Rookie or the year, Dak or Zeke?

[aikemirv]

Has to be Dak. The stage he's on is incomparable in all of sports.

What Zeke is doing is incredible as well, but what Dak is doing is almost inconceivable in the NFL.

RGIII
2012 Washington Commanders 15 15 258 393 65.6 3,200 8.1 20 5 30 217 102.4 120 815 6.8 7 12 2
Alfred Morris
2012 Washington Commanders 16 16 335 1,613 4.8 39T 13 11 77 7.0 20 0 4 3

Amazing what a good running game can do for a QB - just saying!

 

[conner01]

right now, Dak

if Zeke breaks Dickerson's record, it will be him

And that's why neither has won rookie or the week and won't win ROY
They split votes
If zeke breaks Dickerson record he could win but just leading the league in rudjing may not get it for him because him and Dak are gonna split votes

 

[Craig]

If dak plays like this for 16 games he'll run away with it.

 

[BotchedLobotomy]

Deke.

You're wrong, I thing it is going to be Zak

 

[pugilist]

And that's why neither has won rookie or the week and won't win ROY
They split votes
If zeke breaks Dickerson record he could win but just leading the league in rudjing may not get it for him because him and Dak are gonna split votes

yeah i was gonna put that in my original post as a disclaimer, because that is a good point

i was feeling too positive last night i guess

 

[pugilist]

on the flip side though, it's going to have to go to one of them if Wentz continues to flail and Dak / Zeke continue to dominate

 

[DFWJC]

Has there ever been a team that had 2 legitimate contenders for ROY before Dak and Zeke?

Washington with RG3 and Morris

 

[Diehardblues]

No way Dak wins it after being benched.

 

[Jake]

Right now I'm going co- ROY!

Thoughts?

 

[SDCowboy]

If Dak is still the starter, and still coninuing what he's doing, I think it has to go to Dak. Nothing against what Zeke is doing, he's been great, but QB is vastly more important than RB.

 

[jazzcat22]

Hard choice.
Zeke, he is doing what he is supposed to do. What he was drafted to do, and it is expected from a 4th overall pick.
Dak, he is out performing beyond expectations, and a lat 4th round [comp pick]. They guy that was to sit and watch for 3 years. But yet he is out playing some of the better vet QB's.
He is passing the "test" week after week.

Right now, I have to say Dak.

 

[Scandri100]

What's most impressive about zeke is how aware
he is in the 4th quarter, he knows what needs to be done in order the close out the game.

 

[CowboyRoy]

Right now I'm going co- ROY!

Thoughts?

For my money, if Dak stays the QB and leads us to 12-4 and a first round bye, I would pick Dak. Because he is a QB and its tougher what he is doing.

But at the end of the year, I believe that Zekes numbers are going to be absolutely off the charts. Over 2000 combined yards and will break Dickersons 1800 yards rookie rushing record.

 

[dallasdave]

It is great to have 2 rookies who might be the rookie MVP !!! Now this is how you build a team

 

[toto1939]

Right now I'm going co- ROY!

Thoughts?

Or give one MVP and the other one ROY

 

[BrAinPaiNt]

Probably been posted already but...

 

[Sydla]

Wentz might be on the bench soon if he continues to play like he did today

LOL.

The only way he's on the bench is if that OL gets him killed, which is possible.

 

[John813]

Gotta go with Zeke.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Easily Zeke. He may be the best player at his position and have the best rookie season for a rb in 30 years..