Roy Sucks?

[JPM]

we shoulda drafted merriman

We should have drafted Tom Brady....

 

[Ratmatt]

Okay I have been hearing alot about Roy sucking and I would like to clear some things up.
1st he is in a new system this year.
2nd he is picking up slack for injured players that keeps him from playing the way he would like to.
3rd he is a 4 time pro bowl selection. (I wasn't aware that the pro bowl was for all the sucky players.)
4th we don't have anyone better then him and there is no one better in free agency.
This is to all of you who say Roy "Sucks" I don't want a 3 page lecture why he sucks and I don't want to hear how much of a homer I am id rather you answer this questionaire.

1. Have you ever played Highschool football?
a. For how long?
b. What possition did you play?
c. What kinda numbers did you put up?
d. What University signed you?
2. Did you play College Football?
a. For how long?
b. What possition did you play?
c. What kinda numbers did you put up?
d. What records did you break?
e. What bowl game did you win?
f. What NFL team drafted you?
3. Have you ever played pro football?
a. Cand you do any better then Roy is doing now?
b. What makes you an expert on football?
c. Why do you feel you know more then the coaches?

The only thing I agree with you on is they have nothing better.You can make up all the excuses in the world,but the guy is a major liability in pass coverage.He also shoots the wrong gap at times,and misses the back in the running game.He also at times,tries to lay the big hit,instead of wrapping up.So you go ahead and keep defending him,if that makes yo feel better,but that's the reality of it.As far as your questions go,they're a waste of time for anyone on here that has an opinion.

 

[tomson75]

Threads like this make me question Darwinism. Millions of years later, and we're still lacking the ability to grasp complex thought processes. Another million years...and we'll ALL be eagles fans.

 

[cowboy625]

Okay I have been hearing alot about Roy sucking and I would like to clear some things up.
1st he is in a new system this year.
2nd he is picking up slack for injured players that keeps him from playing the way he would like to.
3rd he is a 4 time pro bowl selection. (I wasn't aware that the pro bowl was for all the sucky players.)
4th we don't have anyone better then him and there is no one better in free agency.
This is to all of you who say Roy "Sucks" I don't want a 3 page lecture why he sucks and I don't want to hear how much of a homer I am id rather you answer this questionaire.

1. Have you ever played Highschool football?
a. For how long?
b. What possition did you play?
c. What kinda numbers did you put up?
d. What University signed you?
2. Did you play College Football?
a. For how long?
b. What possition did you play?
c. What kinda numbers did you put up?
d. What records did you break?
e. What bowl game did you win?
f. What NFL team drafted you?
3. Have you ever played pro football?
a. Cand you do any better then Roy is doing now?
b. What makes you an expert on football?
c. Why do you feel you know more then the coaches?

Yes, Sorry to say it but, Roy Sucks. He doesn't suck because he can't play, he suck's because he is way overhyped.

He's a liability in coverage, and barely raps up when he tackles. He hits big, but he misses a lot as well. He does have pretty good ball skills, but he is by far not the best in the league.


1. Have you ever played Highschool football? yes
a. For how long? 4 years
b. What possition did you play? RB
c. What kinda numbers did you put up? 1st team all district 4A level
d. What University signed you? offered Miami and Miss. St
2. Did you play College Football? No, Took academic scholarship to LSU
a. For how long?
b. What possition did you play?
c. What kinda numbers did you put up?
d. What records did you break?
e. What bowl game did you win?
f. What NFL team drafted you?
3. Have you ever played pro football?
a. Cand you do any better then Roy is doing now?
b. What makes you an expert on football?
c. Why do you feel you know more then the coaches?And yes I played ball.