The proactive cap move a great FO would make

As the Cowboys front office drags the Micah Parsons contract negotiations on in their usual wasteful manner, I am reminded of what a great FO would be doing now.

Not only would they already have signed Parsons to free up more cap space to sign other impactful players; they should also start negotiations to extend a new contract for the next best player on this roster: TYLER SMITH.

Why sign Smith now? He has another year on his rookie deal. Here are the reasons:
  • By extending him now, they can lock up TS at 2025 prices, saving future money and cap space. What Smith is worth now will be way cheaper than next year.
  • Smith is 23. Locking him up now ensures he’s here for the duration of his best years.
  • Smith and his agent (like most NFL players and agents) usually like early contract extensions because it protects and guarantees the player a good payday before a potential injury could end a career.
  • Finally - if the Cowboys wait again, it will not only cost more, but further hamstring their cap flexibility in the future.
Tyler Smith is the second most talented player on this team. Get him extended now. It makes sense. Which is why it probably won’t happen here.
Well done !

The only time in recent history we’ve resigned a star early was Elliott. Only cause he threatened not to play and were worried the impact it would make on our QB while in negotiations for him.

The bottomline is we are a Reactive FO not Proactive . Why, it isn’t clear.
 
As the Cowboys front office drags the Micah Parsons contract negotiations on in their usual wasteful manner, I am reminded of what a great FO would be doing now.

Not only would they already have signed Parsons to free up more cap space to sign other impactful players; they should also start negotiations to extend a new contract for the next best player on this roster: TYLER SMITH.

Why sign Smith now? He has another year on his rookie deal. Here are the reasons:
  • By extending him now, they can lock up TS at 2025 prices, saving future money and cap space. What Smith is worth now will be way cheaper than next year.
  • Smith is 23. Locking him up now ensures he’s here for the duration of his best years.
  • Smith and his agent (like most NFL players and agents) usually like early contract extensions because it protects and guarantees the player a good payday before a potential injury could end a career.
  • Finally - if the Cowboys wait again, it will not only cost more, but further hamstring their cap flexibility in the future.
Tyler Smith is the second most talented player on this team. Get him extended now. It makes sense. Which is why it probably won’t happen here.
We got amateurs running the team Bob.
You are asking too much of them.
 
Bob, are you an NFL owner, employed as a NFL coach, consultant, mentor, or anything? Do you, or anyone on this forum, think you know better than the people that are an owner or employed know? The things that make me say Hmm.
Alright Now?????
 
Bob, are you an NFL owner, employed as a NFL coach, consultant, mentor, or anything? Do you, or anyone on this forum, think you know better than the people that are an owner or employed know? The things that make me say Hmm.
I've never understood this argument. Just because there are NFL guys who do this for a living doesn't mean they always make the right moves or even mostly make the right moves. In fact most GMs and HCs are fired and replaced every 2-4 years which means aren't happy with their progress the majority of the time.

There was a GM in 2022 who thought he should give up 6 draft picks to go get Russell Wilson. Another GM though it would be a good idea to trade 6 draft picks for Deshaun Watson and give him a fully guaranteed salary. Jerry Jones himself thought it was a brilliant move to go get Roy Williams for a 1st, 3rd, and 6th rounder. There are no shortages of idiotic moves by NFL franchises, so yes sometimes the fans do know better than the NFL guys.

Having the thought process of 'just let the NFL guys do their jobs' is absolutely insane, and in fact it's a dangerous philosophy to have in life if it transfers over to other professions.
 
IMO with the cap rising higher and higher each year, agents don't have to really concede too many demands for the star players.
Up 30mil one year, 20 the next etc... Asking to reset the market for a player near the top of the market isn't crazy these days. It's no longer the flat cap or negative cap from 3-5 years ago.

Otherwords, the Front office has to know the deal the agent will want will be a resetting deal, more times than not when dealing with a player in the ~ top 5 in their position.
Parsons falls into that, Smith falls into that, CDL falls into that.
The market is set at guard. Landon Dickerson 21mil AAV. It just comes down to the player/agent seeing if they wait a year could they squeeze a few more million on the AAV.
If the front office gave Smith 21.5mil AAV, with 12-13mil per year in total guarantees(4 or 5 years) then I think they could get Smith at the table for the final touches.

Maybe Smith is betting on himself to wait another year, see if 23-25mil aav is realistic. Maybe he's willing to sign for 21mil to ensure he got his generational payday in case he gets injured bad this year. A lot off variables.

However, I'm not sure if there has been any reports that the FO is even in talks with his agent. Or are they on a one track mind of Parsons first, then Smith, with the thought of Parsons not till June-August?
 

