theogt,
He SHOULD, but... what happens if he is the 3rd QB from each of those groups...Brees, Bulger, then Romo? Let's say he only finishes 6th in the fan balloting. What if Favre were to finish 4th in both the player's and coaches vote(or Vick or Grossman or Herman Munster for that matter) and finished 3rd in the fan voting. If each group counts equally for 1/3 of the vote, would that mean Favre would slip in with an average ranking of 3.67 and Romo would be left out at an average of 4.0. This is assuming each ranking is equally weighted. That would be a travesty.
Also, that's assuming that both the coaches and players would have him ranked as highly as we obviously feel he should be.