Reasons McCarthy Could Get Another Contract

Chuck 54

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,503
Reaction score
12,522
  1. Jerry finds he has no better options unless he steps back and gives up more power.
  2. Jerry finally realizes that his inactivity in free agency and dragging his feet on contracts hamstrung the offense without a RB, without a second playmaker, and hamstrung the defense without interior defensive help and depth at CB and LB.
  3. Jerry realizes that the OL wasn’t ready to compete with 2 rookie starters in new positions and that the defense wasn’t ready or properly manned for the new DC, especially after being decimated by injuries.
  4. How many games can you really expect to win with the offense scoring 6 TDs over 4.5 games without your starting QB to date? The two wins show that McCarthy is still a good coach who emphasizes complimentary football.
Personlly, I don’t think any coaching could have changed much with this 2024 roster. The defense is still undermanned on the interior, and the offense cannot score TDs without playmakers. Our offense has fewer playmakers than any offense in the NFL competing for a playoff spot.

That said, I would love to see a new, younger coach making changes across the board. I just don’t think Jerry is ready to take a hands off approach, and I think he’s keeping the McCarthy card in his back pocket because he knows he may not be able to sign a coach that’s clearly better.
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,301
Reaction score
63,985
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Jerry finds he has no better options unless he steps back and gives up more power.
'Better options' is relative to the person considering them. Jerry Jones hired Jimmy Johnson and Bill Parcells. Jones hired Barry Switzer, Chan Gailey, Dave Campo, Wade Phillips, Jason Garrett and Mike McCarthy.

In both circumstances, Jones did not do an extensive coaching search. His gut told him to hire his old college teammate, who was successful at the college level. His gut told him a two-time winning Super Bowl head coach would secure him the best (east/west) stadium he imagined.

His gut told him another college teammate, who was also successful at the college level, would be his '500 coaches' solution. His gut told him an offensive coordinator would re-kindle his team's offensive prowess--only to give up on his choice two years later.

His gut did not warn him his choice was not respected by his players as a head coach. They even de-pantsed the man in practice.

His gut told him to hire an offensive minded prodigy (his gut) before hiring a defensive minded mainstay with a so-so head coaching record. His gut said he already had the next Tom Landry. A decade later, his gut told him he could not continue waiting on Tom Landry type results.

His gut said an out-of-work ex-Super Bowl winning head coach would be an easy hire. Four years later, his gut said do not re-sign his head coach before the final contract season.

Jones has plenty of options available to him. His track record suggests he minimizes his available options to less than a handful. In doing so, his actual hires meet the conditions he desires. This is why his better options more often do not coincide with the better options observers see-and-believe he should obtain.

Jerry finally realizes that his inactivity in free agency and dragging his feet on contracts hamstrung the offense without a RB, without a second playmaker, and hamstrung the defense without interior defensive help and depth at CB and LB.
Jones re-signed Ezekiel Elliott, two seasons after he released him. Jones knows exactly what he is doing because he believes he makes sound player acquisition judgments. That is what he realizes.

Jerry realizes that the OL wasn’t ready to compete with 2 rookie starters in new positions and that the defense wasn’t ready or properly manned for the new DC, especially after being decimated by injuries.
This hypothesis is totally dependent upon how the offensive line improves or regresses now-and-through the end of the team's season.

How many games can you really expect to win with the offense scoring 6 TDs over 4.5 games without your starting QB to date? The two wins show that McCarthy is still a good coach who emphasizes complimentary football.
Great question. Unfortunately, the general manager believes his specific head coaching choices should be successful with the rosters he provides them--which he overrates moreso than outside observers judge.
 

acr731

Jerry learned to GM from Pee Wee Herman
Messages
10,310
Reaction score
28,691
'Better options' is relative to the person considering them. Jerry Jones hired Jimmy Johnson and Bill Parcells. Jones hired Barry Switzer, Chan Gailey, Dave Campo, Wade Phillips, Jason Garrett and Mike McCarthy.

In both circumstances, Jones did not do an extensive coaching search. His gut told him to hire his old college teammate, who was a successful at the college level. His gut told him a two-time winning Super Bowl head coach would secure him the best (east/west) stadium he imagined.

