Random thoughts

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Giving up a punt return was......disappointing. It couldn't have come at a worse time either.

Why can't we cover Steve Smith? We do a great job on that other one. Well, here's my take. He's getting a lot of it in the soft spots. He's getting a lot of it against Scandrick and from our safeties not named Sensabaugh. He owns Scandrick.

Speaking of Scandrick, there were a lot of missed tackles in the game even if they were only the kind to grant a few extra yards.

The holding generally evens out in a game. It appeared at times to favor the Giants. The hold on Sensabaugh was particularly troublesome. Not blaming the refs as I have no idea if that changes the outcome of the game. Probably not. It is random thoughts, right?

The team seems to find ways to lose games at times. Our offense was better overall. Not in the points department though discounting the last TD if I may. STs took one on the chin in this department. So did the defense. It cost us the game. Two big plays.

It's not the end of the world. STs sucked one play o/w looked fine. That's a hiccup. One bad play by Spencer and some luck (I'm guessing the play wasn't designed to isolate Jacobs that well) on defense. The offense played well although again more points per yards gained would be nice. So we don't suck even though half the fans have gone nutso.

RW started slow but finished strong. Heh, that's a big positive. He did miss that one TD throw. And he looks for too many holding calls IMO. He was interfered with at least once today. Good interference by the Giants I guess.

Despite not going anywhere in the run department, there's no need to fire Barber or Garrett. The runs are necessary to put us into favorable third down conversion territory. We don't do well generally in third and long. We converted a lot of third downs this evening. Just not enough I guess.

And speaking of the above I thought the DC for the Giants had a great game plan. Unfortunately. They stacked the box and did some run blitzing and stopped the run. They were also plenty physical IMO.

Garrett was ok tonite overall. I'd give him just a C. What disappoints me is the lack of downfield passing. I'm talking about the big pass not the intermediate ones. Both Austin and Williams beat the Giants long. We should see more of that. Not saying give up on those Witten et al intermediate routes they do so well. Just throw the ball downfield on occasion. That's got Dallas written all over it. Deep shots Red.

Romo was better than ok. Not red hot but good. None of those amazingly inaccurate throws especially the high ones. The last TD to Austin was a pretty good throw. He did his job IMO.

I say nonsense about all this OL talk. Yeah they didn't blow them off the ball despite them selling out for the run. The protection was not great but good enough. The OL didn't cost this team a win.

The Giants were desperate. Not an excuse as there isn't one. But a loss today would likely have ended their playoff hopes. They aren't good enough to win out IMO. They will lose another game or two before its over. But they played desperate.

Speaking of desperate. How come the Cowboys didn't play desperate? Well they didn't. Despite playing at least as well on offense they still didn't display the same amount of physical play. They looked like the Giants wanted it more.

And speaking of that.....why is that? Do the Cowboys lack the desperate will to not lose much less the will to win at all costs? Never once thought that until now. I've seen too much of it. They aren't afraid enough about losing. You must fear losing to the point you don't get beat. I could easily be wrong but I don't sense that about Dallas. They're too refined. Should I say too soft. And I've never thought this until now, but I don't see coaches in their faces often enough. And they certainly don't call them out in public which the Giants' coaches did this week. Questioned their manhood in reality. Said they weren't physical enough. They looked physical enough tonight although that wasn't the difference in the game. The difference was two plays IMO. They didn't have the game to march it down the field consistently. Those two plays won the game. And Dallas wasn't afraid enough to prevent it. That's my take. And if I'm right I can lay that right at Wade's feet. That's right. My first attack on Wade. Not too soft. Too undemanding. No fear.

Well that last should about do it tonite. One last parting thought. How 'bout Witten. Big night and now 2nd overall in pass completions in Dallas Cowboy history. A couple of more years and there's not doubt we're talking HOF here guys. Some history tonight even though it may feel bittersweet.

There's still four more games. We don't suck. And no one else is sneaking up on us. It's the Giants and the Eagles. We are still in first place in the division.

Oh, the Saints are beatable. And we match up well against SD. And I know we can beat the Eagles. The Skins look tougher though.

Don't give up hope fellow zoners.
 

DandyDon1722

It's been a good 'un, ain't it?
Messages
6,386
Reaction score
7,008
Giving the offensive line a pass is VERY generous to say the least. They consistently got beat at the point of attack on running plays and Romo was hurried a lot.

Don't understand giving props to Witten's great day (it was) and say Romo was "better than okay", especially with a career day on the road within the division.

