Real Scout's Top 10 Kicker rankings: Cowboy's Folk not mentioned

Gryphon

Merge Ahead
Messages
3,407
Reaction score
31
Posted: May 28, 2009
http://www.sportingnews.com/yourturn/viewtopic.php?t=553968

Evaluating kickers is more than just checking their stats. Still, you can't be an elite kicker unless you make the clutch kicks.

1. Stephen Gostkowski, Patriots. In just his third NFL season, Gostkowski set team records for points and field goals in a season, and he did it with a backup quarterback getting him into field-goal position. New England didn't boast much of a running game, either. With Tom Brady healthy, Gostkowski should improve on his 90 percent completion rate and once again contend for the NFL points title.

2. John Kasay, Panthers. He turns 40 in October and doesn't kickoff anymore, but he started the '08 season by connecting on 16 consecutive field-goal attempts. He's deadly accurate, and with a punishing rushing attack and a passing game led by the steady hand of Jake Delhomme, he'll have plenty of chances to score.

3. Jason Elam, Falcons. He moved from the rarified air of Denver to the friendly indoor confines of the Georgia Dome last year, and he responded with a career high 93.5 percent completion rate in field-goal attempts, including 11-of-12 from beyond 40 yards. Elam, 39, is playing indoors behind what should be an explosive offense, so look for more of the same in '09.

4. Rob Bironas, Titans. Bironas boasts one of the strongest and most accurate legs, as close to a sure thing as any kicker. He has connected on 6-of-8 field-goal attempts from 50-plus yards the last three years.

5. Kris Brown, Texans. RB Steve Slaton has given the Texans the needed complement to QB Matt Schaub and WR Andre Johnson. The result is one of the NFL's most productive offenses, translating into more scoring chances for Brown.

6. Robbie Gould, Bears. He doesn't have a big leg but has been accurate in tough weather conditions. New QB Jay Cutler should get Gould in striking range much more often this year. Look for a significant increase in Gould's point production.

7. Neil Rackers, Cardinals. Rackers bounced back from a couple of down years to connect on 89.3 percent of field-goal attempts last season. He hasn't put together two good consecutive seasons over his career and doesn't have a strong leg, which limits his scoring chances. Sure, he plays with a high-powered offense, but the Cardinals are about scoring touchdowns -- 37 percent of his points last season were extra-point kicks.

8. Ryan Longwell, Vikings. Longwell doesn't handle kickoff duties but has a strong and accurate leg. He missed on some mid-range kicks last season but was deadly from outside 50 yards, hitting all six attempts. If Brett Favre actually does come out of retirement, Longwell will compete for the league scoring title.

9. Lawrence Tynes, Giants. Though John Carney was awesome last year, earning Pro Bowl honors for the Giants, Tynes is the one who got the contract extension. Tynes is younger and has a stronger leg, and he proved in the '07 Super Bowl run that he can make pressure kicks.

10. Jason Hanson, Lions. It's hard to be a standout on a 0-16 team, but Hanson was every bit of that last season. Though the Lions offense only provided him 22 field-goal chances, he connected on 21 of them, including 8-of-8 from 50-plus yards and 14-of-14 from 40-plus yards.

RealScouts analyze NFL and college players, coaches and teams exclusively for Sporting News.
 

Gryphon

Merge Ahead
Messages
3,407
Reaction score
31
This ranking must factor in Folk's poor kick-off average. HOWEVER HE IS A PRO-BOWL KICKER!
 

NextGenBoys

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,252
Reaction score
1,964
I havent read any of those "Scout" lists that are any good.

Folk is a Top FIVE kicker, not to mention top 10.

Neil Rackers? Yeah, 3 years ago. Dude hasnt made a FG over 50 yards since 1990
 

speedkilz88

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,952
Reaction score
23,100
Gryphon;2791225 said:
This ranking must factor in Folk's poor kick-off average. HOWEVER HE IS A PRO-BOWL KICKER!
John Kasay is #2 and he is really bad at kickoffs, the panthers have a kickoff specialist.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
I am basically opposed to lists of top Kickers. But it is worse when the list is stupid too.
 

AdamJT13

Salary Cap Analyst
Messages
16,583
Reaction score
4,529
Gryphon;2791225 said:
This ranking must factor in Folk's poor kick-off average.

It didn't factor in the fact that John Kasay doesn't even kick off anymore.
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
40,027
Reaction score
37,174
I thought maybe they were just basing it on field-goal accuracy, but Folk's was 91 percent and he was fourth in that category among regular kickers.

Him not being ranked is probably a product of not having a touchback and the fact that Dallas drafted a kicker because of that. (Plus, with the limited knowledge these "scouts" seem to possess about teams, they probably think Buehler is here to replace Folk, which would make them wary of ranking him.)

Sometimes it's better off just not to do it (like with Kasay) than to do it poorly. Out of sight, out of mind.

With Buehler here for kickoffs, if Folk hits over 90 percent again, he'll probably be considered one of the best in the league.
 

TD-33

Benched
Messages
2,542
Reaction score
0
hahahahahahahahahahahahahaahhaahh *breathe* ahahahahahah

:rolleyes:

Nick Folk is $ and I wouldn't trade the guy.
AND he will only get better.
 

Dawgs0916

Will the Thrill
Messages
2,195
Reaction score
4
Its amazing how many kickers are in that 85%+ accuracy range.

I mean its kind of dumb how automatic most of these kickers are nowadays.
 

WarDaddy

kidcrook
Messages
1,480
Reaction score
1,015
Wow. No love for Folk when he's been money for the past two years.

But they really glossed over Jason Hanson's season. According to their bass-ackward system he should be higher than #10.
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
kidcrook;2792349 said:
Wow. No love for Folk when he's been money for the past two years.

But they really glossed over Jason Hanson's season. According to their bass-ackward system he should be higher than #10.

No one cares about a kicker until there is a few seconds on the clock and the game is on the line. :laugh2:
 

NextGenBoys

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,252
Reaction score
1,964
Doomsday101;2792355 said:
No one cares about a kicker until there is a few seconds on the clock and the game is on the line. :laugh2:

I think its funny how they get no credit, yet they are arguably one of the most important positions in close games.

Adam V won NE 3 Super Bowl, and Jeff Christy won Parcells his 2nd ring.

In theory, Vanderjagt won Pitt their SB back in 05.
 
Top