Teams turning to two backs, but not all are created equal

JonCJG

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,175
Reaction score
162
Per ESPN Insider


One recent trend in the NFL is that teams are creating depth at running back and more and more teams are using a two-back system. Here's a look at duos that will have success this season and others that will struggle.

Dynamic Duos

Minnesota's Adrian Peterson and Chester Taylor

The Vikings had the NFL's No. 1 run offense last season for many reasons, but their success starts with the guys who carry the rock. Peterson burst onto the scene as a rookie and showed he is the league's most physical runner between the tackles. What makes him even more dangerous is the power-speed combination he possesses. His ability to run over the defender without losing momentum makes him the most feared pure downhill runner in the NFL. That said, Taylor is no slouch. Two years ago, when Peterson was still in college, Taylor was a 1,300-yard rusher. Last season, he carried the load when Peterson was injured and finished the season with a 5.4 yard-per-carry average and seven touchdowns. Though neither Peterson nor Taylor is a pure speed back, each complements the other very well behind the best offensive line in the NFL.

Jacksonville's Fred Taylor and Maurice Jones-Drew

The Jaguars' backs make up one of the most explosive duos in the NFL. They pressure defenses to remain in position all day because any mental breakdowns or one guy's getting in the wrong gap can result in a big play at any time. Taylor is as healthy as he has been at any point in his career. His vision and ability to make the first defender miss in the hole look as good as they did earlier in his career. Jones-Drew plays much faster than he times and is a threat to score any time he touches the football.

Dallas' Marion Barber and Felix Jones

As soon as the Cowboys selected Jones, I started envisioning how this backfield would shape up in 2008. The rest of the NFC East likely started having nightmares. Now that Julius Jones has left for Seattle, Barber is now the lead back. He is one of the most physical runners in the NFL and leaves a mark when he runs over a defender. Jones' quickness and speed make him the perfect complement. One of the toughest adjustments a defense has to make is when it goes from seeing a physical, between-the-tackles runner to a speed guy. In terms of pure explosiveness when combining strength and speed, this duo is unmatched.

Pittsburgh's Willie Parker and Rashard Mendenhall

Pittsburgh wasn't supposed to be on this list. But then the second-best rookie running back in the 2008 class fell into the Steelers' laps. Though Parker is a speed back who has shown he can carry the load, depth has been a concern for the Steelers. Plus, Parker is coming back from a season-ending injury, so adding Mendenhall made sense. He is a physical runner who should provide nice balance in the backfield to "Fast Willie" and a Pittsburgh offense that will try to re-establish its tough, blue-collar mentality this season.

Seattle's Julius Jones and T.J. Duckett

Unhappy with his backfield, Mike Holmgren decided to shake things up. In a rare move, the Seahawks dipped into the unrestricted free-agent running back market twice in the offseason in an effort to get one star running back via two bodies. A change of scenery will help Jones, who was never given a full opportunity to succeed in Dallas. Once he got the "soft" label, his days of being given the opportunity to carry the load went by the wayside. Duckett is a journeyman but is a proven backup with solid size and the power to run between the tackles.


Destined Duds

Tennessee's LenDale White and Chris Henry

The Titans ran the ball well last season, but that's not necessarily a reflection of White and Henry. Instead, that success stemmed from an offensive line that won't be as good in 2008. White is inconsistent and, if history is a guide, likely will show up out of shape. Henry is a workout warrior but is unproven. Throw in rookie Chris Johnson, who was the fastest back among the rookie runners, and the Titans have bodies. How those bodies will mesh remains to be seen.

Detroit's Tatum Bell and Kevin Smith

After passing on Mendenhall in the first round of the 2008 draft, Lions GM Matt Millen caught a break when Smith was still available on Day 2. Smith was a workhorse in college and is now the most talented back on the Lions. He likely will start. The question mark is Bell, who surprisingly was re-signed by the Lions this offseason. He is not physical and is injury-prone. For this duo to have success, Bell will need to stay healthy.

