An unbiased look at it...
2016
Ezekiel Elliott - Stud. Would love to take a nap with my head on his chest.
Jaylon Smith - Just a guy. Don't know if he can ever be more than that with drop foot.
Maliek Collins - Regressed. Could just be a depth player.
Charles Tapper - Always injured. Done little of note.
Dak Prescott - Bad QB. Wasting time.
Anthony Brown - Regressed. Depth player.
Kavon Frazier - Special teams demon and a pretty nice in the box S in a pass happy era. Means he's limited.
Darius Jackson - Cut
Rico Gathers - Has done nothing yet.
Overall: A stud RB and a few backup types who could end up being more. A QB not good enough that the team will waste years trying to build around.
2017
Taco Charlton - Quiet rookie year. Don't know yet.
Chidobe Awuzie - Looks legit.
Jourdan Lewis - Looks legit.
Ryan Switzer - Promising returner. Don't know about WR yet.
Xavier Woods - Maybe something here but looks like a depth player.
Marquez White - Practice squad.
Joey Ivie - Cut. Out of the league.
Noah Brown - Bottom of the roster blocker for the most part. Developmental player.
Jordan Carrell - Cut. Out of the league.
Overall: Less heralded than 2016 but has a good chance of landing more quality starters, IMO. Jury's still out of course.
--
There you go,
@Wood
Will 1 You 0, I guess.