Smart Free Agency Moves So Far

Chuck 54

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,057
Reaction score
14,353
Disclaimer: I’m not saying this was a great free agent period thus far. Clearly, most of us wish we had signed 2-3 star studs and were thinking about a championship. Yeah, that ain’t happening in Dallas. However, this has been a departure from the norm, and Dan Quinn has already made some changes in the Jones think tank.

What was our biggest problem last year outside of injuries? Defense
What was wrong with the defense? Couldn’t stop the run and routinely blown coverages in the secondary first half of season, surrendering easy TDs. Play-action also killed us because we couldn’t stop the run.

Why couldn’t we stop the run no matter how hard we tried? DL, especially DT issues, again thanks to season injuries to McCoy, Hill, part time injury to Woods, signing a DT who sucked in Carolina the previous year just because of his name, and a general lack of attention to the position. This also caused the DEs to play poorly....trying to do too much at times. This also caused the LBs to play on skates because OLinemen were always at the second level too easily. Some blame the LBs and say they should have made plays anyway. I’ll be honest...I don’t know what we have at LB. I’ve lost confidence. I know I’ve seen them play well and touted as one of the best young groups in the division, but even if they are just average, the best LBs in the league need quality, disciplined play in front of them. No LBs are going to beat 300 lb linemen and make tackles at the line of scrimmage.

So, what have we accomplished in FA. No, we didn’t sign some big name DT to a big contract just to have a run stuffer who can’t rush the QB. We have two young DTs in Hill and Gallimore. We added a very good 3-4 DE who is a 300 pounder, a guy who now will play DT, but can play DE in run situations. We signed a 6’7” DT who played in rotations with Tenn, Baltimore, and Chicago (all good defenses)...he’s another 300 pounder and graded out as the 3rd best run defender in the NFL, another guy who can play DT or DE in situations. Great pro bowlers? No, but maybe the deepest, strongest, heaviest DT group of 4 we’ve fielded in years.

DE, we have one of the best run defenders in Lawrence + Gregory who really came on during the year, a guy who plays the run better than one would expect at his size. We added a DE to rotate with Gregory, a guy who didn’t rack up sacks in NY, but was good vs the run, a guy who excelled as a DE in college but was playing OLB in NY. I don’t expect a star, but he will be better with his hand in the dirt, as will our own Armstrong, who was also out of position last year as a stand up OLB.

Secondary? I was hoping for Adore Jackson on a reasonable contract, but the man got PAID. So we finally addressed the safety position, and while people complain about 1-year contracts, we signed young guys who have been successful. Both Neal and Kazee have played very well when healthy. Both have created plenty of turnovers via either fumbles or INTs. Neal can play WLB, improving the run defense, covering RBs and TEs, but he can also play the deep half at times or SS when needed. Kazee had some great stats at single high safety before this year’s injury. They are both young players. We signed Kearse, primarily as a very good special teamer, but also as a young guy with great size and range who can provide depth and possibly develop. Let’s not dismiss the value of having Neal and Kazee on the field, guys who know and played the defense at the safety positions in Atlanta. Hopefully, that will also cut down on blown coverages and improve quick communication on the back end.

Neal and Kearse and even Hooker are all coming off injury, all young, all very talented, so 1-year contracts were smart. 1. You need to see if they fully recover and play well and avoid further injury before offering more. Aside from injury, we would all be thrilled with even 1 signing. 2. I’m betting their contracts contain an option that allows us to extend and resign any or all who play well and avoid injury.

And on offense, despite all the experience gained by Knight and Steele, we signed the best swing tackle we’ve had since Parnell. Big, tall, experienced OT who was on the field this past year and is healthy and available!

Simply compared with recent years in FA, recent lack of attention to DT or Safety, this has been a very good start and departure from Dallas practices. No, we didn’t find healthy superstars at big prices, but we found proven players who are very good at what we need them to do, and at least those coming off injury have been good players and are very young.

Before free agency ends, before the draft even arrives, I can say confidently that we are going to be better in 2021 at OL, QB, DL vs the run, and at Safety than we were in 2020. That’s not GREAT, but it’s something to go with having a better DC and more sound defensive scheme.
 
