Scout.com: NFL Power Rankings Version 1.0

Gryphon

Merge Ahead
Messages
3,407
Reaction score
31
By Adam Caplan
http://profootball.scout.com/2/864979.html
Senior NFL Reporter
Posted May 14, 2009

1) Pittsburgh Steelers: They proved last year that they could win the Super Bowl with a suspect offensive line. And keep in mind the running game should be buoyed by the return of second-year RB Rashard Mendenhall. But can Limas Sweed handle the third receiver role? Pittsburgh showed last season that if you have a decent offense and the league's best defense, you can win consistently.

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, C, S (depth)


2) Philadelphia Eagles: No team attacked the draft and free agency like this team, but they failed to find a blocking tight end. While free agency technically lasts all year, can they find someone who can help cure their red zone woes? Sure, they'll be able to run the ball better based on the help they got in free agency on the offensive line, but can they throw it better?

Needs Still to be Filled: TE


3) New York Giants: This team doesn't have many weaknesses and they addressed their weakness at receiver with two of them in the first three rounds of this year's draft. But who will handle the ball in the running game should Brandon Jacobs get hurt again? The only potential weakness looks to be at safety.

Needs Still to be Filled: S


4) Indianapolis Colts: It will be interesting to see how the coaches handle the running back rotation between Joseph Addai and Donald Brown. Look for Austin Collie to come in and be a factor right away as their third receiver. It also will be interesting to see how the defense does with Larry Coyer running the show.

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, DT


5) Atlanta Falcons: The offense looks to be complete now with the addition of Tony Gonzalez. But defensively, who can rush the passer other than John Abraham? Can they find a solid cover cornerback within their roster?

Needs Still to be Filled: DE, CB, S


6) San Diego Chargers: What will do they if LaDainian Tomlinson gets hurt again? Can Darren Sproles handle a lot of touches in Tominlson's absence? Can Shawne Merriman rebound from a lost season due to injury? The secondary needs to be more consistent. Can Antonio Cromartie bounce back?

Needs Still to be Filled: RB, DE


7) Minnesota Vikings: This team has what looks to be an average offensive line again. Can they handle the loss of Matt Birk? Can Percy Harvin stay out of trouble and prove to be worth a first-round pick? They have to find a reliable nickel back.

Needs Still to be Filled: RG, C, DT, S


8) Baltimore Ravens: They have to find help for Joe Flacco ASAP. Who will he throw to who can consistently command the football? Can they run it better than last season? Does Willis McGahee have anything left? Defensively, can Greg Mattison effectively replace coordinator Rex Ryan?

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, DE


9) New England Patriots: The return of a healthy Tom Brady will help, but the offensive line was a bit inconsistent last season. Since they run a spread offense, can Joey Galloway give them quality snaps at 37 years old? The secondary, which was poor last season, should improve with the additions at cornerback and safety. But failing to sign Jason Taylor could come back to haunt them. Can they find a consistent pass rush?

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, RT, OLB


10) New York Jets: It's amazing that they didn't replace Laveranues Coles, so who will catch the ball opposite Jerricho Cotchery? On defense, can they effectively replace Kenyon Coleman? Can they find quality play at cornerback opposite Darrelle Revis?

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, DE, OLB, S, CB


11) Tennessee Titans: The offense should be solid and they finally have what looks to be quality depth at receiver. They have to figure out how they are going to get a a consistent pass rush after losing Albert Hayensworth.

Needs Still to be Filled: DE, CB, S


12) Carolina Panthers: They might have the best rushing attack in the NFL, but can they pass the football when they need to? Who will rush the passer besides the inconsistent Julius Peppers? Can they find a suitable nickel back after cutting Ken Lucas?

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, DE, DT, OLB, CB


13) New Orleans Saints: They have a great offense, but can Pierre Thomas handle a lot of carries this season with Deuce McAllister out of the picture? Defensively, they have to find consistent pass rush to go along with much better play from their secondary.

Needs Still to be Filled: RB, DT, OLB


14) Arizona Cardinals: The offensive line looks to be average again and with the shift to more of a power rushing attack, they'll need to perform at a higher level. The loss of DE Antonio Smith is potentially huge. They have to find more of a pass rush and the secondary must also play better if they're going to get back to the playoffs again.

