Re-Drafting The 2014 Offensive Line Class

AsthmaField

Outta bounds
Messages
26,489
Reaction score
44,544
http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000488254/article/redrafting-the-2014-offensive-line-class



Future Stars


1. Zack Martin, G, Dallas Cowboys

When I got to Martin's Week 5 game against theTexans -- one of the matchups I was most excited to watch in-depth from his 2014 campaign -- I was a bit nervous that my appreciation for the Dallas guard was a product of media hype. Initially, his downfield blocking was erratic and, on the opening drive, I watched him bumble his way through a busted screen (no offensive lineman fails gracefully, unfortunately). But as the tape wore on, the attributes I have come to admire about Martin shined. The first step has a certain fearlessness to it, even against Watt. Yet, his center of gravity is such that he's not allowing himself to make mistakes or get caught off balance. I was impressed especially with his eyes downfield. After his initial block, his ability to identify potential targets is instantaneous, but not without thought. His billing as one of the more cerebral guards in the draft made plenty of sense.

This is a little thing I saw that may or may not mean anything, but against Houston -- a team that consistently shifts their fronts and moves Watt around to find the best potential matchup -- Martin never took a snap without a physical conformation from Travis Frederick that they were on the same page. He did it in a few other games as well. It’s a small thing but it gave me the sense that the game wasn’t too big or hectic for him.

On the season, Pro Football Focus credited him with one sack, a good start for a player not lined up right next to Tyron Smith.

One last observation: In a Week 9 matchup against Arizona, Dallas' opening script included plays that were: 1. A run directly off Martin's right hip, 2. Off to the left side on a run play that required a key backside block by Martin and 3. A play-action that was designed off a cut back that would have bounced off Martin's right hip (I think). If I'm a casual observer, is that not a huge vote of confidence from a very good offensive line coach?

Picking Martin as my No. 1 lineman is such a safe bet, though. He will star at two positions in his lifetime and, at least for now, he'll play with a dominant offensive line that can wear opponents down. We may not know if he's a truly great player or not until Year 4 or Year 5.
 

Galian Beast

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
7,457
The sky is the limit for our offensive line. They're all going to get better. The weak link is Doug Free.
 

Crown Royal

Insulin Beware
Messages
14,229
Reaction score
6,383
I'm really excited for this line. Martin and Frederick are sick.

I want to give credit to Free too, though. He and Martin in tandem seemed to be dancing (for lack of a better term). They were in sync every snap they took and the pass offs/communication that they shared was amazing. I think Martin fell off a little when Parnell came in (which calm down @xwalker is not a flam toward Parnell, but it shows the effect chemistry has). I think Martin is a really big reason why they re-signed Free.
 

Knotamus

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,682
Reaction score
4,145
The sky is the limit for our offensive line. They're all going to get better. The weak link is Doug Free.

Ok, for the people that continue to hate on Doug Free, lets just get the record straight... Doug Free has been a Cowboy ever since he's been in the league and I, for one, commend him for that. He provides leadership and attitude to our young (and great) OL. I'll admit, he had a couple years there (mainly 2012) at LT that wasn't good, but ever since he's been at his natural RT position he's been much better than a so-called "weak" link. As a matter of fact, since 2012, he's posted a grade of (+21.6) and ranked 4th RT at run blocking. A recent SI OL tackle ranking had Tyron as 4th and Doug 19th. You'd be hard pressed to find another tandem better than those two. At 6'6" 325lbs, he's hard to move. Add in Martin next to him and we have a very solid right side of the line. The guy is not appreciated enough and deserves praise for his professionalism. In an era where money and free agency rule, I laud him for taking less money to stay with the Cowboys. So please, next time research the player before calling him out.. don't listen to BSPN! If there is a "weak" link in our PFF #1 rated offensive line, it would have to be Leary simple bc of his degenerate knee concerns.

https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2015/02/17/2015-top-free-agents-offensive-tackles/
 

AzorAhai

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,511
Reaction score
8,901
So teams were turned off by Trai Turners speed? He had the best 10 yard split, 20 yard SS and 40 for OG at the combine. This guy has some seriously flawed assertions in his write up, including not knowing if Martin is a star for 4-5 years. All-Pro as a rookie is pretty rare and unless his health is a problem, I don't see how he came to that conclusion.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,711
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I'm really excited for this line. Martin and Frederick are sick.

