Understood, Roy
So, when the point of the Tempo Offense (no-huddle) is to prevent the defense from substitutions, and then you call a quick play to get a first down by catching the defense off guard, I understand that.
And McCarthy is not going to run Tempo in a blowout, unless it's to get a 3rd and short or something to keep the defense from substituting, because the purpose is to use the clock, not run plays that use little time.
But in the few games, McCarthy and Dak go to a Tempo Offense after getting the first down, so then on 1st and 10, it's a pass play, and I guess the immediate read downfield is covered, so then it's just a dump off to the flat for 2 yards. Yes, it prevents a sack and such, which is good. But if you're running Tempo, and you don't have a good play action play called or some play design called to get someone downfield 1-on-1 (or better yet, OPEN because of the play structure), then it's just wasted Tempo. The McCarthy/Dak Tempo Offense never seems to produce much, unless it's at the of the first half.
So, no, I'm not complaining about Dak not forcing a deep throw, and no, I'm not one of those fans who think that only one person is at fault for each bad play.
But, I AM complaining (yes, blueblood, I am indeed complaining
) about McCarthy and Dak running a Tempo Offense on 1st and 10, dropping back to pass, and then either not letting the play develop for a longer play downfield, or just immediately looking to the flat, as if the primary receiver was a 2-yard flat, I guess hoping the defense wouldn't cover the receiver in the flat so there was a chance for YAC. I don't know WHOSE fault it is, but I'm looking at McCarthy who's the architect, so he needs to find a way through play design to get someone open downfield (and it doesn't need to be a bomb) for at least a 10- to 20-yard throw. And I'm looking at Dak who runs tempo, looks downfield for .5 seconds (with no pressure around him yet), and then just dumps it off to the flat for 2 yards. Hec, if Dak is that scared to hold onto the ball (if you don't trust the o-line), OK, I get it....then DON'T RUN TEMPO ON FIRST DOWN THEN. There's no need, if there's not a good chance of taking advantage of the defensive personnel on the field. Just huddle up. Sheesh! One time, Dak ran Tempo, and didn't even look downfield, he
immediately looked at the flat.
I need a bit more creativity out of McCarthy and Dak. If the downfield throw isn't there and the Dee line is breaking free, then all Dak has to do is airmail it over everyone's head in the flat and line back up for 2nd and 10. No need to even try to force a well-covered 2-yard flat pass at that point. And if the flat is open for the 2-yard gain, take it.
I'm just trying to understand their thought process for running Tempo after getting a 1st down, only to not take advantage of the defensive personnel...and just throwing a quick pass in the flat for little yardage. That posed no threat to the defense, even though you kept the "tired", 3rd down personnel on the field.