so long stanback and courtney brown..

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,638
Reaction score
30,240
Dcowboy84;2911626 said:
i guess i'm apparently the extreme minority on this, but i really don't think Stanback lost his spot b/c of tonight.

Brown - yes!

Proctor - should've been gone last year.

but i think Stanback was fine. by no means did he earn his spot, but i don't think he lost it either.

the fumble (if it really was a fumble, i can't say b/c the internet feed sucked) seems more to me like one heck of a job by the DB. should he have still held on? yes, but i can bet there's a great # of WRs who also have that ball stripped in the same situation.

i think all of my points are moot points b/c i think in the end he doesn't make this team. however i just felt the need to point out that he is not going to lose his spot on the team b/c of that play, he will lose it b/c Ogletree is just flat-out playing better.

What has he shown in 3 pre season games? Seriously?
 

28 Joker

28 Joker
Messages
7,878
Reaction score
1
Pat Watkins needs to go, but Micheal Hamlin broke his wrist.

The Special teams penalty machine lives.

Plus, he never makes plays at safety, and he makes mental mistakes back there.

I was so sure he was gone, but now...

Unbelievable.
 

DMX690

Well-Known Member
Messages
748
Reaction score
454
41gy#;2911658 said:
Pat Watkins needs to go, but Micheal Hamlin broke his wrist.

The Special teams penalty machine lives.

Plus, he never makes plays at safety, and he makes mental mistakes back there.

I was so sure he was gone, but now...

Unbelievable.

Watkins is going to end up kill he's too skinny and weak to play in the NFL.
 

MONT17

New Member
Messages
3,269
Reaction score
0
I wonder how many GMs around the NFL busted out laughing when they saw Procter/or get a 2cd round tender! Im glad Ogletree is showing Cowboy fans what a promising young WR can do for an offense... can we still get that 2cd round pick from the Jets, for Miles, because its night and day!
 

TheSport78

The Excellence of Execution
Messages
10,416
Reaction score
3,686
41gy#;2911658 said:
Pat Watkins needs to go, but Micheal Hamlin broke his wrist.

The Special teams penalty machine lives.

Plus, he never makes plays at safety, and he makes mental mistakes back there.

I was so sure he was gone, but now...

Unbelievable.

How do you know Hamlin broke his wrist?
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
AbeBeta;2911527 said:
I think both make it to the final pre-season game... I've been a Stanbacker but after tonight I think he may be done here.
Me too. He and Brown stood out tonight for lack of seizing the brass ring.
 

marchetta

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,185
Reaction score
1,653
Muhast;2911585 said:
Watkins will make the team but I'd prefer him to take a spot over proctor/Stanback/Brown

Watkins is on the team. Heck, we drafted players specifically for their ST abilities, and Watkins is one of the best gunners in the NFL. I remember reading that he was one of the best in college also.
 

UnoDallas

Benched
Messages
5,914
Reaction score
0
Biggems;2911629 said:
Brown, Stanback, Procter, and Watkins all need to go......too be honest, since he is always hurt, Cricket needs to go as well. I say either keep Crosslin or that TE from Southlake Carroll

I agree keep Crosslin and Chandler

I think we keep Stewart at LBer
Carp goes down what do we do ?
 

LeonDixson

Illegitimi non carborundum
Messages
12,299
Reaction score
6,808
Rampage;2911806 said:
what did Stanglass do or should i say not do?
For one thing, he caught a pass and then promptly fumbled the ball to kill a drive.
 

tskyler

Active Member
Messages
218
Reaction score
28
Hostile;2911744 said:
Me too. He and Brown stood out tonight for lack of seizing the brass ring.

Don't disagree at all. Just not ready to write Stanbach off. Proctor and Brown have looked awful. Watkins isn't in the same league but I have seen cause for serious concern. Stanbach hasn't really stepped up but I haven't smelled the stench of a failed experiment yet. I am also not sold on Ogletree as the second coming. I think Ogletree has earned receiver #5, just not sure Stanbach has blown the #6 spot. I have no 53 in my head yet with all the draftee injuries so I have no feeling if that spot will be there.
 

Rampage

Benched
Messages
24,117
Reaction score
2
LeonDixson;2911892 said:
For one thing, he caught a pass and then promptly fumbled the ball to kill a drive.
guess he just fumbled away a chance to be on this team.
 

Hoofbite

Well-Known Member
Messages
40,882
Reaction score
11,587
Dcowboy84;2911626 said:
i guess i'm apparently the extreme minority on this, but i really don't think Stanback lost his spot b/c of tonight.

Brown - yes!

Proctor - should've been gone last year.

but i think Stanback was fine. by no means did he earn his spot, but i don't think he lost it either.

the fumble (if it really was a fumble, i can't say b/c the internet feed sucked) seems more to me like one heck of a job by the DB. should he have still held on? yes, but i can bet there's a great # of WRs who also have that ball stripped in the same situation.

i think all of my points are moot points b/c i think in the end he doesn't make this team. however i just felt the need to point out that he is not going to lose his spot on the team b/c of that play, he will lose it b/c Ogletree is just flat-out playing better.

Stanback shouldn't have been making this team since day 1. Tonight was just an affirmation of that. He's been nothing but potential since the day he was drafted. I used to pull for the guy but anymore I can't wait for him to be done. Feel bad because he was picked with such expectations and never really did a thing. Not really his fault people expected as much as they did but thats the way it goes.

As far as tonight goes, he looked terrible. He gets a few chances per game and hasn't made any of them count. His kick returns were far from special and his play at the WR position sucked.

I thank my lucky stars that Ogletree came along because without him, Stanback would make the roster again despite sucking so much.
 

Muhast

Newo
Messages
7,661
Reaction score
368
marchetta;2911765 said:
Watkins is on the team. Heck, we drafted players specifically for their ST abilities, and Watkins is one of the best gunners in the NFL. I remember reading that he was one of the best in college also.


I know, I meant Id much rather keep him over those 3 guys. He gets a lot of penalties, but the job he does on ST outweighs that in my mind.
 

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
21,556
Reaction score
22,660
I think all three will be cut but would not be surprised if they stick around for the next game due to the injuries we are having.
 
Top