I want to give credit to Free too, though. He and Martin in tandem seemed to be dancing (for lack of a better term). They were in sync every snap they took and the pass offs/communication that they shared was amazing. I think Martin fell off a little when Parnell came in (which calm down @xwalker is not a flam toward Parnell, but it shows the effect chemistry has). I think Martin is a really big reason why they re-signed Free.

I agree about Martin taking a step back; although, if you recall he had and injury issue about that same time.

I think they re-signed Free because Garrett has always liked him while Callahan liked Parnell. I've heard that Callahan campaigned to Jerry in 2012 to have Parnell start over Free. They compromised and had them rotate series for the final 4 games that season. I've heard that was the start of Garrett and Callahan not having a good relationship. It seem obvious that Callahan also campaigned directly to Jerry to call the plays in 2013. I don't think Jerry would pull that idea out a hat at random.

The contract that Parnell was probably excessive. I think he'll be worth it, but it's a big risk considering he started way fewer games than most free agents that get big contracts.

My biggest concern is that Free had 2 ankle surgeries in a 1 year time span and he is now 31. If he loses any quickness, he could decline rapidly because his game is based on quickness not power. I'm really curious to see what they do in regards to the backup. Weems appears to have the physical talent to play RT or LT, but he has yet to prove it. Hawkins has some talent but might be better at Guard. Wetzel did better than expected in TC last year but appears to have limited athleticism. I expect them to draft an OT late.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,711
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
So teams were turned off by Trai Turners speed? He had the best 10 yard split, 20 yard SS and 40 for OG at the combine. This guy has some seriously flawed assertions in his write up, including not knowing if Martin is a star for 4-5 years. All-Pro as a rookie is pretty rare and unless his health is a problem, I don't see how he came to that conclusion.

Yes, that was a terrible review. Martin was an All Pro as a rookie. We don't need 5 years to know if he is good.

Trai Turner show good athleticism/quickness on the field and his combine backed it up. He was only available in the 3rd because he came out as a redshirt sophomore. If he had stayed and was in this years draft I have no doubt he would have been a 1st round pick.
 

TwoCentPlain

Numbnuts
Messages
15,171
Reaction score
11,084
And 2013 saw the Cowboys draft the best player taken in that year's 1st round with the 31st pick in Frederick. Trading down and still getting the best player and also a very good WR Williams to boot in the trade down.
 

JsnSA

Active Member
Messages
206
Reaction score
92
Yes, that was a terrible review. Martin was an All Pro as a rookie. We don't need 5 years to know if he is good.

To be fair he said it may take 4 or 5 years to know if he is a truly great player, not just a good one. He already said he was a safe bet at the number one best rookie O-lineman so he clearly already thinks he is good.
 

a.stovall2

Member
Messages
57
Reaction score
77
Ok, for the people that continue to hate on Doug Free, lets just get the record straight... Doug Free has been a Cowboy ever since he's been in the league and I, for one, commend him for that. He provides leadership and attitude to our young (and great) OL. I'll admit, he had a couple years there (mainly 2012) at LT that wasn't good, but ever since he's been at his natural RT position he's been much better than a so-called "weak" link. As a matter of fact, since 2012, he's posted a grade of (+21.6) and ranked 4th RT at run blocking. A recent SI OL tackle ranking had Tyron as 4th and Doug 19th. You'd be hard pressed to find another tandem better than those two. At 6'6" 325lbs, he's hard to move. Add in Martin next to him and we have a very solid right side of the line. The guy is not appreciated enough and deserves praise for his professionalism. In an era where money and free agency rule, I laud him for taking less money to stay with the Cowboys. So please, next time research the player before calling him out.. don't listen to BSPN! If there is a "weak" link in our PFF #1 rated offensive line, it would have to be Leary simple bc of his degenerate knee concerns.

https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2015/02/17/2015-top-free-agents-offensive-tackles/

