Disagree. He had no weapons and when he finally got them he was injured all the time. Can’t ignore the fact that he holds most of the passing records for the team. Stats are better then Troy and Romo played less games. More TDs, more Total Yards, less Interceptions. He just didn’t win the big one. Cunningham, Moon, and Marino never won a super bowl, you telling me they didn’t have the talent?
There’s lots of arguments to be made as to why his stats are that much better. Change in strategy, coaching, personnel, playing from behind, etc.
Romo had better teams than those other QB’s and on the flip side, there’s plenty of QB’s with less talent that won championships because they didn’t blow it with one or two critical plays. They played solid, sound, consistent football whereas Tony took a lot of risks which could pay off but also killed the chances of a W at times.
In 2007 he had a fine team, enough to go 13-3 which he didn’t do by himself, and what does he do in the playoff loss to the team that eventually won the Super Bowl that year? Threw a 50% completion rate. Blame it on Cabo or whatever but he choked big time and ended the game by throwing an INT when they were in TD range.
2006 playoffs he had a whopping QBR of 40 and fumbled the FG.
How many games did he screw up in Week 17 win and in playoffs? 2 or 3. 2012 comes to mind when he threw 3 INT’s against the Commanders.
The list goes on and on...he blew a lot games when they mattered most.