Last edited:
After committing a significant portion of the cap over the next several years to Dak, we were never in position to sign real playmakers.

Our only hope of significant improvement is the draft. If we can find a couple big time players in the first two rounds, 10 wins isn’t out of the question.
 
They were smart with the dline, average with corner, terrible with safety.
 
Smart? They are thrifty but I think it's too early to say they are smart moves. Maybe so but we'll see.

Every year is a new year but if history is any indicator, these types of moves never really move the needle much for the Cowboys. That being said, I think Kazee, if healthy, could really help. But being healthy coming off an achilles is a big concern.

I also think the swing OT is a decent signing. He's old but he's still a decent OT.
 
They were smart with the dline, average with corner, terrible with safety.
I’m just curious why you think they are terrible with Safety. I’m really happy, thinking these guys would have been too expensive for us if healthy, and I love that they just finished their rookie contracts. Most of the big name safeties were franchised. What else could we have done?
 
We’ve gone from the Dollar General bargain bin to the TJ Max clearance rack. That’s a big jump.
LMAO, and the focus on DT and S instead of overpaying for a CB or has been DE is a big step.
 
They brought in a bunch of role players.....which is a nice way of saying that they will play cheap because they arent that good.

History tells us this approach to FA doesn't work.

History also tells us that when the Dallas Cowboys go into a season looking great on paper they typically disappoint.

So maybe these guys find it together as a unit.

I wouldn't be surprised if the defense is remarkably better, and it wouldn't surprise me if it's just as bad as last year.

Impossible to say at this point.
 
I’m just curious why you think they are terrible with Safety. I’m really happy, thinking these guys would have been too expensive for us if healthy, and I love that they just finished their rookie contracts. Most of the big name safeties were franchised. What else could we have done?
Rayshawn Jenkins. A good, healthy player with attitude but were not interested in that. And his contract wasnt huge. Wouldve been a better investment than resigning Lewis
 
LMAO, and the focus on DT and S instead of overpaying for a CB or has been DE is a big step.

What "focus"?

They signed a bunch of JAGs at both positions. Just signing numbers doesn't equate to focus to me. They signed one S who is going to play WLB most likely. They signed another who really isn't all that good outside of being good on special teams and the last guy appears to be a decent FS but is coming off a major leg injury. DT? They signed a guy in Watkins that is a dime a dozen player and a guy in Urban that people act like is the best run stopper in the NFL.

This isn't all that different than the other bargain bin moves we made at DT and S. And I like the Kazee signing given where we are but he's a big risk.
 
What "focus"?

They signed a bunch of JAGs at both positions. Just signing numbers doesn't equate to focus to me. They signed one S who is going to play WLB most likely. They signed another who really isn't all that good outside of being good on special teams and the last guy appears to be a decent FS but is coming off a major leg injury. DT? They signed a guy in Watkins that is a dime a dozen player and a guy in Urban that people act like is the best run stopper in the NFL.

This isn't all that different than the other bargain bin moves we made at DT and S. And I like the Kazee signing given where we are but he's a big risk.

Yep nothing new...
 
I agree on Kazee. I think Neal if healthy is the real deal though.

I am sick to death of reading and hearing that. Guess that's all they can do given the cap situation, but having to hope first of all a player can actually get on the field before even trying to determine if they can help the team is so tiresome...
 
Rayshawn Jenkins. A good, healthy player with attitude but were not interested in that. And his contract wasnt huge. Wouldve been a better investment than resigning Lewis
He hasn’t been a starter. He was their 4th safety last year and started only one game. Had 58 tackles for the season. Lewis plays CB? The only guy we signed for whom this argument might fit is Kearse.
 
I am sick to death of reading and hearing that. Guess that's all they can do given the cap situation, but having to hope first of all a player can actually get on the field before even trying to determine if they can help the team is so tiresome...

Neal played in 15 games last year the only game he missed was week 4, there is no question he will be on the field.
 
