Rank the NFC East QB's

[JonJon]

How do you rank the NFC East QB's? After this weekend, my rankings look like this:

1. Tony Romo
2. Eli Manning
3. Donovan McNabb
4. Kevin Kolb
5. John Kitna
6. Jason Campbell
7. Michael Vick
8. Todd Collins
9. David Carr

 

[pancakeman]

I'd agree with your top 4. Beyond that we haven't seen enough of them to sort them out.

 

[Tusan_Homichi]

I'd put McNabb above Manning. Other than that, looks like a good list to me.

 

[Big Dakota]

I agree with Kolb over Kitna for the long term. I think it's a toss up for the short term but i'd take both over Campbell. Poor skins.

 

[JonJon]

I agree with Kolb over Kitna for the long term. I think it's a toss up for the short term but i'd take both over Campbell. Poor skins.

After what I saw last night, I was tempted to put Michael Vick above Campbell.

 

[Clove]

Right now, I'd take Romo over all of them, ask me again in a month.

 

[DTK]

For now...

1. Romo
2. McNabb
3. Manning

4. Kolb

5. Kitna

6. Collins
7. Vick
8. Carr



9. Lionel Richie, I mean, Campbell

 

[Future]

After what I saw last night, I was tempted to put Michael Vick above Campbell.

Nahhh...Vick has definitely lost a step and he used to look pretty lost passing too.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

How do you rank the NFC East QB's? After this weekend, my rankings look like this:

1. Tony Romo
2. Eli Manning
3. Donovan McNabb
4. Kevin Kolb
5. John Kitna
6. Jason Campbell
7. Michael Vick
8. Todd Collins
9. David Carr

Where did Kitna come from? :laugh2:

But your list puts it in perspective.
I actually agree with much of your list, not that you need validation from me, albeit a genus.

Good job.

Good night and good luck.

 

[utrunner07]

I know this will probably get flammed, but the top three are all interchangeable. This week it was Romo, Manning, Donavan (IMO), but I don't really think that one stands out head and shoulders above the rest consistently, at least for now.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

After what I saw last night, I was tempted to put Michael Vick above Campbell.

:laugh2:

 

[Cover 2]

I know this will probably get flammed, but the top three are all interchangeable. This week it was Romo, Manning, Donavan (IMO), but I don't really think that one stands out head and shoulders above the rest consistently, at least for now.

I agree with this, although I think by the end of the year Romo will really stand out over the rest.