FEATURED Scattershooting

Messages
18,222
Reaction score
28,531
I think the main difference between Manning and Romo (and all other QB's) is that Manning knows where the ball is going before the ball is snapped. Not every single play, but the majority of the time. So he doesn't have to go through progressions. He sees his guy and throws it, giving the d-line no chance to get to him. Meanwhile Romo typically goes through his reads, which gives the d-line more chance to get to him, especially when there is a shaky line in front of him.

It has little to do with his release, but more to do with the fact that he has to go through progressions, which Peyton doesn't do often. He knows where the ball is going, he just has to wait for his receiver to separate.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
60,079
Reaction score
48,822
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I think the main difference between Manning and Romo (and all other QB's) is that Manning knows where the ball is going before the ball is snapped. Not every single play, but the majority of the time. So he doesn't have to go through progressions. He sees his guy and throws it, giving the d-line no chance to get to him. Meanwhile Romo typically goes through his reads, which gives the d-line more chance to get to him, especially when there is a shaky line in front of him.

It has little to do with his release, but more to do with the fact that he has to go through progressions, which Peyton doesn't do often. He knows where the ball is going, he just has to wait for his receiver to separate.

I'd say more that half the time, that is true. Peyton really is a computer on the field.
Watch any game though and you'll see a lot of plays where he hits his 2nd and 3rd option after going through a very quick progression.
 

Ender

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,970
Reaction score
515
Well as far as Red Ball goes, I agree. There have not been too many games over the last few seasons where I came away thinking he had outcoached or outsmarted the opponent. For the most part, some of our most impressive performances have been when the team completely scrapped the game plan and turned it into schoolyard ball. It would take a lot of convincing to get me to believe that Garrett has gotten the most out of anybody on the offense.

I wholeheartedly disagree, however, on Del Rio. I'm all for giving people second chances, but eight years in one place is a pretty long first chance. And in those eight seasons in Jacksonville, he only had two playoff appearances and never got past the wildcard round. He seems like a good motivator, but I really think we can do a lot better. Aside from his lackluster record in Jacksonville, I have big question marks about how he is as a personnel guy. I'm not sure who was running that show in Jacksonville, but there are some big personnel red flags that come up for me when I look at his Jags teams.

The next head coach being strong in the personnel department is a must for me, because I don't trust anyone currently in the organization has the smarts to be able to turn what we currently have into a championship contending team.

With all things considered, I think when we look back on the Romo era, the personnel decisions made will be the main reason this team didnt achieve a lot more. Jerry seemed to make impromptu signings and trades we all know about those awful drafts) to try to win as soon as possible instead of making actually having a structured rebuilding process. Once we saw that Romo had the potential to be great that should have been the number one objective.
 

ilykdrama

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,474
Reaction score
1,100
That's the big difference between he and Romo. Outside of just not being as physically gifted, Romo doesn't do the extra things to help himself.

How many times has Romo tried to draw someone offsides on a 2nd and short? You know, a prime passing down where you could take a big shot anyway, why not make it a 'free' big shot?

How many times has he pump faked a quick slant to free up a receiver?

Him and anyone. I get that Peyton is obviously gifted, and LOVES the game like anyone else. BUT the huge difference is, he doesn't rely on talent to get him by and treats it more like a profession than any other player. I think he prides himself in his career, in an employee of the month kinda way.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,902
Reaction score
15,993
BTW, all this Payton love means nothing is he loses the first playoff game they play this year.

As good as Peyton is he has less rings than his very mediocre brother.
End of the day it takes teams to win Super Bowls.
Peyton is just a really good start.
 

Beast_from_East

Well-Known Member
Messages
30,167
Reaction score
27,241
I have seen Romo play great, so I think this is just a slump

Opie's offense has always been crap

Guess who I am getting rid of?
 

DrunkWithPower

Active Member
Messages
327
Reaction score
238
I think the main difference between Manning and Romo (and all other QB's) is that Manning knows where the ball is going before the ball is snapped. Not every single play, but the majority of the time. So he doesn't have to go through progressions. He sees his guy and throws it, giving the d-line no chance to get to him. Meanwhile Romo typically goes through his reads, which gives the d-line more chance to get to him, especially when there is a shaky line in front of him.

It has little to do with his release, but more to do with the fact that he has to go through progressions, which Peyton doesn't do often. He knows where the ball is going, he just has to wait for his receiver to separate.

Bingo!

Watch the Eagles against the Commanders yesterday and you'll see the difference in two offenses - one with great play design and the other slogging it out trying find any opening for a pass play. We are like Washington - our guys have to win one on one match ups all the time, and the scheme doesn't help them much. Watch the Eagles and Denver play - almost every time a receiver is open it's because of clear out routes and overloading the zone coverage. Our receivers are good enough to get open, but our line doesn't give Romo the time to wait for them to clear. Earlier in the season he was more comfortable and we got some better passing plays, but now he's jumping around like Troy did his last year (Mr Happy Feet). We need to run the quick slants and bunch formations, and give Romo a very clear 1st target and very quick pass plays. Put the defense on their feet and once they make adjustments hit them with a double-move and get the good plays going. I am just tired of our crap offense...

I was watching the Eagles game yesterday and it was amazing how many time Foles just watched his one side of the field and hit a guy wide open. It wasn't because his receivers were winning the one on one battles every time, it was because the scheme provided the openings. Foles knew with confidence which guy was going to be open and fired it in there all day. With our talent, we should be doing the same thing all day long.
 

blindzebra

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,560
Reaction score
4,451
If we ran the Manning offense we'd set a record for most offensive pass interference ever.

Denver's offense is illegal it just isn't called.
 

maxdallasfan

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,268
Reaction score
1,528
I'm at the point where I give up on expecting anything more than mediocre with this team, no matter who coaches them.

And you all know the reason why.

No established coach will ever come here. And the future coaches who do, will only be puppets.
 

Frosty

Bigdog24
Messages
3,960
Reaction score
2,257
Garrett has demonstrated time and time again he does not provide any upside for this team, what exactly is his specialty, anyway. But I would LOVE to see Jack Del Rio as HC of the Cowboys.....He had the Jag's playing some mean football, especially on defense before the owner came in and got stupid. Can't blame Del Rio for the ownership issues in Jacksonville, anytime you try and sell the team and force the coach to draft a dud QB in the 1st round, (Blaine Gabert ouch) its a gonna be a disaster. Plus I like the Idea of giving a experienced ex-HC a second chance.....they already made their rookie mistakes and no what not to do the second time around....

I would fire Garrett in a NY minute to get JACK DEL RIO...... great 4-3 DC and gonna be a great HC and this team needs an experienced HC.


Only other possibles I would consider is, Jon Gruden, Shaw, Sumlin, or Lovie Smith,
There are others but I just don't care for the Zimmers, Whisenhut, Nolan's out there



Disclaimer: I'm not a English teachers so don't knock the grammar and spelling....
 

percyhoward

Research Tool
Messages
17,062
Reaction score
21,861
His footwork, accuracy and velocity are noticeably off.
If true, the effects of this are only seen on 3rd down.

Last Five Games Only
Romo, on 3rd down:
18 of 46 201 yd 1 td 3 int 33.0 (33rd in NFL)

Romo, on 1st and 2nd down:
86 of 136 957 yd 7 td 1 int 98.2 (3rd in NFL)
 
Top