The proactive cap move a great FO would make​

Let me stop you right there Bob. They would need to know the meaning of the words proactive and great first,

That's not fair....they watched Jimmy operate.
 
As the Cowboys front office drags the Micah Parsons contract negotiations on in their usual wasteful manner, I am reminded of what a great FO would be doing now.

Not only would they already have signed Parsons to free up more cap space to sign other impactful players; they should also start negotiations to extend a new contract for the next best player on this roster: TYLER SMITH.

Why sign Smith now? He has another year on his rookie deal. Here are the reasons:
  • By extending him now, they can lock up TS at 2025 prices, saving future money and cap space. What Smith is worth now will be way cheaper than next year.
  • Smith is 23. Locking him up now ensures he’s here for the duration of his best years.
  • Smith and his agent (like most NFL players and agents) usually like early contract extensions because it protects and guarantees the player a good payday before a potential injury could end a career.
  • Finally - if the Cowboys wait again, it will not only cost more, but further hamstring their cap flexibility in the future.
Tyler Smith is the second most talented player on this team. Get him extended now. It makes sense. Which is why it probably won’t happen here.
There’s a big giant fallacyin your theory. Smith has an agent and that agent isn’t stupid. Both Smith and the agent know he’s going have the negotiating power to be able to smash the current highest paid guard… maybe even demand a little more considering he can perform at a high level as a tackle in a pinch. They can also project what that number will be next year with a fair amount of accuracy. I’m sure Smith’s agent would love to sign him a year early… that’s more potential money when his 3rd contract comes up. But you can bet he’s not going to unless it’s at the 25-26 million he’s most likely projected to be able to command next season. There just isn’t any incentive to do so otherwise. In the end all you’re accomplishing is throwing away the last year of his rookie contract!
 
There’s a big giant fallacyin your theory. Smith has an agent and that agent isn’t stupid. Both Smith and the agent know he’s going have the negotiating power to be able to smash the current highest paid guard… maybe even demand a little more considering he can perform at a high level as a tackle in a pinch. They can also project what that number will be next year with a fair amount of accuracy. I’m sure Smith’s agent would love to sign him a year early… that’s more potential money when his 3rd contract comes up. But you can bet he’s not going to unless it’s at the 25-26 million he’s most likely projected to be able to command next season. There just isn’t any incentive to do so otherwise. In the end all you’re accomplishing is throwing away the last year of his rookie contract!
Sort of...but the Cowboys have a 5th year option + 2 franchise tags in their back pocket if they really need to use them. The 5th year option for Smith would be right at $21M. I agree the Cowboys would still have to pay a premium to lock up Smith this year, but $25-26M feels a little high. I would think you're still around Trey Smith money at $23M at most.
 
As the Cowboys front office drags the Micah Parsons contract negotiations on in their usual wasteful manner, I am reminded of what a great FO would be doing now.

Not only would they already have signed Parsons to free up more cap space to sign other impactful players; they should also start negotiations to extend a new contract for the next best player on this roster: TYLER SMITH.

Why sign Smith now? He has another year on his rookie deal. Here are the reasons:
  • By extending him now, they can lock up TS at 2025 prices, saving future money and cap space. What Smith is worth now will be way cheaper than next year.
  • Smith is 23. Locking him up now ensures he’s here for the duration of his best years.
  • Smith and his agent (like most NFL players and agents) usually like early contract extensions because it protects and guarantees the player a good payday before a potential injury could end a career.
  • Finally - if the Cowboys wait again, it will not only cost more, but further hamstring their cap flexibility in the future.
Tyler Smith is the second most talented player on this team. Get him extended now. It makes sense. Which is why it probably won’t happen here.
but what about the drama? what about the media attention? what about everyone just like now going what's happening? where would Jerry get all the attention? there are jerseys to sell, there is branding and marketing to be done....football is secondary to all of it. Cowboys are a business first and foremost. its not about winning. its about money and profits and value.
 