Needs Still to be Filled: TE, C, DE, CB


15) Houston Texans: Surprisingly, the team didn't sign a back or draft a running back for depth purposes? Can Steve Slaton hold up as the starter? He wore down last season. Defensively, the problems still exist in the secondary. The safety play has been poor since Houston's inaugural season in 2002.

Needs Still to be Filled: RB, G, DE (depth), S


16) Green Bay Packers: RT, DE, OLB, S

Needs Still to be Filled: With Mark Tausher unsigned and unlikely to return to the team, the right tackle position looks like an issue. Does this team have the personnel on defense to make the conversion to the 3-4 scheme successful?


17) Dallas Cowboys: I'm still trying to figure out if Roy Williams is a No. 1 receiver. If he's not, Dallas will have big problems in their passing game--Jason Witten can only do so much. The secondary looks like the weakness of their defense.

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, CB, S


18) Chicago Bears: Who will catch the passes from Jay Cutler? They really need to upgrade the receiver position. Defensively, they could use another pass rusher and depth in the secondary.

Needs Still to be Filled: QB (backup), WR, G, DE, CB


19) Washington Commanders: A lot of pressure will be put on Jason Campbell to move the football in the air this season, but who will catch it at receiver other than Santana Moss? The additions of Albert Haynesworth and Brian Orakpo will help, but this defense only posted 24 sacks last season.

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, RT, OLB


20) Miami Dolphins: They still lack quality playmakers at receiver and they need to make a bigger commitment to Ronnie Brown this season. It would have helped if they improved the tight end position with a good pass catcher. Adding Jason Taylor really should help on the other side of Joey Porter.

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, TE


21) Seattle Seahawks: RB, G

Needs Still to be Filled: Despite the struggles of Julius Jones last season, the team didn't add a single running back in free agency or in the draft. The offensive line, which was once of the top two or three, is looking pretty average these days. The secondary, which was poor last season, must rebound if Seattle is going to be competitive each week.


22) Buffalo Bills: The offensive line looks to be average at best, but the passing game looks to be improved. They'll certainly be able to run the football effectively. The defense will get help from a healthy Aaron Schobel, but he needs help on the other side. Aaron Maybin is more of a project than anything else at this point.

Needs Still to be Filled: LT, DE


23) Tampa Bay Buccaneers: The additions of Derrick Ward and Kellen Winslow should certainly help their offense. But it's looking like a shaky defense again. They have no depth to speak of on their defensive line and the secondary was shaky down the stretch last season.

Needs Still to be Filled: DE, DT, CB


24) Denver Broncos: The key for this team is for QB Kyle Orton to get off to a good start as he did with the Bear last season. But can he perform at a high level in a spread offense? This is going to be quite a change from what he's been used to. They certainly should be able to run the ball effectively. But can this defense, which has been pitiful in recent years, be at least average?

Needs Still to be Filled: DE, CB


25) Cincinnati Bengals: The offensive line is a shell of what it once was, but the addition of Andre Smith will help. Getting back a healthy Carson Palmer behind center has to help their offense as a whole. The defense, under Mike Zimmer, is probably a bit underrated and has a chance to surprise this season.

Needs Still to be Filled: RT, DT, DE, CB


26) San Francisco 49ers: The quarterback position, once again, could be the bane of their existence. They'll run a power rushing offense which will certainly help control the clock, but can they actually score points? And can the defense actually stop teams consistently? There are just too many questions to be answered for this team to be competitive each week.

Needs Still to be Filled: QB, OLB, S


27) Cleveland Browns: They have to stick with one quarterback this season and live with the results. Can they get anything out of the running game? Will they keep Braylon Edwards? Those questions will be answered in training camp. The defense was poor last season, so it will be up to Rob Ryan to get it back to respectability.

Needs Still to be Filled: RB, TE, OLB, CB


28) St. Louis Rams: They've done a nice job of rebuilding their offensive line, but there are still problems left on both sides of the ball. It will be interesting to see how new head coach Steve Spagnuolo improves what has been a very average defense in recent years.

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, DT, DE


29) Oakland Raiders: They should be able to run the ball fairly well, but can they pass it? They are going to be very young at receiver once again this season. The defense looks to be very ordinary again.

