Scattershooting on state of the Dallas Cowboys

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
I have no desire to create an epic rant thread.

Can't blame anyone for being upset but ultimately ranting is pointless. I'd like to try to be logical and not emotional.

Garrett/Romo: These two current Cowboys issues will take care of itself this season. Either the team rapidly ascends behind better QB/Head coach performance or both men will be looking for work elsewhere. That's just reality. So I hereby acknowledge the lack of preparation and poor QB play but try not to harp on it.

Stadium issues: Bottom line is if you want a home field advantage you need to tie the tickets to individual people not services. Long as you are fine selling to scalpers and resell services facts are opponents will pay more for the rare chance to see their teams than home fans will. That's not hard to understand. It's why Cowboys fans get so many tickets in other places. So Jerry needs to look at his marketing angle again and figure out a quick fix to this non-sense. Combine a malaise surrounding the team with ease of opponents acquiring tickets and this will only get worse unless acted upon.

Play-calling: At this point I believe play-calling is linked to poor QB decision-making. I think we are checking to passes when we should be running. If Romo has a major failing that will prevent him from ever winning as many state, this is it.

Defense: Hard to judge them harshly based on yesterday. They held up at the point of attack until late when they wore down. Coverage was solid beyond the obvious busted play to Davis. Folks yammering on about any single reception versus the DBs are being silly. All teams complete passes. 200 yards passing is a pretty mild day. 4.0 ypc is nothing to write home about. Defense really didn't make any plays but they held up.

Offense: Again hard to get around the decision-making. Outside that a lot of individuals played pretty well. The OL did fine as a group. They didn't handle Justin Smith but the rest of the 49ers DL were mostly inconsequential. The running game was there though you can not fumble on the first series like Murray did. The WRs seemed to get open and certainly did block well enough. Only one drop I can recall.

Draft: As we go forward on a week by week basis I think you have to look at positions we might draft. My list right now would be led by QB, DE and Safety. Romo's combo of back, play, money, age should make that understandable. And I am just not sure how anyone can trust Wilcox as a starter before year 4 or 5.
We need a Safety that assists the CBs and makes plays. DE is a glaring weakness that could come off the list if DLaw and Spencer prove they can be counted upon as starters for 2015.

Next week: Tennessee rather manhandled KC but looks pretty poor in talent. If Romo gets outplayed by Locker it will be time to officially panic. DAL should get the win and probably easily. That is if they have shaken the rust and actually play to potential. Something we've admittedly not seen.

Outlook: Really hard not to feel as if Dallas left one out there Sunday. That seemed a very winnable game and outside QB Dallas probably played better football. Since that's been reversed so many times I don't think we can expect that is the common outcome. If we end up solidly missing the playoffs yesterday may end up a blessing in disguise but for a team one game short each of the past 3 seasons giving up a game because you came out of the blocks unprepared and incapable of asserting control of your QB feels like a bad sign indeed.
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,920
Reaction score
112,957
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Great post JT. Really spot on with each point. How we play vs the Titans will answer some questions. Hopefully Romo will shake some rust (physical AND mental) because the offense needs to be a part of the solution not the problem.
 

diehard2294

America's Team
Messages
4,864
Reaction score
593
Good write up, It is disturbing how bad the corners played yesterday. If it continues I would give Pattmon a shot. Wilcox was lost all day
 

links18

Well-Known Member
Messages
24,325
Reaction score
20,105
Garrett/Romo: These two current Cowboys issues will take care of itself this season. Either the team rapidly ascends behind better QB/Head coach performance or both men will be looking for work elsewhere. That's just reality. So I hereby acknowledge the lack of preparation and poor QB play but try not to harp on it.

Here's part of the problem with this organization. Poor/declining performance doesn't necessarily mean being shown the door. In fact, if Jerry is emotionally attached to you, you might even get an extension.

Defense: Hard to judge them harshly based on yesterday. They held up at the point of attack until late when they wore down. Coverage was solid beyond the obvious busted play to Davis. Folks yammering on about any single reception versus the DBs are being silly. All teams complete passes. 200 yards passing is a pretty mild day. 4.0 ypc is nothing to write home about. Defense really didn't make any plays but they held up.