His gut told him another college teammate, who was also successful at the college level, would be his '500 coaches' solution. His gut told him an offensive coordinator would re-kindle his team's offensive prowess--only to give up on his choice two years later.

His gut did not warn him his choice was not respected by his players as a head coach. They even de-pantsed the man in practice.

His gut told him to hire an offensive minded prodigy (his gut) before hiring a defensive minded mainstay with a so-so head coaching record. His gut said he already had the next Tom Landry. A decade later, his gut told him he could not continue waiting on Tom Landry type results.

His gut said an out-of-work ex-Super Bowl winning head coach would be an easy hire. Four years later, his gut said do not re-sign his head coach before the final contract season.

Jones has plenty of options available to him. His track record suggests he minimizes his available options to less than a handful. In doing so, his actual hires meet the conditions he desires. This is why his better options more often do not coincide with the better options observers see-and-believe he should obtain.


Jones re-signed Ezekiel Elliott, two seasons after he released him. Jones knows exactly what he is doing because he believes he makes sound player acquisition judgments. That is what he realizes.


This hypothesis is totally dependent upon how the offensive line improves or regresses now-and-through the end of the team's season.


Great question. Unfortunately, the general manager believes his specific head coaching choices should be successful with the rosters he provides them--which he overrates moreso than outside observers judge.
Jerry's gut is pickled beyond repair by years of abusing Johnny Walker Blue.
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,301
Reaction score
63,985
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Jerry's gut is pickled beyond repair by years of abusing Johnny Walker Blue.
Jones' liver cried 'No Mas!' in his forties but he listened to it just as much as he has listened to pretty much anyone else about anything.
 

fivetwos

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,970
Reaction score
29,037
I think he is going to do something that is supposedly “Dak friendly,” meaning he is already familiar, which suggests McCarthy, Moore or another puppet with a Schottenheimer promotion to calling plays.

Expect that, and expect to hear the term “hit the ground running on offense.”

I’ve thought Moore all along, but I’m beginning to suspect that he knows better, especially if he has options.
 

maryquality

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,254
Reaction score
19,530
CowboysZone DIEHARD Fan
I think he is going to do something that is supposedly “Dak friendly,” meaning he is already familiar, which suggests McCarthy, Moore or another puppet with a Schottenheimer promotion to calling plays.

Expect that, and expect to hear the term “hit the ground running on offense.”

I’ve thought Moore all along, but I’m beginning to suspect that he knows better, especially if he has options.
Yeah.....I don't expect any young and upcoming coach will be hired by the Jones', unless it's K. Moore as Dak is familiar with his offense.
 

cowboyec

Well-Known Member
Messages
34,659
Reaction score
41,428
as long as jerry stays as the gm...it doesn't matter.
the only success a new hc would have is what mccarthy has had.
we aren't winning a title with our current gm.
the ONLY way it might happen...is a hc who learns to coach "around" jerry.
short list of who has the mental toughness to do that.
we have a gm problem...not a mccarthy problem.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,104
Reaction score
11,431
I think he is going to do something that is supposedly “Dak friendly,” meaning he is already familiar, which suggests McCarthy, Moore or another puppet with a Schottenheimer promotion to calling plays.

Expect that, and expect to hear the term “hit the ground running on offense.”

I’ve thought Moore all along, but I’m beginning to suspect that he knows better, especially if he has options.
I'd bet on Kellen, maybe even with Zimmer staying. Jerry is comfortable with both, plus he can sell change plus continuity at the same time.
 

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
42,767
Reaction score
29,005
The only chance I see is if Dak talks Jerry into it. Jerry is going to give major weight to what his 240 million dollar QB wants.

I don't think that happens, though. A new coach is a major part of Jerry's 2025 Marketing Plan.
I see it as a complete opposite perspective than you Jerry already paid Prescott, Prescott no longer has any power or say he just needs to go out and play that's it if Prescott would have used this as leverage and held out as far as like going into the offseason in February and March where we still have his rights to negotiate with him till it's full free agency and he says I'll sign the new contract if you bring back McCarthy only then would he have any say in it then Jerry would have to decide if he wanted both or none that would be a true leverage he has no leverage now Prescott's already here he's already been paid 2 years guaranteed $140 million on the books no matter what he had 0 leverage in anything now...