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, DE, CB


30) Jacksonville Jaguars: One of the keys to their offense is how much David Garrard can improve from last season. It would help if they got him better talent at the receiver position. Maurice Jones-Drew is a star in the making, but can he hold up all season with the expected increase in touches? Why was Mel Tucker brought in after the Cleveland defense collapsed last season?

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, TE, DT, S, CB


31) Detroit Lions: They filled a bunch of needs during the draft and in free agency, but they've got a long way to go toward respectability. This team underachieved in a major way last season and they're not devoid of talent. It's up to the new coaching staff to get them headed in the right direction.

Needs Still to be Filled: G, DE, DT


32) Kansas City Chiefs: They made upgrades at quarterback, guard, defensive end, and linebacker. But no team had more needs coming into the draft. New team czar Scott Pioli has this team on the right track, but it's going to take a while for them to be very competitive again.

Needs Still to be Filled: WR, OLB (pass rusher)
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,104
Reaction score
11,426
Wow, that might be the worst list in history.

The Jets at #10? The Patriots at #9? Us behind the Texans and Packers?
 

sonnyboy

Benched
Messages
7,357
Reaction score
0
Does this person follow the league? I'll stick the Cowboys since this is a Cowboys site.

#17? Are you facking kidding me. I don't know any eagle fans that would rank us so low.

These things are subjective and I've been anticipating little to no love for the Cowboys after our 2008 finish.

But #17 is a joke and Caplan just a hater.
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
Scout.com
Needs Still to be Filled: Competent writing staff.
 

BourbonBalz

Star4Ever
Messages
12,207
Reaction score
8,178
This is about as bad as I've ever seen. Has the writer ever watched an NFL game or is he just an Olympic skating fan trying broaden his interests?
 

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member
Messages
54,310
Reaction score
32,715
Ditto for the Jets at 10.

The fact that they highlighted the loss of Kenyon Coleman as something significant tells you all you need to know.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,663
Reaction score
86,202
I could do a better job by pulling team names out of a hat.
 

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"
Staff member
Messages
47,997
Reaction score
27,917
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I certainly wouldn't homer out and give the Cowboys a top-5 ranking-- but 17th?

Adam Caplan has proven that he doesn't know **** from shinola.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
81,285
Reaction score
102,215
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
As soon as I seen Dallas was not in the top10, or even top 8, I stopped reading. Not to sound like a homer, but this list sucks, and is why I guess I never go to scout.com
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,482
Reaction score
67,294
Chocolate Lab;2776895 said:
Wow, that might be the worst list in history.

The Jets at #10? The Patriots at #9? Us behind the Texans and Packers?

JPM;2776920 said:
The Pats at 9 is beyond stupid.

tyke1doe;2776925 said:
Ditto for the Jets at 10.

The fact that they highlighted the loss of Kenyon Coleman as something significant tells you all you need to know.

Don't forget about the Colts at 4 while the Titans, who have lost nothing, get dropped down to 11.

I usually don't pay a lot of attention to Power Rankings, but this one was so ignorant I couldn't pass.
 

bbgun

Benched
Messages
27,869
Reaction score
6
Alexander;2776951 said:
Don't forget about the Colts at 4 while the Titans, who have lost nothing, get dropped down to 11.

Well, Haynesworth is a pretty significant loss, but maybe not enough to send them plummeting like that.
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,482
Reaction score
67,294
bbgun;2776955 said:
Well, Haynesworth is a pretty significant loss, but maybe not enough to send them plummeting like that.

The Colts lost their head coach, all-time WR, offensive coordinator and offensive line coach. The Titans lost Haynesworth.

I'll take the Titans situation.
 

TD-33

Benched
Messages
2,542
Reaction score
0
PosterChild;2776957 said:
He even spelled his own last name wrong.
:lmao:

:lmao2:
LOL as I read that ridiculous mess I knew the replies would be better content.
What an idiot.
 

Wrangler87

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,178
Reaction score
123
Alexander;2776965 said:
The Colts lost their head coach, all-time WR, offensive coordinator and offensive line coach. The Titans lost Haynesworth.

I'll take the Titans situation.


I think most people feel like the Titans were a bit of a fluke last season. I tend to agree. I certainly would not have them out of the top ten, but probably around ten.

I feel like the Cowboys should be around 5-7. I, personally, think the moves we made in the offseason will make us a better team. I worry a little bit about WR. I am very concerned about Adams. Other than that, we solved many of our problems, on and off the field.
 
Top