Disclaimer: I’m not saying this was a great free agent period thus far. Clearly, most of us wish we had signed 2-3 star studs and were thinking about a championship. Yeah, that ain’t happening in Dallas. However, this has been a departure from the norm, and Dan Quinn has already made some changes in the Jones think tank.

What was our biggest problem last year outside of injuries? Defense
What was wrong with the defense? Couldn’t stop the run and routinely blown coverages in the secondary first half of season, surrendering easy TDs. Play-action also killed us because we couldn’t stop the run.

Why couldn’t we stop the run no matter how hard we tried? DL, especially DT issues, again thanks to season injuries to McCoy, Hill, part time injury to Woods, signing a DT who sucked in Carolina the previous year just because of his name, and a general lack of attention to the position. This also caused the DEs to play poorly....trying to do too much at times. This also caused the LBs to play on skates because OLinemen were always at the second level too easily. Some blame the LBs and say they should have made plays anyway. I’ll be honest...I don’t know what we have at LB. I’ve lost confidence. I know I’ve seen them play well and touted as one of the best young groups in the division, but even if they are just average, the best LBs in the league need quality, disciplined play in front of them. No LBs are going to beat 300 lb linemen and make tackles at the line of scrimmage.

So, what have we accomplished in FA. No, we didn’t sign some big name DT to a big contract just to have a run stuffer who can’t rush the QB. We have two young DTs in Hill and Gallimore. We added a very good 3-4 DE who is a 300 pounder, a guy who now will play DT, but can play DE in run situations. We signed a 6’7” DT who played in rotations with Tenn, Baltimore, and Chicago (all good defenses)...he’s another 300 pounder and graded out as the 3rd best run defender in the NFL, another guy who can play DT or DE in situations. Great pro bowlers? No, but maybe the deepest, strongest, heaviest DT group of 4 we’ve fielded in years.

DE, we have one of the best run defenders in Lawrence + Gregory who really came on during the year, a guy who plays the run better than one would expect at his size. We added a DE to rotate with Gregory, a guy who didn’t rack up sacks in NY, but was good vs the run, a guy who excelled as a DE in college but was playing OLB in NY. I don’t expect a star, but he will be better with his hand in the dirt, as will our own Armstrong, who was also out of position last year as a stand up OLB.

Secondary? I was hoping for Adore Jackson on a reasonable contract, but the man got PAID. So we finally addressed the safety position, and while people complain about 1-year contracts, we signed young guys who have been successful. Both Neal and Kazee have played very well when healthy. Both have created plenty of turnovers via either fumbles or INTs. Neal can play WLB, improving the run defense, covering RBs and TEs, but he can also play the deep half at times or SS when needed. Kazee had some great stats at single high safety before this year’s injury. They are both young players. We signed Kearse, primarily as a very good special teamer, but also as a young guy with great size and range who can provide depth and possibly develop. Let’s not dismiss the value of having Neal and Kazee on the field, guys who know and played the defense at the safety positions in Atlanta. Hopefully, that will also cut down on blown coverages and improve quick communication on the back end.

Neal and Kearse and even Hooker are all coming off injury, all young, all very talented, so 1-year contracts were smart. 1. You need to see if they fully recover and play well and avoid further injury before offering more. Aside from injury, we would all be thrilled with even 1 signing. 2. I’m betting their contracts contain an option that allows us to extend and resign any or all who play well and avoid injury.

And on offense, despite all the experience gained by Knight and Steele, we signed the best swing tackle we’ve had since Parnell. Big, tall, experienced OT who was on the field this past year and is healthy and available!

Simply compared with recent years in FA, recent lack of attention to DT or Safety, this has been a very good start and departure from Dallas practices. No, we didn’t find healthy superstars at big prices, but we found proven players who are very good at what we need them to do, and at least those coming off injury have been good players and are very young.

Before free agency ends, before the draft even arrives, I can say confidently that we are going to be better in 2021 at OL, QB, DL vs the run, and at Safety than we were in 2020. That’s not GREAT, but it’s something to go with having a better DC and more sound defensive scheme.
Now sire you know positivity isn't allowed in this place lol
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,684
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top