Defense was better than anyone expected, but the 3rd down coverage was still very porous.
 

jrumann59

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,017
Reaction score
8,770
As much heat that Heath got last year for never beingable to make a play on the ball correctly Wilcox is no where near the ball, I mean he is 5 yards away from his guy that caught the ball.
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
Great post JT. Really spot on with each point. How we play vs the Titans will answer some questions. Hopefully Romo will shake some rust (physical AND mental) because the offense needs to be a part of the solution not the problem.

On offense the answer is simple: Run the dang football, especially in the redzone!

Defensively, they just need to continue to play physical and they need to execute their assignments.
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
As much heat that Heath got last year for never beingable to make a play on the ball correctly Wilcox is no where near the ball, I mean he is 5 yards away from his guy that caught the ball.

Are you calling for the switch? o_O :D

I think both Wilcox and Heath are huge liabilities; one is not in the play and the other does not make the play. Safety will be a top-three priority this off-season.
 

Bull Frog

Well-Known Member
Messages
907
Reaction score
394
As much heat that Heath got last year for never beingable to make a play on the ball correctly Wilcox is no where near the ball, I mean he is 5 yards away from his guy that caught the ball.

You are assuming he knew who his guy was. I don't think he had a clue who to cover. It's either poor coaching or the guy is not that bright. It's like we didn't have any tape on Vernon Davis and he caught us completely off guard.
 

Doc50

Original Fan
Messages
3,142
Reaction score
3,430
Good summary, and I share your views.

The 2 glaring deficiencies were QB and coaching. A reasonable person would reserve judgement on this after only one game.
But Tony's back may well hinder him from now on, and the lack of scheme and game mgt. success cannot be tolerated much longer.

So, fans who want Romo, Garrett, and most of the coaches tarred & feathered will need to be a bit more patient.

And there is room for optimism in many other areas.

Now, as to JJ -- he's not going anywhere, and he might be getting less reasonable.

Next game should begin to answer some questions.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
81,320
Reaction score
102,271
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Great OP, can't disagree with anything.
Of the negative things that happened yesterday, most can be corrected. Others, we just need the players to be better, or get healthy too.
I am not down on this team after yesterday, but certainly not up, but can see better games ahead though too. But hopefully they translate into wins, and not have some stupid thing that causes a loss.
But that is on the coaches for not having this team prepared or disciplined. Why can't Witten stop his false starts, seems he has one every game that nullifies a big play or a first down, or makes a 3rd and short into a 3rd and long.
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,030
Reaction score
22,617
Thank you Sir, for a well voiced and reasoned OP.

Since we got past the new negotiated contract for the NFL, you have been one of my favorite reads.

I like a discussion, instead of just atta-boys.

I actually liked what I saw developing in the linebacker positional group for yesterday. If Lawrence and Spencer return to the unit and provide their levels of projected credible play, well, this box area could get a strong/respectable air to it. It could even project into a team strength by next season, when Sean Lee returns.
 

Future

Intramural Legend
Messages
27,566
Reaction score
14,714
You are assuming he knew who his guy was. I don't think he had a clue who to cover. It's either poor coaching or the guy is not that bright. It's like we didn't have any tape on Vernon Davis and he caught us completely off guard.
You're talking about the play down the sideline?

I thought I read something where Wilcox' responsibility was the short zone and the flats, with Carr over the top. If that's the case, then Davis wasn't really his man. Maybe he should have left his zone and run up the sideline with him, but it's hard to know for sure.
 

brickman

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,567
Reaction score
330
After the big contract we signed Romo to, how in hell is he going to be gone if he doesn't perform well this year?
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,030
Reaction score
22,617
After the big contract we signed Romo to, how in hell is he going to be gone if he doesn't perform well this year?

Worry about that when the contract was done...or at the conclusion of this season.
 

SilverStarCowboy

The Actualist
Messages
10,337
Reaction score
1,998
Logical and non emotional Jerry is the bad apple that spoiled the batch, and you knew it from day 1 PERIOD
 
Top