Judas;4390130 said:
Name the undrafted QBs who have won a Super Bowl, and then name the number 1 picks who have won, then get back to me. It's like arguing with a fork, nothing gets through.
Undrafted (I'm treating 8th round of later as UD, since the draft is seven rounds today) QBs who were good enough to make as many Pro Bowls as Romo:
Tony Romo - 0 Super Bowl Wins
Warren Moon - 0 Super Bowl Wins
Dave Krieg - 0 Super Bowl Wins
Jim Hart - 0 Super Bowl Wins
Jeff Garcia - 0 Super Bowl Wins
Daryle Lamonica - 0 Super Bowl Wins
Johnny Unitas - 1 Super Bowl Win
Kurt Warner - 1 Super Bowl Win
Bart Starr - 2 Super Bowl Wins
Roger Staubach - 2 Super Bowl Wins
So, 40% got at least one win, and they average 0.8 wins apiece.
1st Round QBs, since 1966:
Total 117
Total Super Bowl Wins: 27 (by 18 different players)
Average: 0.23 Super Bowl wins each
15% won at least one Super Bowl
So, history says that we are at least twice as well off with an undrafted QB as proven as Romo than with a shiny new 1st rounder, and probably more like three times.
The lesson here, kids, is that if you don't do your research before spouting off, your opinion probably won't be worth the 1s and 0s it's printed on.