The case of Hamlin

Mr Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,612
Reaction score
32,654
1:05 PM Thu, Apr 10, 2008 | Permalink | Yahoo! Buzz
Albert Breer E-mail News tips
We're closing in on two months since the Cowboys slapped the franchise tag on Ken Hamlin.

Does that mean a long-term deal won't be reached? No. But as time passes, it becomes harder and harder to be optimistic of that happening.

Just the other day, Jets safety Kerry Rhodes reached a five-year, $33.5 million accord with New York, with $20 million of that guaranteed. That's on the heels of Bob Sanders getting $37.5 million, and about $20 million guaranteed on a five-year deal from Indy.

Now, to be clear, the feeling here is that Bob Sanders -- the 2007 Defensive Player of the Year -- is the best safety in the game, and has been for a couple years. Rhodes is right there with him, and has probably been the Jets' best player over the last two years, one of which was a playoff season.

Is Hamlin in that class? You could say he isn't. But then, the Cowboys could have a hard time arguing that with the Pro Bowler's reps, since they put the franchise tag on him, which designates him to be paid among the top five at his position.

Further complicating matters are the deals copped by new Viking Madieu Williams (six years, $33 million) and Raider Gibril Wilson (six years, $39 million) this offseason.

The bottom line is that it won't be easy to get a deal done. The Cowboys would have to spend big, and that's with guys like Terence Newman and DeMarcus Ware in the running for bank-breaking bonanzas.

Here's one thing we are hearing that may be relevant over the next few weeks -- The Cowboys like Miami S Kenny Phillips, who should be there for the taking at the end of Round 1. I believe they are correct to like him, and not just because of the lineage at his position at "The U" (Ed Reed, Sean Taylor, Brandon Meriweather). The kid can play.

Therein lies a possible solution. Draft Phillips, and sign Hamlin to the tender, with a guarantee he won't be franchised again. Then, use Phillips in sub packages as a rookie and groom him to take over in 2009.

That way, the Cowboys save money at the position, and secure their future back there.

This isn't in any way saying Hamlin shouldn't be part of Dallas' future. Nor is their any guarantee that he won't hold out into training camp. It's just that there's only so much money to go around and, right now, the cash might not be there to get a deal with Hamlin done.
 
Messages
464
Reaction score
5
I like the idea of drafting Phillips. And then rotating him, Roy, and Ken throughout the year. Then after the season we can get rid of the weak link (most likely Roy).

But wasn't there talk during the owner's meetings that they were working on a long term deal with Hamilin?
 

DasTex

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,647
Reaction score
4,859
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Well if Hamlin wants top 5 money, let him walk. He's ALOT better than what we've had since Woody left, but he's not one of the best in the NFL.
 

BouncingCheese

Stay out of my Bidness
Messages
1,704
Reaction score
0
CowboysNumeroUno;2031129 said:
I like the idea of drafting Phillips. And then rotating him, Roy, and Ken throughout the year. Then after the season we can get rid of the weak link (most likely Roy).

But wasn't there talk during the owner's meetings that they were working on a long term deal with Hamlin?

AMEN brother! Hamlin is better fit at the SS position anyway; he is strong but he is still fast enough and has adequate enough skills to cover (though not all of the time) receivers, and he was a vocal leader for the Seahawks' defense.
Roy Kool-aid drinkers have nothing to fall back on after this past season, he was atrocious and the weight he lost as well as the Schemes created by Phillips and the D staff still showed Roy's weaknesses in coverage. I'm not 100 percent sold on Kenny Phillips but I think Roy needs to go. Any team with a competent coaching staff and a good TE can eat us alive by moving the TE into coverage against Roy.
 

ABQcowboyJR

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,424
Reaction score
494
I'm still very optimistic about Watkins. Not so much in favor of drafting a guy at safety. In my eyes Hamlin was never a long term cowboy but rather a quick fix. I do not think that he deserves top five money. I hope we let him hit the road next year.
 

burmafrd

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,820
Reaction score
3,379
And WHAT has watkins done to make ANYONE think he is the answer?
 
Top