RBs drafted in 2005, Barber is #?

[TwoCentPlain]

1) Ronnie Brown 1st rd
2) Cedric Benson 1st rd
3) Carnell Williams 1st rd
4)JJ Arrington 2nd rd
5) Eric Shelton 2nd rd
6) Frank Gore 3rd rd
7) Vernand Morency 3rd rd
8) Ryan Moats 3rd rd
9) Maurice Clarett 3rd rd
10) Marion Barber 4th rd
11) Brandon Jacobs 4th rd, next pick right after Barber

Think about the above as you are complaining about wanting Mendenhall. All this talk about Mendenhall vs. Felix Jones is much ado about nothing. 9 RBs were selected before Barber. Interesting that Jacobs was selected right after Barber. Imagine if the Cowboys would have taken Jacobs and the Giants Barber! In hindsight, with the 10th rb selected the Cowboys got the best RB of the 2005 class in the 4th rd.

McFadden, Stewart, Jones, Mendenhall, Johnson, Choice, etc. It wouldn't surprise me if Choice ended up the best of the class of 2008. We shall see.

 

[CF74]

Give Choice about 2 years and he's gonna blow it up. Huge acquisition, huge!!!

 

[Hypnotoad]

If we took brandon jacobs, we would have won the superbowl.

Blast!

 

[cowboyz]

frank gore and ronnie brown are better than barber

 

[big dog cowboy]

1) Ronnie Brown
6) Frank Gore
10) Marion Barber
11) Brandon Jacobs

Those are the best of the group. Brown and Gore battled injuries. A good bettle to watch the next few years.

 

[CF74]

frank gore and ronnie brown are better than barber

Perhaps but maybe not as durable?

 

[soccerbud]

Perhaps but maybe not as durable?

lets watch barber carry a full load for a few years and we can then make our judgemetn

 

[tecolote]

lets watch barber carry a full load for a few years and we can then make our judgemetn

Fortunately, we won't have to.