Chicago's Cedric Benson and Matt Forte

Ever since the Bears traded veteran Thomas Jones, they have been trying to fill that spot. Benson has yet to live up to expectations, and his offseason problems don't help. Last year, Chicago took Garrett Wolfe and followed that with the selection of Forte this year. Wolfe and Forte do not possess the physical tools to ever be "the guy." Throw in veteran Adrian Peterson, and the Bears are doing nothing more than stockpiling bodies at the position right now. The Bears are not building a duo. They are throwing darts at the position, which will mean a different body as the lead back every week.


Carolina's DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart

Maybe this isn't the worst of duos, but it is one that makes you scratch your head. Surprisingly, the Panthers have earned a free pass for taking a running back in Round 1 two of the past three years despite giving a long-term deal to veteran DeShaun Foster (who is no longer with the team). It's funny, but the way they talk about Stewart sounds similar to the way they talked about Williams when he came out to team with Foster. Time will tell, but the Panthers have yet to find a combination that works as they keep trying to develop a consistent ground game during the John Fox era.

Miami's Ronnie Brown and Ricky Williams

It is hard to grasp why the Miami Dolphins showed no interest in rookie RB Darren McFadden, who clearly was the best player in the 2008 NFL draft. On paper it appears the Dolphins have a RB duo, but the reality is there isn't a stable force as the lead back on this team. Brown is coming off an ACL injury, and Williams is aloof and can't be trusted. Miami wants to have a physical, grind-it-out run offense, but it's hard to count on Brown and Williams to do that. The Dolphins are hoping one back comes through. Two would be a bonus.
 

MarionBarberThe4th

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,414
Reaction score
5,389
I like Jerious Norwood and Turner.

Norwood will make a perfect compliment to Barber......... on Madden
 

sago1

Active Member
Messages
7,791
Reaction score
0
Don't agree with statement that Julius wasn't given a full chance in Dallas once he got the soft label. On the other hand away from Parcells (and Sparano's) shadow in Dallas, maybe the change of scenary helps Jones but I got to see it to believe it. OTOH, all of us have wondered for last 2 years what happened to JJ. Maybe the mind games Parcells played with the players didn't work/hindered JJ. Hope it works out for JJ but not against the Cowboys.
 

Sonny#9

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,613
Reaction score
64
How do you have 2 backs who have been mediocre #2 backs, at best, in Jones and Duckett, and two backs who have never taken a snap in the NFL over 1000 yrd backs in Portis and Betts? Or a running game that propelled the World Champions in Jacobs and Bradshaw/Ward?

No one can argue with the tandems of Peterson and C. Taylor or F. Taylor and MJD. But the summer before their rookie years, you would have been laughed off the planet had you said MJD would have been better then Reggie Bush. Ryan Grant was on the Giants practice squad. How'd that turn out?

While the potential of these running backs is great (aside for Jones and Duckett, really, that's just pathetic), perhaps we should reserve judgment until they actually play a down, at least in pre-season.
 

tomson75

Brain Dead Shill
Messages
16,720
Reaction score
1
Sonny#9;2104743 said:
How do you have 2 backs who have been mediocre #2 backs, at best, in Jones and Duckett, and two backs who have never taken a snap in the NFL over 1000 yrd backs in Portis and Betts? Or a running game that propelled the World Champions in Jacobs and Bradshaw/Ward?

No one can argue with the tandems of Peterson and C. Taylor or F. Taylor and MJD. But the summer before their rookie years, you would have been laughed off the planet had you said MJD would have been better then Reggie Bush. Ryan Grant was on the Giants practice squad. How'd that turn out?

While the potential of these running backs is great (aside for Jones and Duckett, really, that's just pathetic), perhaps we should reserve judgment until they actually play a down, at least in pre-season.

I hate to say it, but I agree.
 

THUMPER

Papa
Messages
9,522
Reaction score
61
The Jags tandem of F. Taylor and Jones-Drew is the best utilized in the league IMO because they run a true 2-back offense and the two RBs compliment each other very well. I expect them to have another great season running the ball and controlling the clock. If they get consistent performance from their WRs they could be a contender.

The Vikes did a good job with Peterson and C. Taylor but they aren't really a 2-back system as much as they rotated them a lot to get Peterson more playing time as a rookie. I don't expect them to do that as much this year and will instead feature Peterson more with Taylor coming in as needed.