There’s a big giant fallacyin your theory. Smith has an agent and that agent isn’t stupid. Both Smith and the agent know he’s going have the negotiating power to be able to smash the current highest paid guard… maybe even demand a little more considering he can perform at a high level as a tackle in a pinch. They can also project what that number will be next year with a fair amount of accuracy. I’m sure Smith’s agent would love to sign him a year early… that’s more potential money when his 3rd contract comes up. But you can bet he’s not going to unless it’s at the 25-26 million he’s most likely projected to be able to command next season. There just isn’t any incentive to do so otherwise. In the end all you’re accomplishing is throwing away the last year of his rookie contract!
Good points. But here’s where I disagree:
  • Agents and players are usually open to signing an extension early at market value because it guarantees a great payday NOW before an injury.
  • The key being market value as of NOW. Obviously market prices go up with time so if a player can get a 4-5 year extension at age 23 like Tyler Smith, he would still be in his prime at 27 or 28 for another deal.
  • Extending players early you already know you want to keep is usually a good move. It’s not good with guys you still aren’t sure about.
Aren’t we already convinced Tyler Smith is a great player? Locking him in now is a good financial move however you slice it.
And do we honestly believe Smith’s agent wouldn’t want to listen?

In the last decade the Cowboys did an early extension 3 times, and two of them were great financial moves- Tyron Smith, Travis Frederick and Zeke. The Zeke deal was a bad one but the other two were excellent.
 
I think fans are the ones who care about getting these players at today's prices. I don't think 2025 prices are all that relevant for owners because they know that the cap is going to continue to go up and so will the prices. It's just part of the business.

Fans may be thinking, hey, we could have gotten Parsons for $35 million APY instead of $40 million APY if we'd renewed him last year, but I really don't think owners believe that is all that relevant.

I mean, Cleveland (OK, not exactly the bastion of cap management) extended Myles Garrett this offseason, but could have done it last year to avoid all the trade talk and save money. Couldn't we say the same about Justin Jefferson, paid in his fifth year just like Lamb, or JaMarr Chase this year?

It seems to be common business to take the fifth-year option on top players and then negotiate a deal instead of striking a new deal in their fourth year. There are some exceptions to that, of course, but what the Cowboys do is a common practice with first-round successes.
Most of the people on here don't follow what other franchises do. They just follow the Cowboys, disparage everything they do, and call them a circus. They have no idea what goes on around the rest of the NFL.
 
But but but we are always being told that we pay players later than other teams. Horn they both be true? Please make it stop…
The Cowboys for years have liked to negotiate on a deadline because they think it makes both sides work harder to get the job done instead of slow-playing it to see if the other side budges. But a lot of teams wait until the fifth-year option year to negotiate a new contract. Can't blame them in a sense. Football is a high-injury sport, so why guarantee a player more money until you have to? The fifth-year option is usually so high that it becomes advantageous to the team costwise to do a long-term deal then.
 
As the Cowboys front office drags the Micah Parsons contract negotiations on in their usual wasteful manner, I am reminded of what a great FO would be doing now.

Not only would they already have signed Parsons to free up more cap space to sign other impactful players; they should also start negotiations to extend a new contract for the next best player on this roster: TYLER SMITH.

Why sign Smith now? He has another year on his rookie deal. Here are the reasons:
  • By extending him now, they can lock up TS at 2025 prices, saving future money and cap space. What Smith is worth now will be way cheaper than next year.
  • Smith is 23. Locking him up now ensures he’s here for the duration of his best years.
  • Smith and his agent (like most NFL players and agents) usually like early contract extensions because it protects and guarantees the player a good payday before a potential injury could end a career.
  • Finally - if the Cowboys wait again, it will not only cost more, but further hamstring their cap flexibility in the future.
Tyler Smith is the second most talented player on this team. Get him extended now. It makes sense. Which is why it probably won’t happen here.
Totally agree. It’s all about being decisive. If you aren’t gonna extend a guy you trade him with one year left so he has value. If he’s part of your plan, then you extend him at first chance. It’s cheaper, it gets contract issues settled quickly without all the drama in the media. And it shows a commitment to winning and a plan. You can’t wing decisions on a roster. The key to managing the cap is a plan and every contract effects another. The most frustrating thing with Jerry is there is no plan.
 
The Cowboys for years have liked to negotiate on a deadline because they think it makes both sides work harder to get the job done instead of slow-playing it to see if the other side budges. But a lot of teams wait until the fifth-year option year to negotiate a new contract. Can't blame them in a sense. Football is a high-injury sport, so why guarantee a player more money until you have to? The fifth-year option is usually so high that it becomes advantageous to the team costwise to do a long-term deal then.
The biggest thing is certain players you aren’t letting get away. Others you’d keep at the right price. And others you just don’t see as worth a srcond contract. If you start early you get those guys you aren’t letting get away done. You know where you at with the guys that only at the right price so you can trade them if it looks like they are gonna be out of your range. The ones you don’t want to keep anyway might have some value with someone else. If not no loss
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
464,576
Messages
13,819,680
Members
23,780
Latest member
HoppleSopple
Back
Top