Roy vs. Rodney

[America's Team]

me and my friend always argure about who is a better strong safety, he thinks it is Rodney Harrison (obviously a Patriots fan) and I think it is Roy Williams, can you guys please enlighten on this subject.

 

[Doomsday]

me and my friend always argure about who is a better strong safety, he thinks it is Rodney Harrison (obviously a Patriots fan) and I think it is Roy Williams, can you guys please enlighten on this subject.

Both are good players but I have to go with the home town bias.

 

[Yeagermeister]

The only area that Rodney is better than Roy IMO is coverage and it's not that big of a difference.

 

[Hostile]

Ronnie Lott, the greatest Safety to ever play the game, said he watches Roy Williams.

 

[America's Team]

Ronnie Lott, the greatest Safety to ever play the game, said he watches Roy Williams.

yeah chris collonsworth compared him to ronnie lott

 

[Yakuza Rich]

Harrison is probably a bit better. But it's tough to tell since Harrison has Eugene Wilson covering massive amounts of the field while Roy has had Keith Davis, Willie Pile, and Lynn Scott.

One thing about Harrison, he gets away with more blatant holds....like him grabbing ahold of a receiver's jersey where you can see a good foot of jersey in his hands. Refs rarely call it.

I'd probably take Roy in defending the run, give the slight edge to Harrison in blitzing, Roy the edge in deep coverage, and Harrison the edge in short coverage.


Rich.........

 

[superpunk]

Harrison is probably a bit better. But it's tough to tell since Harrison has Eugene Wilson covering massive amounts of the field while Roy has had Keith Davis, Willie Pile, and Lynn Scott.

One thing about Harrison, he gets away with more blatant holds....like him grabbing ahold of a receiver's jersey where you can see a good foot of jersey in his hands. Refs rarely call it.

I'd probably take Roy in defending the run, give the slight edge to Harrison in blitzing, Roy the edge in deep coverage, and Harrison the edge in short coverage.


Rich.........

Who gets the edge in the "working knee" category?

 

[Funxva]

yeah chris collonsworth compared him to ronnie lott

If collinsworthless said it.. I question it.

:loser:

 

[the kid 05]

Who gets the edge in the "working knee" category?

rodneys knee is fine now :