Roster Evaluation

[burmafrd]

Each starter by how good or bad he is vs the rest of the NFL:


QB- TOP 10
RB- TOP 15
FB- Bottom 10

TE-TOP 5
LT- BOTTOM 15
LG- Bottom 5
C- Bottom 5
RG- Bottom 5
RT-BOTTOM

WR-Dez Top 15
WR- Miles Top 20
WR- Bottom 15

P- Bottom 15
K- Top 5

4-3 now
DE- Ware- Top 5
DT- Ratlif- Top 20
DT- Hatcher- Bottom 15
DE- Spencer Top 10

OLB- Unknown - Bottom 15
MLB- Lee- TOP 10
OLB- Carter TOP 20

S- Sensie- Top 20
S- Church- Bottom 15
CB- Carr- Top 10
CB- Claiborne- Top 20


Top 5 is 1-5, Top 10 is 6-10; etc


Some of them are arguable certainly

 

[blindzebra]

There are not 14 WRs better than Dez or 17 LT better than Smith.

Other than injuries Lee is top 5 inside and Carter top 15...seriously pushing top 10.

I'd also flip the safety ratings.

 

[DFWJC]

Yeah, anything is debatable.
Probably almost every single line could be debated by someone (ex. I think Church is already better than Sensy and as a 3rd WR I suspect Tyron will be better than bottom 15 in his 2nd year at LT). But that is beside the point.

But this does highlight big time our massive holes in the oline.

 

[burmafrd]

There are not 14 WRs better than Dez or 17 LT better than Smith.

Other than injuries Lee is top 5 inside and Carter top 15...seriously pushing top 10.

I'd also flip the safety ratings.

Church has not done enough

Dez is just pushing top 10 as he finished the end of the year; but we need to see if he can keep it up

LEE is playing a different position in MLB and same with Carter; I think they have the potential of being much better

 

[blindzebra]

Church has not done enough

Dez is just pushing top 10 as he finished the end of the year; but we need to see if he can keep it up

LEE is playing a different position in MLB and same with Carter; I think they have the potential of being much better

Dez is solid within the top ten and seriously pushing top 5.

LBing is LBing except for OLB in a 3-4. Frankly both Lee and Carter are perfect for a 4-3.

 

[burmafrd]

Dez is solid within the top ten and seriously pushing top 5.

LBing is LBing except for OLB in a 3-4. Frankly both Lee and Carter are perfect for a 4-3.

As Dez ended the year that argument has merit; but I want to see him keep it up before I put him in Top 5. He was not at that level even half a season so not yet.

 

[Risen Star]

As Dez ended the year that argument has merit; but I want to see him keep it up before I put him in Top 5. He was not at that level even half a season so not yet.

The problem is he wasn't just a top 5 WR the second half of last year, he was the most productive WR in the league over those 8 games.

And when he supposedly struggled the first half, we was still on pace for a 1,000 yard season.

 

[burmafrd]

The problem is he wasn't just a top 5 WR the second half of last year, he was the most productive WR in the league over those 8 games.

And when he supposedly struggled the first half, we was still on pace for a 1,000 yard season.

Yes he was BUT I want to see a whole season of that before I annoint him