As a fan if I'm Jerry in this situation and it does become an issue with Prescott really pushing for this I invite Prescott to seek a trade wherever he'd like to go pick three teams and let's start the negotiations then what you wanna see who has leverage then if Prescott don't like it he can follow Mike McCarthy wherever he goes maybe they both end up on The Jets or raiders that would be interesting....
 

KMY_Amber

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
1,660
Dead. Coach. Walking. Jerry ain't bringing him back unless this rag-tag team squeezes into the playoffs after a miraculous run to the end the season.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,104
Reaction score
11,431
I see it as a complete opposite perspective than you Jerry already paid Prescott, Prescott no longer has any power or say he just needs to go out and play that's it if Prescott would have used this as leverage and held out as far as like going into the offseason in February and March where we still have his rights to negotiate with him till it's full free agency and he says I'll sign the new contract if you bring back McCarthy only then would he have any say in it then Jerry would have to decide if he wanted both or none that would be a true leverage he has no leverage now Prescott's already here he's already been paid 2 years guaranteed $140 million on the books no matter what he had 0 leverage in anything now...

As a fan if I'm Jerry in this situation and it does become an issue with Prescott really pushing for this I invite Prescott to seek a trade wherever he'd like to go pick three teams and let's start the negotiations then what you wanna see who has leverage then if Prescott don't like it he can follow Mike McCarthy wherever he goes maybe they both end up on The Jets or raiders that would be interesting....
I think people are reading too much into this Dak endorsement of Mike. I do think Dak likes Mike, and they have a good relationship, but I doubt Dak feels that strongly about it. Dak wanted Garrett back, too, and that wasn't enough for Jerry to keep him even though he was in Jerry's family portrait.

Dak was mostly supporting his coach, as he should. He wouldn't demand Mike stay for his contract or any of that.
 

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
42,767
Reaction score
29,005
I think people are reading too much into this Dak endorsement of Mike. I do think Dak likes Mike, and they have a good relationship, but I doubt Dak feels that strongly about it. Dak wanted Garrett back, too, and that wasn't enough for Jerry to keep him even though he was in Jerry's family portrait.

Dak was mostly supporting his coach, as he should. He wouldn't demand Mike stay for his contract or any of that.
I understand this I was giving you a hypothetical scenario that literally if it happened that's how I would handle it they have Cowboys fans wants Prescott gone so fast ,that'd be the fastest way for him to challenge Jerry , might say OK you and Mike and both go pick a team waive your no trade clause...bye bye
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
40,008
Reaction score
37,150
  1. Jerry finds he has no better options unless he steps back and gives up more power.
  2. Jerry finally realizes that his inactivity in free agency and dragging his feet on contracts hamstrung the offense without a RB, without a second playmaker, and hamstrung the defense without interior defensive help and depth at CB and LB.
  3. Jerry realizes that the OL wasn’t ready to compete with 2 rookie starters in new positions and that the defense wasn’t ready or properly manned for the new DC, especially after being decimated by injuries.
  4. How many games can you really expect to win with the offense scoring 6 TDs over 4.5 games without your starting QB to date? The two wins show that McCarthy is still a good coach who emphasizes complimentary football.
Personlly, I don’t think any coaching could have changed much with this 2024 roster. The defense is still undermanned on the interior, and the offense cannot score TDs without playmakers. Our offense has fewer playmakers than any offense in the NFL competing for a playoff spot.

That said, I would love to see a new, younger coach making changes across the board. I just don’t think Jerry is ready to take a hands off approach, and I think he’s keeping the McCarthy card in his back pocket because he knows he may not be able to sign a coach that’s clearly better.
That's why we need a coach with more influence over personnel. Unfortunately, I'm not sure if Jerry will ever hire one of those again. The only two he has had where he gave them an inordinate amount of say was Jimmy and Parcells. The only one I can see who might wield that kind of influence is Belichick.
 

Aven8

Well-Known Member
Messages
29,118
Reaction score
45,952
The only chance I see is if Dak talks Jerry into it. Jerry is going to give major weight to what his 240 million dollar QB wants.

