He was on the team, so yes he was a Dallas Cowboy. Hate him for being an eagle all you want but when he is inducted it will say Philadelphia Eagle AND Dallas CowboyCarmichael was not a Cowboy. His one catch does not count.
Carmichael is not a Cowboy. lolPlus Jimmy Johnson.......
Harris
Pearson
Carmichael
Johnson
All Cowboy players and a coach. Can't let that happen right
Yes he is. 1984Carmichael is not a Cowboy. lol
no Moose JohnstonThe Canton Screw-Job:
no Chuck Howley.
no Lee Roy Jordan.
no Drew Pearson.
no Ralph Neely.
no Ed too tall Jones.
no Harvey Martin.
no Everson Walls.
no Darren Woodson.
this is sad seeing his disappointment
He was on the team, so yes he was a Dallas Cowboy. Hate him for being an eagle all you want but when he is inducted it will say Philadelphia Eagle AND Dallas Cowboy
Did he put on the cowboys uniform, with a star on his helmet and play in a game for the Cowboys?....... this is a yes or no question.Not in my mind. 2 games, 1 catch. Blah
no Moose.no Moose Johnston
Pearson and Carmichael are contemporaries. They played at essentially the same time. During that time, Pearson was a three-time FIRST TEAM all-pro. Carmichael was a three-time SECOND TEAM all-pro. Pearson was a FIRST TEAM selection for the all-1970s team. Carmichael was a SECOND TEAM selection. Those selections show what the people who were tasked with ranking the players during their careers thought of how they compared. Carmichael was a fine receiver. Does not deserve to be HOF before Pearson, plain and simple. This was a whiff from the selection committee.
Yes, Harris getting in corrects a wrong, but Carmichael's selection along with Pearson's omission creates another.
Always.Mr. Clutch
The Canton Screw-Job:
no Chuck Howley
no Lee Roy Jordan
no Drew Pearson
no Ralph Neely
no Ed Too Tall Jones
no Harvey Martin
no Everson Walls
no Darren Woodson
no Moose Johnson
no Don Meredith
no Don Perkins
no Cornell Green
no Herschel Walker
no Big Nate Newton
no John Niland
no Blaine Nye
this is sad seeing his disappointment
Did he put on the cowboys uniform, with a star on his helmet and play in a game for the Cowboys?....... this is a yes or no question.
A forgettable year as well.Yes he is. 1984
I don't even remember him as a Cowboy. That's how little he is to this team. At least with Mike Ditka he contributed and coached here. He went in as a Bear but I consider him a Cowboy too.Do I care? nope. he was an eagle. nobody cares that he played 2 games. his HOF credentials are from the other team.