Tanier Draft Review

JD_KaPow

jimnabby
Messages
11,185
Reaction score
10,971
https://www.footballoutsiders.com/walkthrough/2023/nfl-draft-2023-non-grades

Mike Tanier
in
Walkthrough

NFL Draft 2023 (Non) Grades​


Dallas Cowboys​

Improved Roster: B
Used Resources Well: B-
Met Needs: B
FINAL PPA: B


We enter every draft expecting the Cowboys to do loopy, splashy stuff. In most cases, they just add a collection of big/strong/fast guys, most of whom fill a need and come with a round-appropriate scouting report, perhaps with a dash of splash.

Mazi Smith is going to make Micah Parsons and Tank Lawrence better by munching about 45 double-teams per game. I also enjoyed Parsons' "no more sneaks" messaging. I don't think defenses can solve the quarterback sneak issue with manpower, but it's interesting to watch teams and players try to address the problem.

Luke Schoonmaker is a talented athlete and a sturdy blocker. He's a solid system fit for a team that probably plans to feature its receivers and use the tight end as a safety valve in the passing game, though Schoonmaker is fast enough to beat linebackers up the seam.

Yes, Deuce Vaughn's father works for the Cowboys, and he's only 5-foot-5. Vaughn's a thick little bocce ball, though, and the fact that the Cowboys pursued a Tony Pollard change-up in the sixth round instead of a Zeke Elliott surrogate in the first or second round illustrates the difference between Cowboys philosophies and Cowboys Internet memes.

The rest of the Cowboys draft class isn't all that interesting, and they didn't do any significant trading. Like the Bills, Bengals, and Chiefs (but not the Eagles), they acted like a Super Bowl contender just looking to plug holes and fine-tune the roster. But they are the Cowboys, so we always expect something more, or less, or just more COWBOYS.
 
Interest is in the eye of the beholder. I'm very interested in the Fehoko pick. I view him kind of like Golston when we took him a couple of years ago. He wasn't a great fit at end because he had length but not the speed to win the edge. However, we viewed Golston as a player who could gain some weight and move inside where his speed would be adequate enough. Fehoko should be viewed similarly. Maybe he plays some base end on run downs at first, but we're mainly looking him as an edge player who will be a better fit as a 3-tech once he bulks up some. Since he's already 280, he might can contribute some in that role this season as we continue looking for players who can be disruptive from that 3-tech spot.
 
https://www.footballoutsiders.com/walkthrough/2023/nfl-draft-2023-non-grades

Mike Tanier
in
Walkthrough

NFL Draft 2023 (Non) Grades​


Dallas Cowboys​

Improved Roster: B
Used Resources Well: B-
Met Needs: B
FINAL PPA: B


We enter every draft expecting the Cowboys to do loopy, splashy stuff. In most cases, they just add a collection of big/strong/fast guys, most of whom fill a need and come with a round-appropriate scouting report, perhaps with a dash of splash.

Mazi Smith is going to make Micah Parsons and Tank Lawrence better by munching about 45 double-teams per game. I also enjoyed Parsons' "no more sneaks" messaging. I don't think defenses can solve the quarterback sneak issue with manpower, but it's interesting to watch teams and players try to address the problem.

Luke Schoonmaker is a talented athlete and a sturdy blocker. He's a solid system fit for a team that probably plans to feature its receivers and use the tight end as a safety valve in the passing game, though Schoonmaker is fast enough to beat linebackers up the seam.

Yes, Deuce Vaughn's father works for the Cowboys, and he's only 5-foot-5. Vaughn's a thick little bocce ball, though, and the fact that the Cowboys pursued a Tony Pollard change-up in the sixth round instead of a Zeke Elliott surrogate in the first or second round illustrates the difference between Cowboys philosophies and Cowboys Internet memes.

The rest of the Cowboys draft class isn't all that interesting, and they didn't do any significant trading. Like the Bills, Bengals, and Chiefs (but not the Eagles), they acted like a Super Bowl contender just looking to plug holes and fine-tune the roster. But they are the Cowboys, so we always expect something more, or less, or just more COWBOYS.
I will give Tanier a D+ for that shallow review.
 
Under Miami they include the Ramsey trade to improve the grade.

But with Dallas their trades are never mentioned. Include the trades and Dallas gets straight "A"s.
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,658
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top