I stick by my assessment. And no, Dak has never played with that kind of control and accuracy. NEVER.

He hasn’t?

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

The ones who want to compare Stafford's playoff success with Detroit vs Dak's in Dallas. And I agree with you on the idiocy.

But Stafford record in Detroit wasn't that good.
He got a good defense around him. A top notch coach.
He cashed in

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Dak has had really good teams. It's been 10 years not one or two. His teams were better before his last contract.

No denying we have some good teams, maybe 3, 4 years. But a lot of flawed teams as well.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

I was asked a question and answered it. That is about Dak's actual cash value. And like I've said before I would have traded him before I signed him for $40M the first time. I said it when his demands first leaked. I was right then and nothing's changed to prove me wrong.

I actually advocated for us not to resign Dak this last time around.

It would have been better for Dak.

Force Dallas into a rebuild

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Have you actually watched Stafford play? Did you watch the game winning drive in the SB? They had Kupp covered with a blanket and he still found the tightest of windows to get him the ball. Dak's arm isn't even in the same league as Stafford's. There really isn't much comparison talent wise.

I did say,

When given good defense and good coach, he. Ashed in. Good QBs need help and when they have it, they cash in.

 

[Relayer]

You think so? We aren’t that far removed from the Bills safety actually dying on the field and being brought back to life. I’m not equating them to our military and servicemen but these guys for sure out their lives out there.

Like that's a common thing? That is about the most freaky thing ever to get hit in the chest at the exact moment that would stop his heart. We've never seen it before and are likely to never see it again. Someone is about as likely to be struck by lightning on a sunny day.

 

[Relayer]

I did say,

When given good defense and good coach, he. Ashed in. Good QBs need help and when they have it, they cash in.

Dak has had that and didn't cash in. McCarthy was a very good coach. Not McVey, but worse coaches than McVey have won SBs. Look at Philly.

 

[Relayer]

I actually advocated for us not to resign Dak this last time around.

It would have been better for Dak.

Force Dallas into a rebuild

I can't imagine what could be better for Dak than the contracts he's signed in Dallas. I don't think he would have won a SB anywhere else either.

 

[DarkVader33]

Are you trying to start a debate we'd never be allowed to have here?

The one you started? No we can leave it as is.

 

[DarkVader33]

I stick by my assessment. And no, Dak has never played with that kind of control and accuracy. NEVER.

That is a completely false statement. He has made throws like that. Not enough? Sure, he is inconsistent. At least try to be honest.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Dak has had that and didn't cash in. McCarthy was a very good coach. Not McVey, but worse coaches than McVey have won SBs. Look at Philly.

Seriously!!! McCarthy...he is done.

And yes all kinds of coaches have won superbowls. Each team has been different. But Stafford, and I am saying he is good, had good teams in Detroit and didnt do much.

McVeyb is a great coach. Great offensive mind, took Goff to the superbowl and came very very very close to winning it. So Rams had a good team in place. Added more pieces to the defense and went all in and won it. Didnt dominate but pulled it out instead of falling g short

Yes, look at Philly. It took Barkley and a great great defense to win it. Give me that typenof dominant defense everyear.

Like I said, Dak did have some good teams and failed. Other times the team was flawed.

Such is life under Jerry Jones.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

I can't imagine what could be better for Dak than the contracts he's signed in Dallas. I don't think he would have won a SB anywhere else either.

Would have had better opportunity else where where focusnis football. Not marketing.

Just look at Seattle.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Like that's a common thing? That is about the most freaky thing ever to get hit in the chest at the exact moment that would stop his heart. We've never seen it before and are likely to never see it again. Someone is about as likely to be struck by lightning on a sunny day.

We see all types of athletes die before they hit 40. This is a dangerous sport. I get it doesn’t happen frequently but they are still risking their lives and bodies. Last I heard from Byron Jones is he can’t walk and he was in his 30s when he said.

You don’t hear about the same stories from NBA and NHL guys.

 

[DandyDon52]

Maybe they are and maybe they aren't. Fish doesn't know. I doubt Jerry does.

Thing is fish wouldnt say that unless someone in the building said that was the plan.
That plan could change though.

 

[diamonddelts]

When Dak leaves you are gonna be just like the Romosexuals do with Romo and revise history and talk about how good he really was lol. Romo went from a solid qb who choked in the playoffs to Tom Brady and Dan Marino once he retired. They miss you when you gone lol.

I will not on both counts.