Everything else I agree and I really like the close of your post, I wish I had that in me right now...maybe tomorrow.
 

wileedog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,356
Reaction score
2,393
jobberone;3124262 said:
One bad play by Spencer and some luck (I'm guessing the play wasn't designed to isolate Jacobs that well) on defense. .

So the two TDs in 2 minutes at the end of the half get a pass?
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
wileedog;3124333 said:
So the two TDs in 2 minutes at the end of the half get a pass?

No. One was just the game. I didn't expect a shutout although I agree we give up too many of those last minute scoring drives. It does drive me crazy. I just overlooked it. The short field TD is on the Barber fumble and if you're really a stickler on the offense. I blame it on the runner. Take away the two long scoring plays and the game is too close to call.
 

wileedog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,356
Reaction score
2,393
jobberone;3124382 said:
No. One was just the game. I didn't expect a shutout although I agree we give up too many of those last minute scoring drives. It does drive me crazy. I just overlooked it. The short field TD is on the Barber fumble and if you're really a stickler on the offense. I blame it on the runner.

I see what you're saying, but they didn't even slow the Giants down after the fumble. That's what good D's do - neutralize the TO's.

To me the entire game shifted in the 3 minutes after we scored and went up 10-0. The Giants marched down on 4 plays, got the fumble, and marched in again. The crowd is back into it, the Giants are back into it, and then Flozell is cheap shotting Tuck to even get them more into it.

Horrible series, and say what you want about any other play, those 3 minutes when the defense collapsed entirely changed the game.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
wileedog;3124428 said:
I see what you're saying, but they didn't even slow the Giants down after the fumble. That's what good D's do - neutralize the TO's.

To me the entire game shifted in the 3 minutes after we scored and went up 10-0. The Giants marched down on 4 plays, got the fumble, and marched in again. The crowd is back into it, the Giants are back into it, and then Flozell is cheap shotting Tuck to even get them more into it.

Horrible series, and say what you want about any other play, those 3 minutes when the defense collapsed entirely changed the game.

Well it's a nobrainer they changed the game. But one TO isn't a lot and points off them are frequent. I count that as part of the game. We did the same to them.

But we're still in the game at 14-10. The back breaker was the punt return. The long score was more a fluke play IMO. Sure it counts and yes Spencer played it poorly. But the stars aligned along with a hold to make that a TD. Otherwise we're in this game up to the bitter end.

But I see your point.
 

Doomsay

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,542
Reaction score
6,160
There is no silver lining when you consistently lose winnable games at the end of the season. It is who the Cowboys are.
 

kramskoi

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,387
Reaction score
1,765
Doomsay;3124474 said:
There is no silver lining when you consistently lose winnable games at the end of the season. It is who the Cowboys are.


...and some of us will make excuses for them until their record makes them irrelevant in regards to post-season play...

...this pattern of mental inferiority has turned the Cowboys into the whipping boys of December...i'm not sure that they realize the intensity that has to be maintained on a weekly basis going into the post-season...

...this time of year sees players with tired and bruised bodies...a critical time for coaches to extract/demand the best from their money players...i don't see who the hammer is in the Cowboy's organization right now...
 

TellerMorrow34

BraveHeartFan
Messages
28,358
Reaction score
5,076
I just hate that Romo played so darn good today, did everything he possibly could have, and yet he's still going to keep getting pissed on by morons who don't have a clue whats going on cause our defense decided they didn't want to show up today and allowed the Giants to pretty much do as they please from midway through the second quarter on.

And I'm more than a little tired of Scandrick at this point. I'll admit that after last season I thought he was a steal in the draft. Right now I'm questioning that in a big time way cause the kid just keeps giving up catches all over the field. Once again Steve Smith owned him all over the field from the slot.
 

speedkilz88

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,949
Reaction score
23,097
On the missed pass to Roy in the endzone. Roy really never had a chance to catch that one. Romo sent it a little too deep on that play and then the CB pushed him from behind to prevent him from jumping up for it. It should have been PI, but it would have been an easy td if Romo throws is just a little better.
 

wileedog

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,356
Reaction score
2,393
speedkilz88;3124600 said:
On the missed pass to Roy in the endzone. Roy really never had a chance to catch that one. Romo sent it a little too deep on that play and then the CB pushed him from behind to prevent him from jumping up for it. It should have been PI, but it would have been an easy td if Romo throws is just a little better.

I don't disagree that there may have been a push in the back, but it hit Roy's hands.

And if we are going to go with the theory that the DB pushed Roy, should Tony have thrown the ball somehow compensating for the push in the back?

Can't have it both ways.
 
Top