Pre Super Bowl, Post-season QB ratings

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,981
Reaction score
48,728
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
1000x...team wins is the bottom line. I think (hope) we all get that.

Having said that, here are the NFL post-season QB ratings thru championship weekend.

  1. Tony Romo...125.8
  2. Joe Flacco...100.7
  3. Tom Brady..99.8
  4. Aaron Rodgers...91.1
  5. Matt Stafford...87.7
  6. Russell Wilson...81.9
  7. Cam Newton...80.8
  8. Ben Roethlisberger..79.3
  9. Peyton Manning...75,5
  10. Andrew Luck...71.8
  11. Andy Dalton...63.4
  12. Ryan Lindley..44.3
 

Staubacher

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,311
Reaction score
23,739
Yep. Defense is still king in the NFL.

I said all season we did not have a championship defense. Obvious I know, but sooner or later it would cost us.

The D overachieved, battled, and closed out a few games. But the stagecoach turned into a pumpkin on those last 3 drives vs GB. Poor pass rush, tackling, coverage.

Romo played as well as you could ask and then some. No turnovers, made big plays, led long drives, made plays in the end of games. Everything a QB needs to do to win in the playoffs.

It just never seems to work out for the guy.

Wilson stunk for 56 minutes. Rodgers was pedestrian. If Romo has a game like that no way our team even has a chance to win in the playoffs.
 

perrykemp

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,503
Reaction score
9,274
1000x...team wins is the bottom line. I think (hope) we all get that.

Having said that, here are the NFL post-season QB ratings thru championship weekend.

  1. Tony Romo...125.8
  2. Joe Flacco...100.7
  3. Tom Brady..99.8
  4. Aaron Rodgers...91.1
  5. Matt Stafford...87.7
  6. Russell Wilson...81.9
  7. Cam Newton...80.8
  8. Ben Roethlisberger..79.3
  9. Peyton Manning...75,5
  10. Andrew Luck...71.8
  11. Andy Dalton...63.4
  12. Ryan Lindley..44.3

Good stuff. Thank for posting.

In terms of ESPN QBR, the postseason ratings are as follows:

1. Flacco 85.8
2. Brady 77.3
3. Rodgers 69.8
4. Luck 69.2
5. Romo 54.9
6. Wilson 44.8
7. Roethlisberger 37.8
8. Stafford 36.3
9. Cam Newton 35.3
10. Manning 27.9
11. Dalton 20.0
12. Lindley 6.1
 

Plankton

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,257
Reaction score
18,644
What that list shows is how unbelievably bad Ryan Lindley is as a QB. Absolutely dreadful, as in shouldn't be in the league bad.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,981
Reaction score
48,728
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
QB's Playoff Rating vs Playoff Opponents' Pass Defenses' Season Rating

Romo +43.3
Brady +10.1
Flacco +9.5
Rodgers +6.6
Stafford -0.8
Newton -2.4
Wilson -3.9
Luck -8.9
Roethlisberger -11.3
Manning -12.2
Dalton -25.3
Lindley -45.2

probably the most telling of all.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,981
Reaction score
48,728
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
What that list shows is how unbelievably bad Ryan Lindley is as a QB. Absolutely dreadful, as in shouldn't be in the league bad.

lol..ouch
Maybe true.
But it was only game in his case. Really tiny sample size and for a guy who got thrown to the wolves.

For perspective, Russell Wilson's rating yesterday was 44.3.... even worse than Lindley's
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,307
Reaction score
63,996
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
125.8

Football is the ultimate team sport. Even so, offseasen rhetoric will over-emphasize Romo holding onto the ball too long while under-emphasizing (or just not commenting at all about) a critical fumble, a tipped field goal attempt, and missed tackle after missed tackle on defense. And Romo throwing a perfect pass on 4th down late in a do-or-die game? Well, he gets zero credit for doing his job as well as the best quarterbacks in today's game because of a reversed call.

125.8

It is just another number Romo critics will dismiss while assigning inappropriate blame on him. Again.
 

Fritsch_the_cat

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,749
Reaction score
4,138
I said all season we did not have a championship defense.

They haven't had one for several seasons, because many NFL teams seem to think in this pass happy day and age that defense and the running game no longer matter. This season reminds everyone how important those two parts of the game still are.
 

Plankton

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,257
Reaction score
18,644
125.8

Football is the ultimate team sport. Even so, offseasen rhetoric will over-emphasize Romo holding onto the ball too long while under-emphasizing (or just not commenting at all about) a critical fumble, a tipped field goal attempt, and missed tackle after missed tackle on defense. And Romo throwing a perfect pass on 4th down late in a do-or-die game? Well, he gets zero credit for doing his job as well as the best quarterbacks in today's game because of a reversed call.

125.8

It is just another number Romo critics will dismiss while assigning inappropriate blame on him. Again.

I haven't seen Romo get criticized at all for the loss to the Packers. Not one bit.
 

Staubacher

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,311
Reaction score
23,739
I haven't seen Romo get criticized at all for the loss to the Packers. Not one bit.

People like Broaddus and Sturm were on his jock for the 4th and 2 play. Because you know, he could do better than hitting Dez one on one for a go ahead score.

Mostly "friendly fire" though. Nothing much from the national media.
 

percyhoward

Research Tool
Messages
17,062
Reaction score
21,861
125.8

Football is the ultimate team sport. Even so, offseasen rhetoric will over-emphasize Romo holding onto the ball too long while under-emphasizing (or just not commenting at all about) a critical fumble, a tipped field goal attempt, and missed tackle after missed tackle on defense. And Romo throwing a perfect pass on 4th down late in a do-or-die game? Well, he gets zero credit for doing his job as well as the best quarterbacks in today's game because of a reversed call.

125.8

It is just another number Romo critics will dismiss while assigning inappropriate blame on him. Again.
As long as we've got a top 5 team, we've got a legitimate shot. That's all you can ask for. We were top 10 in the differentials of the three most important team categories -- points per drive, pass rating, and drive success rate. There were only six teams that managed to do this. Green Bay wasted an even better season than we did, and some of that actually does fall on their QB. The way I look at it, if we can get into this position two or three years in a row, good things are bound to happen.

Cowboys 2014
Points per drive differential 5th (off 2nd, def 16th)
Pass rating differential 2nd (off 1st, def 13th)
Drive Success Rate differential 7th (off 4th, def 24th)

Top 10 in all 3 categories
Green Bay 1st, 1st, 6th
Dallas 5th, 2nd, 7th
Denver 4th, 3rd, 1st
Seattle 3rd, 4th, 2nd
New England 2nd, 5th, 4th
Indianapolis 6th, 8th, 3rd
 
Top