I don't think that happens, though. A new coach is a major part of Jerry's 2025 Marketing Plan.
It gets scary when players get involved with the HC decision. It’s too bad we didn’t get in on the Jim Harbaugh deal. That’s the kind of coach Dak needs. Herbert has more talent in his pinky than Dak but they are playing a team game on offense now. What I fear and will most likely happen is Jerry will want to justify the money spent by adding more WR’s to throw to, instead of building a balanced team offense….
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,838
Reaction score
112,754
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
  1. Jerry finds he has no better options unless he steps back and gives up more power.
  2. Jerry finally realizes that his inactivity in free agency and dragging his feet on contracts hamstrung the offense without a RB, without a second playmaker, and hamstrung the defense without interior defensive help and depth at CB and LB.
  3. Jerry realizes that the OL wasn’t ready to compete with 2 rookie starters in new positions and that the defense wasn’t ready or properly manned for the new DC, especially after being decimated by injuries.
  4. How many games can you really expect to win with the offense scoring 6 TDs over 4.5 games without your starting QB to date? The two wins show that McCarthy is still a good coach who emphasizes complimentary football.
Personlly, I don’t think any coaching could have changed much with this 2024 roster. The defense is still undermanned on the interior, and the offense cannot score TDs without playmakers. Our offense has fewer playmakers than any offense in the NFL competing for a playoff spot.

That said, I would love to see a new, younger coach making changes across the board. I just don’t think Jerry is ready to take a hands off approach, and I think he’s keeping the McCarthy card in his back pocket because he knows he may not be able to sign a coach that’s clearly better.
Interesting. My top 4 reasons why McCarthy could get another contract.

1.
2.
3.
4.

In conclusion I'll just that I would gladly help him pack up his belongings and show him the door on Black Monday.
 

boysfanindc

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,226
Reaction score
2,863
I believe Jerry intended this to be a year to conserve cap, make Mike coach out his contract without the horses to win and get higher draft picks.
 

Hawkeye0202

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,282
Reaction score
47,580
I'm not convinced Mike wants to come back.......hell, he's had his house for sale since July. I agree with C-Lab.......Kellen Moore with Zimm returning. Kellen is Jerry's protege and his return checks a lot of boxes......


Jason Witten as an assistant



Former Cowboys tight end Jason Witten is currently a high-school football coach. Cowboys owner and G.M. Jerry Jones thinks Witten could do a lot better than that.

Appearing on 105.3 The Fan in Dallas on Friday, Jones was asked whether he believes Witten could be an NFL head coach.

Yes,” Jones said, via Jon Machota of TheAtheltic.com. “Without hesitation. Yes. He has something that you can’t draw up. He reminds me a lot of our other tight end who is head coach up there in Detroit right now. . . . Jason is very sophisticated when it comes to understanding football and all the nuances. But more important than anything, he really does understand the physical and the mentality of being physical and that part of it. Without a question, he could become [an NFL coach]. He has extraordinary work ethic. . . . He can be a top coach.”
 

Bobhaze

Staff member
Messages
18,681
Reaction score
73,835
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I'm not convinced Mike wants to come back.......hell, he's had his house for sale since July. I agree with C-Lab.......Kellen Moore with Zimm returning. Kellen is Jerry's protege and his return checks a lot of boxes......


Jason Witten as an assistant



Former Cowboys tight end Jason Witten is currently a high-school football coach. Cowboys owner and G.M. Jerry Jones thinks Witten could do a lot better than that.

Appearing on 105.3 The Fan in Dallas on Friday, Jones was asked whether he believes Witten could be an NFL head coach.

Yes,” Jones said, via Jon Machota of TheAtheltic.com. “Without hesitation. Yes. He has something that you can’t draw up. He reminds me a lot of our other tight end who is head coach up there in Detroit right now. . . . Jason is very sophisticated when it comes to understanding football and all the nuances. But more important than anything, he really does understand the physical and the mentality of being physical and that part of it. Without a question, he could become [an NFL coach]. He has extraordinary work ethic. . . . He can be a top coach.”
Jerry thinking Coach Jason Witten is in the same conversation as Coach Dan Campbell is a very brief glimpse into why we haven’t won a divisional playoff game in three decades.
 
Top