News: Ranked: The 20 Greatest Quarterbacks in NFL History

[diefree666]

Absolutely agree with how under-rated he sometimes seems to be. During their run that guy was just....wow. And like you said especially in big games. Wasn't he like 11-3 at one point for his playoff career with 3 Superbowls? Just insanely good when it mattered most.

ONLY when he had the complete team though. Before it was built and after it began to come apart he could not do more when he had to. He needed protection that he stopped getting starting in 98 or so. And of course losing Irvin and never replacing him plus the other losses and the D going down hill.
That makes Rodgers so interesting; as like tony he has done the best at making up for weak D, etc. Tony of course was handicapped by having for far too long a lousy Front Office (read GM) and after BP mediocre at best coaching staff. Rodgers has had a very good GM most of the time and CLEARLY superior coaches.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Cant put Troy over the Dodger

Roger was leading the league in passer rating at 36 and 37 yrs old

Troy was very average once his supporting cast deteriorated

 

[FLCowboyFan]

I dont like those pages designed largely to create clicks.
Roger Staubauh was the greatest I saw.
Sammy Baugh was a little ahead of my time but read his was a wizard on the field.
Aikman was a general on the field throwing darts. People dismiss because of stats,Thats so misleading.
I didn't keep going after Aikman

I know they are a pain. They make you click forever to get to the end.

 

[noshame]

I’m sorry but Roger was possibly the best ever and far superior to Aikman. Aikman is only on this list because of wins. Arguments can be made that Romo and White were better players than Troy

No they cannot

 

[Blake]

Wentz is 1. Brady's 2. Peyton is 3. There's a healthy debate after that.

Why do I get the sense that you are an unlikable loner in real life?

 

[LocimusPrime]

Roger and Troy

 

[LocimusPrime]

Wentz is 1. Brady's 2. Peyton is 3. There's a healthy debate after that.

Jerk