He did not say Doug sucks. He just said he is the weak link of the best o-line in football. No big deal.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,711
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Ok, for the people that continue to hate on Doug Free, lets just get the record straight... Doug Free has been a Cowboy ever since he's been in the league and I, for one, commend him for that. He provides leadership and attitude to our young (and great) OL. I'll admit, he had a couple years there (mainly 2012) at LT that wasn't good, but ever since he's been at his natural RT position he's been much better than a so-called "weak" link. As a matter of fact, since 2012, he's posted a grade of (+21.6) and ranked 4th RT at run blocking. A recent SI OL tackle ranking had Tyron as 4th and Doug 19th. You'd be hard pressed to find another tandem better than those two. At 6'6" 325lbs, he's hard to move. Add in Martin next to him and we have a very solid right side of the line. The guy is not appreciated enough and deserves praise for his professionalism. In an era where money and free agency rule, I laud him for taking less money to stay with the Cowboys. So please, next time research the player before calling him out.. don't listen to BSPN! If there is a "weak" link in our PFF #1 rated offensive line, it would have to be Leary simple bc of his degenerate knee concerns.

https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2015/02/17/2015-top-free-agents-offensive-tackles/

That site gave Parnell a higher grade for 2014 and he only had 1 career start prior to the season.

Free was incredibly bad in 2012. Callahan wanted to bench him back then but Garrett didn't. Then in 2013 they tweaked the OL scheme to help him. They have the RG keep a closer than normal spacing to Free which prevent him from getting beat inside. This allows him to over-set to the outside which gives him a big advantage. They have Fred cheat right as much as possible to compensate for the RG helping Free. This put Leary in a more difficult position than normal with less help from the Center. Leary is often on an island similar to an OT; whereas, the right side of the OL is often bunched tightly together.

Free does a good job on the backside cut-off blocks in the Zone runs to the left; however, he is not powerful in runs to his side. The zone scheme helps him because it allow him to just get in the way of the defender instead o f having to move him.

Free had ankle surgery in Jan 2014 and Jan 2015 and he is now 31. That is a bigger concern than Leary's knee issue which has yet to show any signs of a problem. Leary's knee is not really degenerative per se. It's more of an all or nothing issue. Jonathan Vilma played 10 years in the NFL with the same condition.

I think it's a safe bet that I've spent more time studying Doug Free and just about any fan or media. Most people here know that I have been obsessive about this issue. I've tried and tried to figure out why he is not better. He has the basic requirement of quick feet and size (6-6, 325) with decent arm length; however, he is just not strong in his upper body. He has gone though every possible variance of technique trying to offset the issue. He looks like someone that has weak shoulders. He has not power in his arms if they're not tucked in close to his body. His foot quickness is what allows him to survive. Guys like Tyron can reach out and keep defenders from turning the corner even if he is not in perfect position with his body. Free can't do that. I will say that 2014 was Free's best season so that much is a good sign. He did look slightly stronger. I think he spent more time training because he lost some of the gut and looked to be in better shape in training camp.

They had a younger player on the rise in Parnell and let him go in FA. They kept the older player with ankle problems in Free. Hopefully that does not come back to bite them in the butt.

I've watched each snaps that Free has ever played with the Cowboys at least 10 times each including pre-season games. I fell comfortable that I've done the "research".
 

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
21,555
Reaction score
22,657
That is what I would call hitting the lottery.

100% disagree. Just because the person they were going draft is gone does not mean Martin was a lucky pick. Dallas did their research and knew Martin would be a solid pick. It is called contingency. A backup plan. Plan B. AKA being smart.
 

Macnalty

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,639
Reaction score
2,162
100% disagree. Just because the person they were going draft is gone does not mean Martin was a lucky pick. Dallas did their research and knew Martin would be a solid pick. It is called contingency. A backup plan. Plan B. AKA being smart.

you do know they were desperate to trade the pick so they could grab DeMarcus in the first rd and could find no trading partners. In my mind this dilutes the smartness quotient. I do love that he was part of their plan just the story of how it happened is like the lottery IMO.
 

waving monkey

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,540
Reaction score
14,930
you do know they were desperate to trade the pick so they could grab DeMarcus in the first rd and could find no trading partners. In my mind this dilutes the smartness quotient. I do love that he was part of their plan just the story of how it happened is like the lottery IMO.
it happens every draft
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,920
Reaction score
112,965
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Picking Martin as my No. 1 lineman is such a safe bet, though. He will star at two positions in his lifetime and, at least for now, he'll play with a dominant offensive line that can wear opponents down. We may not know if he's a truly great player or not until Year 4 or Year 5.

Say what?
 
Top