Something to consider when evaluating the Cowboys Defense and Vince Young

cobra

Salty *******
Messages
3,134
Reaction score
0
When game-planning to play a team, the Defense reviews footage of the opposing team's offense and tries to prepare ways to counteract the tendencies of the scheme and the quarterback. When you have a bye week, you have extra time to prepare to play for the other team.

Coming out of the bye week, the Cowboys defense played well, but not as well as it could have. The reason for this, I think, is that Fisher did not tell us that Young was starting until the last minute.

The Cowboys did not have footage of Young. They had no tape to review on Young since this was his first NFL start. I suspect the Defense game-planned the last couple weeks to face Collins. When the last-minute switch to Young happened, I think our Defense had to play more cautiously. They did not know what to expect from Young. They did not know what kind of routes, formations, and the like that Tennessee would be throwing out there.

I think that effected our ability to be aggressive. We had to respond to Young instead of attacking him because we didn't know what they were going to be doing with him or what Young was going to try to do with the ball.

The unknown effect is amplified in this instance due to the kind of player Young is. If you are game-planning for Warner in Arizona and Leinart gets put in at the last minute, your game plan probably isn't going to change much. But if you are planning for Kerry Collins and they throw in Vince Young--perhaps the biggest question mark talent to enter the league in recent memory--then you are kind of thrown off a little bit.

The Cowboys played well. Vince Young made some decent looking throws, but made some raw mistakes. Vince did not take off and run as much as one would have anticipated he would have.

Other teams playing the Titans from here on out will now have some tape of Young with which to game plan. Other teams will also prepare all week with the knowledge that Young will be the starter.

When evaluating our defense's performance, I think that when consider this fact, they played well. They were guinea pigs having to figure out a great unknown on the fly.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,834
Reaction score
103,558
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Nice point, but I wouldn't agree that the Cowboys were unprepared for Young.

While they do have limited pro footage on him, they have plenty of college and preseason stuff.

And Parcells knew that Young was going to start - he said as much earlier in the week.

Despite what Fisher stated publicly, Parcells knew Young was starting and prepared the team for it.

Given Young's mobility and inclination to run, the Cowboys' defenders stressed gap-control and keeping Young in the pocket - wher he's less effective.

I thought they did a nice job of that and did what they needed to in order to win.
 

dmq

If I'm so pretty, why am I available?
Messages
7,436
Reaction score
941
Honestly, knowing you are facing a rookie in his first game gives you every reason in the world to be aggressive.
We played a big time immobile QB in week one and didn't get near him.
We didn't get near MB until we had wrapped the game up. I am worried about this because I see a trend here. We have no imagination on defense. It is gonna bite us badly soon enough. Could be against Philly. We can't let Mcnabb sit back in the pocket all day or he is gonna kill us.
 

hmcorp

Member
Messages
709
Reaction score
14
I cant believe a defense that almost has 5 interceptions 3 forced fumbles 2 sacks a touchdown off an interception and gives up a little over 230 total yards has a bad day!!!

HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAH!! I hope we have more bad days like this one.

They just started out slow in the first half. Then pretty much didnt let tennessee do anything.
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
hmcorp;1064930 said:
I cant believe a defense that almost has 5 interceptions 3 forced fumbles 2 sacks a touchdown off an interception and gives up a little over 230 total yards has a bad day!!!

HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAH!! I hope we have more bad days like this one.

They just started out slow in the first half. Then pretty much didnt let tennessee do anything.

If some fans had their way we would have been sending the kitchen sink at Young and allow him to do what he does the best. Thankfully Dallas coaches took away what Young likes to do which is run and create plays on the move.
 

cobra

Salty *******
Messages
3,134
Reaction score
0
hmcorp;1064930 said:
I cant believe a defense that almost has 5 interceptions 3 forced fumbles 2 sacks a touchdown off an interception and gives up a little over 230 total yards has a bad day!!!

HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAH!! I hope we have more bad days like this one.

They just started out slow in the first half. Then pretty much didnt let tennessee do anything.

Who said the defense played badly?

I said they played well. I was trying to state a basis to explain the problem some people had with our gameplan because players weren't pinning their ear's back and going after Vince like madmen.
 
Top