Post Supplemental Mocks

[jterrell]

OTC using Optimum:
16
ILB C.J. MOSLEY
ALABAMA
47
DT TIMMY JERNIGAN
FLORIDA STATE
78
DE CHRIS SMITH
ARKANSAS
119
WR MARTAVIUS BRYANT
CLEMSON
158
DT KELCY QUARLES
SOUTH CAROLINA
229
S TELVIN SMITH
FLORIDA STATE
231
TE CROCKETT GILMORE
COLORADO STATE
238
OT MICHAEL SCHOFIELD
MICHIGAN
248
QB JEFF MATTHEWS
CORNELL
251
CB DONTAE JOHNSON
NC STATE
254
G RYAN GROY
WISCONSIN

Thoughts: Not happy about lack of OL. Groy is a solid add late but not much meat there.

OTC using WalterFootball Board

16
WR MIKE EVANS
TEXAS A&M
47
DE SCOTT CRICHTON
OREGON STATE
78
C TRAVIS SWANSON
ARKANSAS
119
RB CHARLES SIMS
WVU
158
DE KAREEM MARTIN
NORTH CAROLINA
229
WR JALEN SAUNDERS
OKLAHOMA
231
CB BENE BENWIKERE
SAN JOSE STATE
238
DE AARON LYNCH
USF
248
FB TREY MILLARD
OKLAHOMA
251
DT CALVIN BARNETT
OKLAHOMA STATE
254
QB JEFF MATHEWS
CORNELL

thoughts: Went BPA virtually every pick. Hated going Evans but it paid off when Crichton was there in r2. Loved my last 6 picks. All insane r7 values imho. Wish my r3 OL was a pure Guard but it is what it is and at best available had to go that route.

 

[xwalker]

You got a lot of talent in both drafts. If Evans is available, you almost have to pick him; although, in the real draft I think another team would offer a premium to trade up for him.

I think you could do better on all of your OL picks.

 

[Hardline]

Timmy Jernagen will not make it out of the first round .

 

[xwalker]

FYI - They're compensatory picks not supplemental.

 

[jterrell]

You got a lot of talent in both drafts. If Evans is available, you almost have to pick him; although, in the real draft I think another team would offer a premium to trade up for him.

I think you could do better on all of your OL picks.

yup if trades were offered at chart value i'd be moving down in r1.

and i didn't like the OL value in the mocks but wont argue there may be other guys i underrate.
certainly didnt study ol as i did last off-season.

and of course you are correct about compensatory v supplemental.

 

[jterrell]

Timmy Jernagen will not make it out of the first round .

he was in this mock so i had to take him.
every mock plays out a bit different but i tend to agree with you that he is gone in the 1st.

 

[casmith07]

Quite a few sims have Jernigan falling to the 2nd round. I don't think there's anyway it happens in real life though.

 

[xwalker]

yup if trades were offered at chart value i'd be moving down in r1.

and i didn't like the OL value in the mocks but wont argue there may be other guys i underrate.
certainly didnt study ol as i did last off-season.

and of course you are correct about compensatory v supplemental.

You and I disagree a lot but I appreciate your posts. I know that you put effort into real football topics.

The more "Jerry sucks" posts that I see the more I realize the value of real football related posts, even the ones I disagree with.

 

[jterrell]

You and I disagree a lot but I appreciate your posts. I know that you put effort into real football topics.

The more "Jerry sucks" posts that I see the more I realize the value of real football related posts, even the ones I disagree with.

We go at each other pretty hard in threads because we are both passionate about the subject.
I absolutely respect that. And I read all your posts because they will say something actually relevant and football related.
You bring a ton of legwork and meat to any debate which is why I'd certainly be looking to hire people like you were I Jerry or Stephen Jones

You need passionate and even argumentative people to get at the right decisions. No one needs yes men around them.

 

[Fredd]

We go at each other pretty hard in threads because we are both passionate about the subject.
I absolutely respect that. And I read all your posts because they will say something actually relevant and football related.
You bring a ton of legwork and meat to any debate which is why I'd certainly be looking to hire people like you were I Jerry or Stephen Jones

You need passionate and even argumentative people to get at the right decisions. No one needs yes men around them.

I disagree

j/k....I like both of the mocks that you have in here and would walk away from the draft very happy with either...but, like the first much better, likely because I think that Chris Smith has the potential to be very good and the other 5 out of the first 6 could start for us at some point

 

[Idgit]

You and I disagree a lot but I appreciate your posts. I know that you put effort into real football topics.

The more "Jerry sucks" posts that I see the more I realize the value of real football related posts, even the ones I disagree with.

We go at each other pretty hard in threads because we are both passionate about the subject.
I absolutely respect that. And I read all your posts because they will say something actually relevant and football related.
You bring a ton of legwork and meat to any debate which is why I'd certainly be looking to hire people like you were I Jerry or Stephen Jones

You need passionate and even argumentative people to get at the right decisions. No one needs yes men around them.

Group hug, guys. I read every one of each of your posts, for the same reasons. Always informed, always thoughtful.

 

[AsthmaField]

Group hug, guys. I read every one of each of your posts, for the same reasons. Always informed, always thoughtful.

I'll echo that sentiment as well. Football savvy posters are few and far between. I'll read either side of an argument and can be swayed if it is laid out logically and passionately.

Kudos to everyone who can really talk football and not just gripe about the current state of things.

 

[Idgit]

I'll echo that sentiment as well. Football savvy posters are few and far between. I'll read either side of an argument and can be swayed if it is laid out logically and passionately.

Kudos to everyone who can really talk football and not just gripe about the current state of things.

Come to think of it, this is actually a thread full of the posters I like to read, with none of the guys I just have to read to moderate content.

 

[AsthmaField]

Come to think of it, this is actually a thread full of the posters I like to read, with none of the guys I just have to read to moderate content.

Yeah, threads started by jterrell tend to bring out the better football posters because what he writes is almost always quality posts.