Dallas ran a very good 2-back system last year and it should be better with Felix replacing Julius, because his skillset is a better compliment to Barber's, but there are no guarantees with a rookie so I wouldn't rank them high yet but they do have solid potential to be a top tandem this year.

Parker & Mendenhall are another one with potential but the Stealers haven't run a 2-back system much since Bettis retired so I don't know how this will work there. They do have potential as their styles should compliment each other well so we'll see. The losses on their O-Line will hurt their chances too.

Julius Jones & T.J. Duckett are NOT a top tandem and Seattle will have a tough time running the ball consistently with those two. Still, they have an excellent OL blocking for them (especially on the left side) and Julius has shown some ability in the past so maybe he will shine there like he did here as a rookie but that still remains to be seen. I wish him well.

Atlanta might have something in Turner & Norwood but with a rookie QB and a lot of changes in personnel and systems it will probably not produce much this year. Turner is not a known commodity, having played only spot duty behind LT in San Diego but he has shown some skills and they should have a much better running game this year but I don't see them being one of the top tandems in 2008, maybe in 2009 though.

Just my observations.
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
THUMPER;2104943 said:
The Jags tandem of F. Taylor and Jones-Drew is the best utilized in the league IMO because they run a true 2-back offense and the two RBs compliment each other very well. I expect them to have another great season running the ball and controlling the clock. If they get their QB situation settled and consistent performance from their WRs they could be a contender.

What QB situation do they need to settle? They did give Garrard a lot of money this off season.
 

THUMPER

Papa
Messages
9,522
Reaction score
61
joseephuss;2104955 said:
What QB situation do they need to settle? They did give Garrard a lot of money this off season.

You are right, I forgot how well he played last year. I guess I was more impressed with their running game and overlooked him. :eek:

I fixed it in the original.
 

bootsy

Benched
Messages
892
Reaction score
0
I stopped reading after it said Julius Jones and TJ Duckett as a top duo for running backs.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,982
Reaction score
48,729
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I like the top 4...maybe not in that order.

But, not only should the Seattle tandem not be in the top 5, they should probably be closer to the bottom of the duds list.
Furthermore, I don't even think it'll be Jones and Duckett---it'll be Jones and Morris.

BTW, I think LenDale and Chris Johnson will combine for 2500+ yards rushing receiving....which may not be elite, but is not "dud" either. At this point though, the rookie tandems are pure specualtion. That inlcudes Felix and Mendenhall....though I predict they'll be fine.
 

CrazyCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,287
Reaction score
440
MarionBarberThe4th;2104615 said:
I like Jerious Norwood and Turner.

Norwood will make a perfect compliment to Barber......... on Madden

I agree......this duo has unlimited potential if their line will improve.
 

AtlCB

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,860
Reaction score
110
Sonny#9;2104743 said:
How do you have 2 backs who have been mediocre #2 backs, at best, in Jones and Duckett, and two backs who have never taken a snap in the NFL over 1000 yrd backs in Portis and Betts? Or a running game that propelled the World Champions in Jacobs and Bradshaw/Ward?

No one can argue with the tandems of Peterson and C. Taylor or F. Taylor and MJD. But the summer before their rookie years, you would have been laughed off the planet had you said MJD would have been better then Reggie Bush. Ryan Grant was on the Giants practice squad. How'd that turn out?

While the potential of these running backs is great (aside for Jones and Duckett, really, that's just pathetic), perhaps we should reserve judgment until they actually play a down, at least in pre-season.
The author was talking rating teams with a two back system. Washington runs Clinton Portis about 80% of the time. Although I agree that Betts is a very good back, he isn't a big factor in the offense unless Portis is injured. The Giants should have made the top 5 over Seattle. I don't see how Seattle wasn't near the top of the bust category. Jones hasn't been a factor for years in Dallas and I'm surprised T.J. Duckett is still in the league.
 

Billy Bullocks

Active Member
Messages
4,098
Reaction score
22
I agree that Portis and Betts definately should be above Duckett and Jones.

As much as I hate Portis, he's a real good back when he's healthy. And I've always liked Betts, even though he plays for the Skins (sorry).
 
Top