Romo gets a pass for bottomfeeding. But not Dak?

[McKDaddy]

No, he wasn't.

Seems there is an argument to be made. Eli's record is 8-4, 2-0 in the SB & 2 SB MVP's while having a 2-1 TD ratio. Peyton's record is 14-13, 2-2 in SB & 1 SB MVP while having a 1.6-1 TD ratio.

 

[McKDaddy]

3 years in a row (2011 - 2013), win the last game of the regular season to make it into the playoffs. What does Romo do? Led the team to 3 losses in a row and missed the playoffs all 3 years.

That is incorrect. Kyle Orton played in 2013.

2011 - was the year the Giants got hot & won their 2nd SB with Eli.

2012 - Tony didn't play well it would seem. RGIII & Alfred Morris ran all over them.

 

[kskboys]

Seems there is an argument to be made. Eli's record is 8-4, 2-0 in the SB & 2 SB MVP's while having a 2-1 TD ratio. Peyton's record is 14-13, 2-2 in SB & 1 SB MVP while having a 1.6-1 TD ratio.

Eli's record for game altering D's is 2-2.

Payton is 1-2.

Much more complex than comparing wins. Did you know that in both Eli's playoff runs his D held the opponents to under 21 points in every game? Are you claiming Payton had that luxury, to fail repeatedly and get bailed out by the D?

If you watched the 07 super bowl, you'd know that Eli in no way deserved the MVP. Justin Tuck was hands down the MVP of that game, taking over the D and harrassing Brady and that high scoring D into a paltry 14 points.