Philly had Reid for a decade

[3rdEyewarrior]

Like Jeff Garcia and Romo made TO feel supported? TO was just full of himself. You can’t put that split on McNabb.

T o was paid in Dallas.

 

[quickccc]

Simms was a bus driver. That’s why I pick parcels as the g o a t. He won twice with bus drivers. He took q Carter to the playoffs.

Simms was Jeff Hostler, ...Trent Dilfer .. Nick Foles.... ,Joe Flacco ...

, that's not the same as sheer HOF difference makers like Brady and Mahomes

 

[Cabrito]

Eagles still can't win a superbowl with Andy Reid on the field.

 

[3rdEyewarrior]

He was held back by his FO. See how McNabb played with TO. That would have been a problem for the league for while if they kept them together. The Eagles never had a #1 WR other than Jackson. Andy’s Eagles teams were no where near this Eagles team when it comes to personal.

What happened after d jack came? He had two number ones abd still lost his job.

 

[Reid1boys]

He had a great offense with Alex smith. He finally has a all time great q b.

what was his best playoff run with that great offense when Smith was running things?

 

[Reid1boys]

He went to a Super Bowl with Mcnabb…
Mcnabb.

yea???? and Mcnabb was an MVP candidate that season. McNabb was one of the best qbs in the nfc over that five year run... but, like I keep saying, Reid coached for 20 years and won no titles. Mahomes shows up..... wala..... keep the Lombardis coming baby.

 

[gimmesix]

He always gave bellicheck prices blend with his offense. Now he’s winning superbowls. It just shows how much his other q b held him back.

Those other 52 players also might have had a little to do with it.

 

[Flamma]

He was held back by his FO. See how McNabb played with TO. That would have been a problem for the league for while if they kept them together. The Eagles never had a #1 WR other than Jackson. Andy’s Eagles teams were no where near this Eagles team when it comes to personal.

Wha he did with that team was impressive. They went to a SB and multiple NFC championship games. What was it, 4 or 5? That's not easy to do without a stacked team.

 

[8FOR!3]

Exactly.

He had guys like Todd Pinkston, James Thrash, Greg Lewis and Freddie Mitchell

It's also not fair to really compare McNabb to Mahomes. McNabb didn't hold him back, but Mahomes will definitely elevate your team.

 

[Zman5]

you cant win with the Dirt Killer.

Just Shows you how great of coach Reid was going to multiple NFCC and a SB with that Dirt Killer.

 

[Zman5]

McNabb was a very good to great (At times) QB. I don't think he held them back.

The receivers (Sans a year of TO) were truly awful. He had Westbrook and not much else.

Reid isn't a product of Mahomes either. He made the postseason four times with Smith.

McFLabb was a career 59% passer. Those are backup numbers at best. Reid made him look much better than he actually was.

 

[KJJ]

He always gave bellicheck prices blend with his offense. Now he’s winning superbowls. It just shows how much his other q b held him back.

He had a lot of success with Donovan McNabb, but Mahomes is in another stratosphere. If his career ended tonight he would already be a first ballot Hall of Famer.

 

[infamousstyles]

Nothing is better than seeing classy likeable Andy Reid beat toolbag sirianni. The eagles pushed him out the door so I love seeing him win against them.

 

[3rdEyewarrior]

Nothing is better than seeing classy likeable Andy Reid beat toolbag sirianni. The eagles pushed him out the door so I love seeing him win against them.

Mcnabb was dak with better legs abd a bigger arm.

 

[Pass2Run]

Their WRs sucked, but those early 2000s Eagles squads were loaded. Jim Johnson's defense was top 5 every year.

McNabb was a better QB tho.

 

[Pass2Run]

I mean, if you're a Philthy phan, that has got to sting a little.

Makes me say hallelujah.

Can I get an Amen?

 

[Pass2Run]

Just Shows you how great of coach Reid was going to multiple NFCC and a SB with that Dirt Killer.

Probably top 5 in the NFL.

 

[khiladi]

He went to a Super Bowl with Mcnabb…
Mcnabb.

I remember McNabb would have this habit at times of basically throwing the ball into the turf at odd times.