Prisco overated/ undrated NFC East

[RS12]

Dallas Cowboys

Overrated: WR Roy Williams. Has he ever lived up to the hype? He had better now or Dallas will be in trouble at receiver.

Underrated: NT Jay Ratliff. How he didn't make the Pro Bowl last season is a mystery. He was dominant.

New York Giants

Overrated: MLB Antonio Pierce. His bark is bigger than his bite. He is a good player but not nearly as good as some would believe.

Underrated: LT David Diehl. He isn't an elite player, but after moving from guard, he has done a nice job at left tackle.

Philadelphia Eagles

Overrated: RB Brian Westbrook. He's a good player but some think he's great. He doesn't stay on the field, and for a guy who didn't rush for 1,000 yards last season, you'd think he was Adrian Peterson the way some talk about him.

Underrated: S Quentin Mikell. He was the Eagles best safety last season, not Brian Dawkins. He's a good tackler who has improved in pass coverage.

Washington Commanders

Overrated: CB DeAngelo Hall. He played well for the Commanders when he was picked up last season, but he isn't as good as he thinks -- or others think.

Underrated: CB Carlos Rogers. He looked like a Pro Bowl corner at times last season but has some inconsistency. If he can work through that, he should be a better player than Hall.

Kind of suprised by Westbrook.

 

[bbgun]

Underrated: NT Jay Ratliff. How he didn't make the Pro Bowl last season is a mystery. He was dominant.

What?

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Bradie James would be my underrated

 

[CowboyMike]

Bradie James would be my underrated too.

Jay Ratliff made the Pro Bowl...

Anyway...

How can Roy Williams be overrated if really no one is overrating him? Seems like pretty much 100% of the media is bashing him all the time. Who's overrating him?

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Bradie James would be my underrated too.

Jay Ratliff made the Pro Bowl...

Anyway...

How can Roy Williams be overrated if really no one is overrating him? Seems like pretty much 100% of the media is bashing him all the time. Who's overrating him?

Jerry Jones

 

[speedkilz88]

I don't think Roy Williams ever was considered over-rated when he was a Lion. Ratliff not making the pro bowl shows how uninformed Prisco is, his only excuse would have to be he was thinking Bradie James.

 

[Rampage]

Dallas Cowboys

.

New York Giants

Overrated: MLB Antonio Pierce. His bark is bigger than his bite. He is a good player but not nearly as good as some would believe.

I said the same exact thing.

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

Crisco sounds dumb...

 

[Plumfool]

Uninformed!

 

[Ren]

Dallas Cowboys

Overrated: WR Roy Williams. Has he ever lived up to the hype? He had better now or Dallas will be in trouble at receiver.

Underrated: NT Jay Ratliff. How he didn't make the Pro Bowl last season is a mystery. He was dominant.

New York Giants

Overrated: MLB Antonio Pierce. His bark is bigger than his bite. He is a good player but not nearly as good as some would believe.

Underrated: LT David Diehl. He isn't an elite player, but after moving from guard, he has done a nice job at left tackle.

Philadelphia Eagles

Overrated: RB Brian Westbrook. He's a good player but some think he's great. He doesn't stay on the field, and for a guy who didn't rush for 1,000 yards last season, you'd think he was Adrian Peterson the way some talk about him.

Underrated: S Quentin Mikell. He was the Eagles best safety last season, not Brian Dawkins. He's a good tackler who has improved in pass coverage.

Washington Commanders

Overrated: CB DeAngelo Hall. He played well for the Commanders when he was picked up last season, but he isn't as good as he thinks -- or others think.

Underrated: CB Carlos Rogers. He looked like a Pro Bowl corner at times last season but has some inconsistency. If he can work through that, he should be a better player than Hall.

Kind of suprised by Westbrook.

really... wow :laugh1:

 

[CM Duck]

I said the same exact thing.

so did I a few weeks, or months back and I got roasted by some of the poeple on here that drink the Pierce flavored kool-aid...

ehh, oh well. Prisco doesn't seem uninformed about everything IMO

 

[gimmesix]

Dallas Cowboys

Overrated: WR Roy Williams. Has he ever lived up to the hype? He had better now or Dallas will be in trouble at receiver.

Underrated: NT Jay Ratliff. How he didn't make the Pro Bowl last season is a mystery. He was dominant.

How Prisco didn't know that Ratliff made the Pro Bowl last season isn't a mystery ... he's a headline-watching NFL hack who doesn't pay enough attention to what's really going on to have an informed opinion.

 

[Yakuza Rich]

I thought saying that Carlos Rogers played like a pro bowler at times last year was a mystery to me. When did that happen?



YAKUZA

 

[speedkilz88]

I thought saying that Carlos Rogers played like a pro bowler at times last year was a mystery to me. When did that happen?



YAKUZA

The only thing I could come up with is that he looked like a pro bowler when comparing him to DeAngelo Hall.

 

[Muhast]

I thought saying that Carlos Rogers played like a pro bowler at times last year was a mystery to me. When did that happen?



YAKUZA

maybe he means, Carlos Rogers played like a probowler..... As in he didnt play very hard at all ( like they play in the actual pro bowl) ??

 

[Hoofbite]

I'd say that is a pretty good list. I don't have much a complaint with any of the picks. Maybe Rogers for WAS. I don't think he is that good at all. Of course, he hasn't really played with anyone worth a piss but he just seems to be an average guy.